What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

forevermakingthreadafterthread

IF THE CLUBS AND PLAYERS CAN BE FINED SO SHOULD THE NRL AND THE REF BOSS AND THE REFS BE FINED TOO


  • Total voters
    14
Status
Not open for further replies.

Clifferd

Coach
Messages
10,805
That's as they hate Souths genius!!!!!!

He didn't have pressure down. He just dropped it and it was short of the line.

He had control of it for the brief moment it touched the ground, whilst at the same time it hit the line. Get an idea
 

foreverinourshadow

First Grade
Messages
9,400
I have woken up with a massive headache today and i have reviewed the posts on here Alien dont take offence mate i said R20 and SSTID are the only two on here with real footy knowledge and i stick to my words on that.Many on here including yourself pick souths sides that i dont agree with and comment on certain players that i dont deem to be 1st grade players.I have found that usually R20 and SSTID are more in line with my views and expectations on here.Alien everyone has their own views mate this was not a personal attack on you personally and i have found that you dont agree with many of my views over the times which is human nature to believe in your views alone,Alien i just agree more so with these two other people"s views on here...Shadow...
 

callmack1

Moderator
Staff member
Messages
12,155
How did the refs give us leg ups? Penalties went your way 4-3.

There were a couple of times you laid on us and Klein put the whistle near his kith but wouldn't blow it.

But overall the referees were fair. They didn't give us leg ups.

I'm sure Callmack you'd agree.
Yep
 

foreverinourshadow

First Grade
Messages
9,400
Shadows most logical choice for our round 2 team::bye bye kelly,clark and tyrrell if madge and the silly souths selectors re-instate these (3) duds for round 2 ile be GOBSMACKED!!!And when reyno returns we should still use the same farah/cook no9 combo again like before i believe it works but i would bench cook and send turner to the bears in the nsw cup where he belongs.And when inglis returns then inglis can return to fullback and aj goes back to his wing position.And when gray comes back he can then take either jennings or talakai"s spot in the centres to partner hunt in the centres i believe. Quote:: AJ needs to lift otherwise when inglis returns otherwise bryson will take his spot on the wing and i believe bryson goodwin is a far far better accomplished seasoned player today than AJ by a country mile AJ usually gets rag dolled unlike bryson goodwin its a fact but i believe the best centre pairing will be gray/goodwin and the wingers should be aj/burns...looking back to 2014 if it was not for the star players such as inglis,the 3 burgi"s and teo,and bully and api and mcqueen and lote and dylan walker (clark and tyrrell and turner would not be wearing a grand final ring and if i may say so how has turner and clark and tyrrell been playing since many of the above star players have since left?only R20 and SSTID know what i am saying.Souths need a clean out immediately its a no brainer but i know many of you still want to play those 2014 premiership ring wearing forward players such as clark,turner and tyrrell because they all have a premiership ring from 2014...Im sorry but your all way off the mark just ask R20 and SSTID but R20 we dont need clark ok please perish the thought see Alien i dont always agree with R20 OK!!!!!...Shadow....
1. AJ
2. Burns
3. Hunt
4. Jennings
5. Goodwin
6. Cody
7. Farah
8. Musgrove
9. Cook
10. G. Burgess
11. Sutton
12. Crichton
13. S. Burgess

14. Turner
15. Rochow
16. T. Burgess
17. Cherrington
 
Last edited:

handyman2190

Bench
Messages
3,750
1. Correct re GI. He had to be pulled off straight away. He was a liability. The trainers had to overrule him.

2. Correct re Goodwin. He did the work for the forwards too with 13 for 113metres. I to,d you about Bryson Shadow. He is getting older and not the quickest but he's still got it.

3. As I said Talakai was all at sea in defence. He isn't confident in his defence and is too slow. He got shown up big time. He ran the ball well but it doesn't cut it. He's best used as a back up back rower off the bench.

4. George should've been there. He may drop the ball but he bends the line. Our completion rate was 88percent tonight but you get nowhere when players like Tyrrell and Clark can't bend the line and get ragdolled.

5. We seem to be in for a long year Shadow. If Madge doesn't make changes ASAP he will lose his job.

6. I agree with all you say except I thought Cody was hot and cold.

7. Kelly isn't a first grade player. He didn't find the grass with his kicks and some of his bombs went nowhere. We lost the territorial advantage and he doesn't guide the side around well. It's sad to say but he seems out of his depth. Farah should go to 7 next week. He finds the grass with his kicks and has some creativity.

8. Robbie was very solid. He did his best behind a poor pack. We could see earlier in the week that Madge named the wrong team Shadow.

9. The 3 you mention, 2 have to be dropped and Turner has to be put back to the bench.

10. Farah to 7. Cook to 9. George, Burns, Crichton and Jennings in.

11. I understand fully Shadow. If Madge doesn't make the changes and put guys on notice the results will keep going against us. Madge could definitely lose his job this season.




Oi Shadow lots at the game are saying the same kind of thing we are saying.

My side for next week Shadow, tell me your thoughts mate:

1. AJ
2. Burns
3, Hunt
4. Jennings
5. Goodwin
6. Cody
7. Farah
8. Musgrove
9. Cook
10. G. Burgess
11. Sutton
12. Crichton
13. S. Burgess (C)


14. Turner
15. Rochow
16. T. Burgess
17. Cherrington


I tend to agree with much of this when i saw the final makeup of the team i was disgusted madge has lost it.
Talakai turner tyrell good luck .
Most knock bryson but he consistently performs and should be in the centres
Turner is too light and gets monstered crighton would be better.
At the end of the day defence wins games and ours was non existent we were playing tip and made them look better than they are.
Im upset and disgusted 13th place and i dont care if its round 1what an excuse u could see from the 7s we had no idea alarm bells should have rung
 

foreverinourshadow

First Grade
Messages
9,400
i know one thing for sure george burgess will be playing in rd2......how plain dumb to leave him out in rd1....souths and madge have lost the plot no contest.........oi madge use my team and r20"s team in rd2 and you might go well mate for crikes sake.....Shadow...
 

Thumper

Juniors
Messages
467
Shadows most logical choice for our round 2 team::bye bye kelly,clark and tyrrell if madge and the silly souths selectors re-instate these (3) duds for round 2 ile be GOBSMACKED!!!And when reyno returns we should still use the same farah/cook no9 combo again like before i believe it works but i would bench cook and send turner to the bears in the nsw cup where he belongs.And when inglis returns then inglis can return to fullback and aj goes back to his wing position.And when gray comes back he can then take either jennings or talakai"s spot in the centres to partner hunt in the centres i believe. Quote:: AJ needs to lift otherwise when inglis returns otherwise bryson will take his spot on the wing and i believe bryson goodwin is a far far better accomplished seasoned player today than AJ by a country mile AJ usually gets rag dolled unlike bryson goodwin its a fact but i believe the best centre pairing will be gray/goodwin and the wingers should be aj/burns...looking back to 2014 if it was not for the star players such as inglis,the 3 burgi"s and teo,and bully and api and mcqueen and lote and dylan walker (clark and tyrrell and turner would not be wearing a grand final ring and if i may say so how has turner and clark and tyrrell been playing since many of the above star players have since left?only R20 and SSTID know what i am saying.Souths need a clean out immediately its a no brainer but i know many of you still want to play those 2014 premiership ring wearing forward players such as clark,turner and tyrrell because they all have a premiership ring from 2014...Im sorry but your all way off the mark just ask R20 and SSTID but R20 we dont need clark ok please perish the thought see Alien i dont always agree with R20 OK!!!!!...Shadow....
1. AJ
2. Burns
3. Hunt
4. Jennings
5. Goodwin
6. Cody
7. Farah
8. Musgrove
9. Cook
10. G. Burgess
11. Sutton
12. Crichton
13. S. Burgess

14. Turner
15. Rochow
16. T. Burgess
17. Cherrington

I think Clark and Tyrell are the worst first graders in the comp. add Kelly to that list also but he's only playing due to injury.
Why have all these young kids If we are not gonnna play them.
Rochow was a passenger last night. I wouldn't have him in.
Pick burns pick Jennings. Chrighton should be there. Give fuimono a game. He lead the 20's for metres gained for the Comp last year.
I wanna see how cam Murray goes in first grade. He's young but he's tough. I'd much rather watch these blokes play make mistakes and learn how to play first grade than watch the same blokes who have played shit for the last 20 months.
 

DiegoNT

First Grade
Messages
9,378
We look like we are falling into the same trap we always do. Replacing Tyrell or clark will do nothing? Who do you replace them with? For the price these guys are reported to be on, you aren't going to get better players. Could try rookies, but that is always a huge gamble. Look at the knights. They've had to clear away duds, and replaced them with youngsters. They aren't tipped to win a game this season. I think we've shown with musgrove that when we have a young guy ready we will play him, but until they are ready it's a gamble. Clark and Tyrrell would be the best value for money players in our squad. Between the 2 of them they'd probably be on half the money George Burgess is on, yet while he languishes in nsw cup, Tyrrell and Clark combined over the 80 minutes to contribute 60 odd good tackles and a a handy 150 metres. We're we need better value for money is our big name players. George and Tom have been poor for years, Walker has to get better now his been upgraded, aj as well, even Sam has to be better. People praising Sam last night must have watched a different game. He made less runs and metres per minute then Tyrrell and Clark, made less tackles total then Clark even though he had more minutes and he came up with 5 missed tackles. This is from our million dollar player. It's easy to kick Tyrrell and Clark, but they are both playing like 150k a year players. Luke Kelly played like a back up half that was both drafted into the squad at the last minute, and drafted into the team at the last minute. What we need is for the twins to play to their pay packet and for Sam to play like a million dollar elite player
 

foreverinourshadow

First Grade
Messages
9,400
We look like we are falling into the same trap we always do. Replacing Tyrell or clark will do nothing? Who do you replace them with? For the price these guys are reported to be on, you aren't going to get better players. Could try rookies, but that is always a huge gamble. Look at the knights. They've had to clear away duds, and replaced them with youngsters. They aren't tipped to win a game this season. I think we've shown with musgrove that when we have a young guy ready we will play him, but until they are ready it's a gamble. Clark and Tyrrell would be the best value for money players in our squad. Between the 2 of them they'd probably be on half the money George Burgess is on, yet while he languishes in nsw cup, Tyrrell and Clark combined over the 80 minutes to contribute 60 odd good tackles and a a handy 150 metres. We're we need better value for money is our big name players. George and Tom have been poor for years, Walker has to get better now his been upgraded, aj as well, even Sam has to be better. People praising Sam last night must have watched a different game. He made less runs and metres per minute then Tyrrell and Clark, made less tackles total then Clark even though he had more minutes and he came up with 5 missed tackles. This is from our million dollar player. It's easy to kick Tyrrell and Clark, but they are both playing like 150k a year players. Luke Kelly played like a back up half that was both drafted into the squad at the last minute, and drafted into the team at the last minute. What we need is for the twins to play to their pay packet and for Sam to play like a million dollar elite player


diego i see you have called some newcastle players duds?your catching on fast bingo....Shadow...
 

Rabbits20

Immortal
Messages
42,064
I tend to agree with much of this when i saw the final makeup of the team i was disgusted madge has lost it.
Talakai turner tyrell good luck .
Most knock bryson but he consistently performs and should be in the centres
Turner is too light and gets monstered crighton would be better.
At the end of the day defence wins games and ours was non existent we were playing tip and made them look better than they are.
Im upset and disgusted 13th place and i dont care if its round 1what an excuse u could see from the 7s we had no idea alarm bells should have rung
Madge is losing it. Correct.

Spot on re the 4 you name. Add Kelly to that too. Zero idea how to guide a team around.

Correct re Bryson. He should be a centre but he won't let you down on the wing. In fact we could put Jennings at centre with his speed and keep Bryson on the wing. Talakai can't defend!!!!

Turner is a lightweight. I'm nearly in tears that someone besides Shadow finally understands this. He must play off the bench and be put on notice.


Tyrrell and Clark well we know they aren't first graders these days.

The highlight of the match was when they announced Clark is replaced but Tyrrell.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top