Finch

[Prodigal Eel]

I hope where ever he goes he has a successful carrer!!!!
I put myself in his shoes, and think of how i would feel being treated the same way and ill feel gutted!

Hope if he does come here...we treat him with respect and give him a fair go (which dosent mean 1 game)

 

[Utey]

I hope where ever he goes he has a successful carrer!!!!
I put myself in his shoes, and think of how i would feel being treated the same way and ill feel gutted!

Hope if he does come here...we treat him with respect and give him a fair go (which dosent mean 1 game)

also well said!

 

[mickdo]

Hey funboys, get a room!

 

[ParraDude_Jay]

Open your eyes Eela, Finch is the worst half in the NRL. He does NOTHING right and then blames his team mates for it, I don't want to see that happening here.

You can read him like a book, 5th tackle play inside the opponents 50 is a bomb, in his own half it's a long kick. That's all he does, his running game is poor and his passing is equal to it. He offers nothing, he is a solid defender and that's about as much praise as I have for him. But for that solid defence, we also gain a sook, untalented hack who has brought shame on the Roosters a few times and there's no reason he won't do that here.

If he signs, so be it there's nothing any of us can do. He better perform though, or I'm sure there'll be a few people putting their hands up to take over the "FOFF" from the Roosters fans.

 

[lucablight]

Eelavation is right! We're all whinging for nothing because we enjoy it not because there's any valid reason behind it.

 

[Maroubra Eel]

I love it.

 

[Stagger eel]

Open your eyes Eela, Finch is the worst half in the NRL. He does NOTHING right and then blames his team mates for it, I don't want to see that happening here.

You can read him like a book, 5th tackle play inside the opponents 50 is a bomb, in his own half it's a long kick. That's all he does, his running game is poor and his passing is equal to it. He offers nothing, he is a solid defender and that's about as much praise as I have for him. But for that solid defence, we also gain a sook, untalented hack who has brought shame on the Roosters a few times and there's no reason he won't do that here.

If he signs, so be it there's nothing any of us can do. He better perform though, or I'm sure there'll be a few people putting their hands up to take over the "FOFF" from the Roosters fans.

well you obviously predicted that Dykes would be the worst five-eight in 2002, a season after he won Dally M five-eight of the year..

personally, I'll reserve my judgement under a different club with a different regime.

 

[ParraDude_Jay]

He's failed at two very different clubs, and both of those clubs' fans hate him, I thought that was enough to judge him on.

 

[lucablight]

well you obviously predicted that Dykes would be the worst five-eight in 2002, a season after he won Dally M five-eight of the year..

personally, I'll reserve my judgement under a different club with a different regime.

I predict Chad Robinson will be the Dally M player of 2007 because obviously everything you have done in the past has no basis upon which to make your predictions.

 

[Stagger eel]

He's failed at two very different clubs, and both of those clubs' fans hate him, I thought that was enough to judge him on.

he was a star at Canberra you only had to remember the reaction of Canberra fans when he left the club,

 

[Stagger eel]

I predict Chad Robinson will be the Dally M player of 2007 because obviously everything you have done in the past has no basis upon which to make your predictions.

you're the one predicting he's going to be a flop for us next year if he signs. not me.

 

[CrazyEel]

Your all bloody whingers

 

[Stagger eel]

Your all bloody whingers

so are you.

 

[strider]

He's failed at two very different clubs, and both of those clubs' fans hate him, I thought that was enough to judge him on.

well fans have generally hated him cos of his emotion, not so much his playing ability .... i'm not keen for him to come, but it won't die if he does

 

[lucablight]

you're the one predicting he's going to be a flop for us next year if he signs. not me.

Why do some players earn higher salaries than others? Why do some players get to play origin and for Australia while others don't? Spectators, Clubs and selectors all make their judgments based on what they've seen a certain player do. Using your logic why don't we just start signing random players without reason because we'll never know how they'll go anyway.

 

[The Colonel]

Meh. As long as he doesn't get the 7 jersey I'll be happy.

 

[Stagger eel]

Why do some players earn higher salaries than others? Why do some players get to play origin and for Australia while others don't? Spectators, Clubs and selectors all make their judgments based on what they've seen a certain player do. Using your logic why don't we just start signing random players without reason because we'll never know how they'll go anyway.

so what are you saying..are you questioning the judgement of those who know the game better than you and I???...

 

[ParraDude_Jay]

he was a star at Canberra you only had to remember the reaction of Canberra fans when he left the club,

they booed him off the field if I recall correctly... compare that to the reception Wiki got when he did almost the same thing

 

[lucablight]

so what are you saying..are you questioning the judgement of those who know the game better than you and I???...

Who might they be?

 

[Suitman]

Meh. As long as he doesn't get the 7 jersey I'll be happy.

I'll be happy if he has the number of the half back in Premier League.

This is a very disappointing development of our recruiting campaign.

In saying that, if he comes, I'll cheer him, 'cause that's what Eels fans do, right?

Suity