General Discussion Thread

[herbert henry1908]

Turns out Nathan lied twice to the NRL anyway.

First lie was that the women popped into his house, the truth is he went to their house.

second lie was about being photographed.

He’s pretty lucky in the end.

 

[franklin2323]

If True surely the police would of discovered that and fined him instead of the girls?

 

[herbert henry1908]

If True surely the police would of discovered that and fined him instead of the girls?

Unless he lied to the police as well, or they didn’t properly question him.

But most of the girls were visiting the house too.


This new piece of information is why Tyrone May has been penalised.

 

[franklin2323]

Unless he lied to the police as well, or they didn’t properly question him.

But most of the girls were visiting the house too.


This new piece of information is why Tyrone May has been penalised.

I would think the police would need an addess the offence took place. Either way been a mess all round

 

[Aliceinwonderland]

Turns out Nathan lied twice to the NRL anyway.

First lie was that the women popped into his house, the truth is he went to their house.

second lie was about being photographed.

He’s pretty lucky in the end.

and that's why the fine and suspension is so heavy. Also why May was fined and suspended too.

I think May needs to move on.

 

[Kev07]

Agree with Gallen,May has also taken a bullet regarding the sex tapes.
If he hadn't then the Panthers and the NRL would be in ruins.
It maybe the reason the club hasn't moved him on.

https://amp.nine.com.au/article/a94d1204-f2ba-4580-89ba-0a6a2347c48d

 

[herbert henry1908]

They’ve changed their reporting now. It was at Cleary’s house, but he went and picked up the girls and drove them to his place.

Either way it seems like he lied more than once, which is the reason for the harsher penalty.

 

[TheFrog]

They’ve changed their reporting now.

So they lied before? Or more likely making it up as they go along.

Also why May was fined and suspended too.

It hasn't really been satisfactorily explained what May's role in this was.

 

[franklin2323]

So they lied before? Or more likely making it up as they go along.


It hasn't really been satisfactorily explained what May's role in this was.

Gallen seems to think for not dobbing in Cleary is the reason

 

[TheFrog]

Turns out Nathan lied twice to the NRL anyway.

First lie was that the women popped into his house, the truth is he went to their house.

Seems likely the cops will issue him a $1,000 bluey as well. Will be interested to see if May also gets one.

 

[CCJohnC]

I am bored with all the Cleary comments here and in the press. He is being made a scape goat by all for basically being a silly boy. It's all finished now. Can we please give it a rest.

 

[herbert henry1908]

Seems likely the cops will issue him a $1,000 bluey as well. Will be interested to see if May also gets one.

Police are now re-investigating him

 

[herbert henry1908]

I am bored with all the Cleary comments here and in the press. He is being made a scape goat by all for basically being a silly boy. It's all finished now. Can we please give it a rest.

Goes beyond being silly. He lied several times, possibly even to the police.

If he’d just copped to it initially this would all be well behind us, but he made it much worse by lying.

 

[TheFrog]

Goes beyond being silly. He lied several times, possibly even to the police.

No-one ever lies to the police. No-one ever rings in and says they're sick when they're not either.

It's all finished now. Can we please give it a rest.

I'm more concerned with May, to be honest. There seems to be some suggestion he's been stitched up. The club wanted it over and you can't blame them for that but there's not a great deal of transparency insofar as May's suspension goes.

 

[herbert henry1908]

No-one ever lies to the police. No-one ever rings in and says they're sick when they're not either.

That’s entirely irrelevant to my point.

I was saying that lying to the NRL & Police is more than just being silly, that other people lie doesn’t disprove that.

You don’t get suspended for 2 matches & fined tens of thousands of dollars for being silly.

 

[soc123_au]

Sounds like May is copping it unfairly. He has f**ked up a bit over the past 18 months, but the punishment is pretty severe compared to the crimes.

 

[franklin2323]

I am bored with all the Cleary comments here and in the press. He is being made a scape goat by all for basically being a silly boy. It's all finished now. Can we please give it a rest.

It is the result of nothing else to talk about

 

[franklin2323]

Sounds like May is copping it unfairly. He has f**ked up a bit over the past 18 months, but the punishment is pretty severe compared to the crimes.

I am curious what he actually did

 

[herbert henry1908]

I am curious what he actually did

According to this he lied to them as well. I assume they questioned him first time round because he lives with Nathan.

https://au.sports.yahoo.com/nrl-2020-nathan-cleary-tyrone-may-suspended-virus-breach-204152565.html

 

[franklin2323]

According to this he lied to them as well. I assume they questioned him first time round because he lives with Nathan.

https://au.sports.yahoo.com/nrl-2020-nathan-cleary-tyrone-may-suspended-virus-breach-204152565.html

So Gallen’s account of it might be true in that he went along with the story