What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Eels Team vs Bulldogs - Round 9.

Poupou Escobar

Post Whore
Messages
92,147
Yes Kearneys record speaks for itself.

A season and a half isn't long enough for his skill or lack thereof to come out. Look at Daniel Anderson - after a season we all thought he was a world beater. Likewise with Hagan and Stuart.

What do you think of Mal Meninga's record as Origin coach?
 

ParraAds

Juniors
Messages
1,694
A season and a half isn't long enough for his skill or lack thereof to come out. Look at Daniel Anderson - after a season we all thought he was a world beater. Likewise with Hagan and Stuart.

What do you think of Mal Meninga's record as Origin coach?

So you're now comparing a 3 game rep season against a 24 game NRL season? :lol:

Whatever way you look at it Kearney's record is diabolical... but the spin doctors around here will do all they can to convince you otherwise.
 

Twizzle

Administrator
Staff member
Messages
153,847
I reckon if we start be rumour that he could be OK for this weekend it'll will be in the Telecrap tomorrow
 

eloquentEEL

First Grade
Messages
8,065
Just saw a replay of his try. F'ing Loltzen gets up holding Blair's leg, with a completely unnecessary leg pull. Would have loved to see him penalised for it and Burt given another kick at goal for the win.
 

oldmancraigy

Coach
Messages
11,969
Just saw a replay of his try. F'ing Loltzen gets up holding Blair's leg, with a completely unnecessary leg pull. Would have loved to see him penalised for it and Burt given another kick at goal for the win.

Yeh I was screaming penalty try at the time. My Tigers mate was all :crazy:
 

lingard

Coach
Messages
11,436
Then the point he made is pointless.

You stick a halfback on the bench for a couple of reasons:

1. He is versatile
2. He isn't versatile but the starting halfback is
3. To keep him out of the early exchanges

How common this ploy is is irrelevant. There are very few halfbacks as defensively poor as Chris Sandow, so it can be a good move to use him differently to most halfbacks.

So while he's coming back from a week off and his confidence might be shaky, he can come off the bench like a rookie (whose confidence might also be shaky).

I reckon it could be a good move this week. Don't be so quick to put shit on every decision the coach makes. He knows his players better than you do.

Why don't you criticise Hasler for playing that nuffy Kris Keating at halfback again? They've lost their last three matches in a row with him there.


Sung to the tune of 'The Littlest Hobo' - a 1960`s television show:

Arguing my way from town to town,
Sometimes I think I`ll settle down,
But I know I`d hunger for an argument,
Arguing`s the only life for me.

Ar-gu-ing; the forum`s my friend,
I`m arguing along the thread without end.
dum dum; dum dum.
 

Suitman

Post Whore
Messages
56,114
Sung to the tune of 'The Littlest Hobo' - a 1960`s television show:

Arguing my way from town to town,
Sometimes I think I`ll settle down,
But I know I`d hunger for an argument,
Arguing`s the only life for me.

Ar-gu-ing; the forum`s my friend,
I`m arguing along the thread without end.
dum dum; dum dum.

parra pete and Casper finally have some competition. :sarcasm:

Suity
 

Poupou Escobar

Post Whore
Messages
92,147
So you're now comparing a 3 game rep season against a 24 game NRL season? :lol:

Mate you're the one trying to draw concusions from a coach with less than a season and a half worth of stats under his belt.

Whatever way you look at it Kearney's record is diabolical... but the spin doctors around here will do all they can to convince you otherwise.

I put it to you that your sample size determination is deliberately flawed because you're trying to support your agenda.

A season and a bit isn't long enough to determine anything about an NRL coach, which is why they sign three year contracts.
 

Casper The Ghost

First Grade
Messages
9,924
Mate you're the one trying to draw concusions from a coach with less than a season and a half worth of stats under his belt.



I put it to you that your sample size determination is deliberately flawed because you're trying to support your agenda.

A season and a bit isn't long enough to determine anything about an NRL coach, which is why they sign three year contracts.

Daniel Anderson wanted a contract extension.
This can be taken that he had long term plans for our squad/club as well.
So why was he booted then?
It's clear, plans to get rid of him began during 2009, were stalled during the golden run and reignited early 2010 season.
 

Poupou Escobar

Post Whore
Messages
92,147
So we hired an unproven rookie to revamp the whole club?

Well our last two coaches proved they couldn't. There are only a couple of coaches who have proved they can turn a club around. Why not take the risk on an unknown? What was the alternative?

Life's full of certainty.
 

Latest posts

Top