What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Eels Salary Cap Mk V

eels_fan

First Grade
Messages
7,584
No one. I'd say this ends the possibility of an appeal. The whole plea by Ray to the minister this morning was they needed to be sacked for considering an appeal
 
Messages
11,677
I don't think Sharpe would have sent out that letter if it meant the end of an appeal.

Making it look like you backed the idea doesn't really do anything once you're gone, so there's no point in him sending it out just to save face, especially if it means the end of the only thing left he could do to help the Club.

It just doesn't make sense - or am I missing something?
 

eels_fan

First Grade
Messages
7,584
With the entire board wiped out next week, who is going to argue the appeal? The administrators appointed by the NRL? They can't appeal their own judgement..
 
Messages
11,677
I don't know. To my uninformed eyes there seems to be no one left but if that's true then it means Sharpe's letter makes no sense.

Perhaps someone might know who could possibly remain to move the appeal forward.

Also, it will be a government appointed administrator, not an NRL appointed one.
 
Messages
15,412
I don't think Sharpe would have sent out that letter if it meant the end of an appeal.

Making it look like you backed the idea doesn't really do anything once you're gone, so there's no point in him sending it out just to save face, especially if it means the end of the only thing left he could do to help the Club.

It just doesn't make sense - or am I missing something?
You make sense (who would have thought I would have uttered those lines 12 years ago)

This only works if the appeal is lodged, to be heard by the independent appeals committee without need for representation.
 

Delboy

First Grade
Messages
7,551
Funnily enough I heard from someone a week or so ago, that Sharp, Serrao and Gerrard were trying to push reform and accept the decision , with the proviso that they saw the full transcript that the NRL used against them. The remaininv board members wanted to continue the action against the NRL without compromise

Sharp always seemed To want club to go forward, perhaps he surrounded himself with selfish and egotistical Pelicans, that coupled with the decision to appoint DA to his role really backfired and nailed him to the mast so to speak

The unicorn in me wants to think that Sharp was a bit of a catalyst for the move from Troy Grant, doesn't matter I guess as long as the outcome strengthens the club
 

forward pass

Coach
Messages
10,209
I don't know. To my uninformed eyes there seems to be no one left but if that's true then it means Sharpe's letter makes no sense.

Perhaps someone might know who could possibly remain to move the appeal forward.

Also, it will be a government appointed administrator, not an NRL appointed one.

Good post - except it is Sharp not Sharpe.
 

T-Boon

Coach
Messages
15,907
I don't have any evidence, but i bet someone does. It will come out one day i bet. Once he upsets the media they will find it all.

Greenberg himself confirmed that he and his friend Seward had a conversation about "how to do TPA's" just before Seward got started with doing TPA's at Parramatta.
Combine this with the refusal of the NRL to release the transcript of interview.
This stuff is pretty circumstantial but warrants the speculation... these two should be questioned (by someone independent) about what they discussed and when.
 

Bigfella

Coach
Messages
10,102
Funnily enough I heard from someone a week or so ago, that Sharp, Serrao and Gerrard were trying to push reform and accept the decision , with the proviso that they saw the full transcript that the NRL used against them. The remaininv board members wanted to continue the action against the NRL without compromise

Sharp always seemed To want club to go forward, perhaps he surrounded himself with selfish and egotistical Pelicans, that coupled with the decision to appoint DA to his role really backfired and nailed him to the mast so to speak

The unicorn in me wants to think that Sharp was a bit of a catalyst for the move from Troy Grant, doesn't matter I guess as long as the outcome strengthens the club

You were right all along.

Sharp was the best thing that happened to this club
 

BoneyBlake17

Juniors
Messages
885
Funnily enough I heard from someone a week or so ago, that Sharp, Serrao and Gerrard were trying to push reform and accept the decision , with the proviso that they saw the full transcript that the NRL used against them. The remaininv board members wanted to continue the action against the NRL without compromise

Sharp always seemed To want club to go forward, perhaps he surrounded himself with selfish and egotistical Pelicans, that coupled with the decision to appoint DA to his role really backfired and nailed him to the mast so to speak

The unicorn in me wants to think that Sharp was a bit of a catalyst for the move from Troy Grant, doesn't matter I guess as long as the outcome strengthens the club
Yep paul garrard and tanya gadiel have NFI typical politicians the sooner them and cordwell are kicked out the better. The nrl should have the deregistered the lot of them.

There the ones causing the trouble atm not the G05
 
Messages
17,650
Funnily enough I heard from someone a week or so ago, that Sharp, Serrao and Gerrard were trying to push reform and accept the decision , with the proviso that they saw the full transcript that the NRL used against them. The remaininv board members wanted to continue the action against the NRL without compromise

Sharp always seemed To want club to go forward, perhaps he surrounded himself with selfish and egotistical Pelicans, that coupled with the decision to appoint DA to his role really backfired and nailed him to the mast so to speak

The unicorn in me wants to think that Sharp was a bit of a catalyst for the move from Troy Grant, doesn't matter I guess as long as the outcome strengthens the club

Really? They were trying to push for reform were they? Only after they saw the NRL's full transcript? LOL is that the line the they are going peddle out.

On a separate note, I also like the fact that the plumber saw it in our best interests "to hand over to the government" in heart felt letter that he wrote.... OFCOURSE THIS WAS ONLY AFTER THE GOVERNMENT SAID THEY'D TAKE CONTROL 6 HOURS EARLIER .... LOL

good riddance to the plumber and to the worst and most embarrasing management to have ever managed any sporting club. Now Looking forward to their memberships being cancelled.
 

El Diablo

Post Whore
Messages
94,107
DT have gone to RL hater Steve Allen. the clown who always says the NRL will get f**k all for TV rights

http://www.dailytelegraph.com.au/sp...s/news-story/d58085fe7872aca898cc2bbc60d576f4

Why Steve Sharp had to quit Parramatta Eels
d58085fe7872aca898cc2bbc60d576f4

DAVID RICCIO, The Daily Telegraph
July 16, 2016 10:34pm

d58085fe7872aca898cc2bbc60d576f4

THIS is the reason why desperate Parramatta chairman Steve Sharp has called on NSW deputy premier Troy Grant to take control of the embattled NRL club.

In a bombshell statement, Sharp pleaded with the government to put the club into administration then start fresh with a new board.

The development came as Steve Allen, one of Australia’s leading media analysts, responsible for orchestrating multimillion-dollar sponsorship deals, including aligning Kia Motors with the Australian Open Tennis tournament, has declared the Eels as “the most embarrassing club in Australian sport.”

“I can’t think of anyone who has imploded like this,’’ Allen said.

“At a moment in time, other teams have imploded, but never from the first kick of the season until now. Every week there’s a new revelation and none of it is good.

“There’s been nothing as sustained as this. Every week brings a new episode of a train wreck. The problem is, it’s rotten at both ends. We’ve never seen that before. You couldn’t get a worse report card for the board. And to follow that, now we’ve got nothing but trouble with all their stars.’’

In a major development to the Eels’ ever-evolving crisis, Grant told 2GB radio that he had the legislative powers to turf the entire Parramatta board.

“As the minister I don’t have any fear or favour in acting in the best interests of the Parramatta Leagues Club members and or ultimately the NRL footy club,’’ Grant said.

PARRA-LYSED BRAND

Allen, the chief executive of Fusion strategy and former managing director of Dentsu’s Australian media buying agency AIS Media, said his job as a strategist was to analyse the value of a client’s company or brand.

“The Parramatta Eels is easy, there’s no value,’’ Allen said.

“There is intrinsic value, but there is no value right now.

“The intrinsic value is gambling that it’s going to come good and the team is going to play well sometime in the future. That’s all that is left now, intrinsic value.’’

Asked why he believed major jersey sponsor Dyldam stuck with the Eels, Allen replied: “Well, a lot of people once they’ve made a decision never want to admit that you got it wrong.

“There’s a huge resistance to make the call, ‘we simply stuffed up — we got it wrong’.’’

EELS TARNISH ORIGIN

The day before State of Origin III last Wednesday, damaging headlines emerged that Eels star Corey Norman had sent a sexually explicit video to other NRL players which also included vision of an elderly man apparently snorting cocaine.

On game day, it was the lead news item on almost every major news bulletin, robbing the NRL of priceless positive PR ahead of the final Origin match of the series.

“Origin is the showpiece,’’ Allen said.

“It certainly tarnished the overall image of NRL, therefore whether its State of Origin or whether it's the code, it’s been tarnished.

“It therefore makes it more difficult for corporates to consider. It makes it more difficult for families to consider and therefore viewers.

“All these sports deals for television, whether its pay-TV or free-to-air, they’re all written on the back of audiences — that’s the currency.

“So if audiences drop because of all the turmoil of one team or a number of teams, bringing the overall code into ill-repute, then it will count somewhere in the future.’’

ADVICE FOR FREE

Asked what he would tell the Eels, should they approach him for advice, Allen said simply: The board has to change.

“They have to put in place a new clean board,’’ Allen said.

“Because I think some of what is now happening with the players stems from that.

“If the players know that there’s chaos in the boardroom and there’s all kinds of alleged deals going on, then why would they (players) be disciplined?

“Why wouldn’t they (players) say; ‘well, if the fat cats are doing things that aren’t quite proper, why the hell shouldn’t we?’

“So, if they came to me or an advertiser came to me, the very first thing I’d say is, until a clean sweep of the board occurs and they get a chief executive that’s cleaner than clean, the problem will not go away.’’

THE SHARKS MODEL

Allen pointed to the Cronulla Sharks’ rebuild following the 2014 ASADA scandal as the copybook version of how the Eels can save themselves.

The Sharks overhauled their dysfunctional board by replacing them with directors with minimal ties to the club or rugby league who also boast a portfolio of rich business acumen.

“Absolutely the Sharks have shown how it’s done, no question,’’ Allen said.

“But even with the Sharks, their board was nowhere near as tarnished as this board.

“They had some problems at board level, but this is just rotten at the top.

“Maybe there is an honest one (at the Eels), but you can’t see it. Standing on their digs is the craziest thing. They’re not analysing what’s in front of the club and they’re not doing the right thing for the club.’’
 

Latest posts

Top