What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

General Discussion Thread

murraymob

Coach
Messages
10,338
G
I must admit as I sat there watching the superstar get told he had failed, I thought I was doomed. But, yes I did pass and went on to serve for four years in airborne forces. Ahh, those were the days. No grey hairs then!
as I read the original post my reaction was did you pass lol luckily I read on and Kilkenny asked
 

Crashtest

Juniors
Messages
1,193
It’s nice to see some of the off field good deeds that the Panther players do get noticed by the media, instead of the usual ego and arrogance crap that some of the journalists go on about.

And great work by Peachey and the other players to dedicate time to do this in a week when they were also preparing for a prelim final:


SAINT
Penrith might’ve been busy preparing for a historic shot at a three-peat last week but it didn’t stop Tyrone Peachey from organising a bus full of his teammates, including star Nathan Cleary, from visiting the home of seven-year-old Panthers fan Thomas, who was recently diagnosed with Diffuse Intrinsic Pontine Glioma, which is the worst form of aggressive brain tumour. The visit was part of Peachey’s community business he runs with his wife that supports Indigenous Australians.


 

Crashtest

Juniors
Messages
1,193
It’s no great surprise to see that Penrith dominated the Dally M Team of the Year nominations with nine, which is the most of any team. We even have nominations for coach, captain and rookie of the year.


The only positions we don’t have nominations for are hooker and five-eight. Although I personally wouldn’t swap Luai for any of the 3 nominees for five-eight, which were Munster, Mam and Walker.

 

Kilkenny

Coach
Messages
13,878
It’s no great surprise to see that Penrith dominated the Dally M Team of the Year nominations with nine, which is the most of any team. We even have nominations for coach, captain and rookie of the year.


The only positions we don’t have nominations for are hooker and five-eight. Although I personally wouldn’t swap Luai for any of the 3 nominees for five-eight, which were Munster, Mam and Walker.

Dylan Edwards should be a certainty for fullback of the year. Likewise Liam Martin. There two givens.
 

Fangs

Coach
Messages
14,177
So for positional awards, that is Dally M point based as well?

e.g. Munster wins as the the five-eighth with the most Dally M points. Or are player votes involved.
 

Kilkenny

Coach
Messages
13,878
I’m guessing;

Edwards - Fullback.
DWZ - Wing.
To’o - Wing.
Farnworth - Centre.
Crichton - Centre
Mam - 5/8.
Johnson - Half Back.
Egan- Hooker.
Martin - Second Row.
Hamoule Olakau'atu - Second Row.
Haas - Front Row.
Fonua-Blake - Front Row.
Yeo - Lock.
Webster - Coach.
Reynolds - Captain.
Bula - Rookie.

no opinion on the other two minor awards.

I think Turuva should get rookie, but he won’t they’ll give it the Tigers fullback.
 

Goonji

Juniors
Messages
461
Tough match-up’: Could a team of ex-Panthers challenge the premiers?

ByAdrian Proszenko

September 27, 2023 — 5.00am

Jarome Luai casts his eye over the list and raises an eyebrow. “There are some guns there,” Luai said before adding, perhaps only half-jokingly, “I’d probably be scared to verse those guys.”

Luai is looking at a list of 17 players, named in positional order by this masthead, who have left Penrith since they made the first of four consecutive grand finals. The salary cap has forced a slew of superstars – including Apisai Koroisau, Matt Burton, Viliame Kikau and Kurt Capewell – to join rivals during the club’s golden run.

The quality of the parting Panthers is such that a team comprised solely of them would likely be competitive if entered into the NRL.

“Absolutely, that’s crazy,” said back-rower Liam Martin. “It would be tough, they are all just such quality players, they bought into the system and the culture so well. It would be a tough match-up.”

A spine of Koroisau, Burton, Sean O’Sullivan and Daine Laurie – the latter is returning to the foot of the mountains from next year – would play behind a forward pack consisting of Tevita Pangai Junior, Kikau, Capewell, J’maine Hopgood, Jack Hetherington and James Tamou.

The Panthers brace for the departure of at least two superstars every year – Stephen Crichton (Bulldogs) and Spencer Leniu (Roosters) will depart after Sunday’s grand final against Brisbane – but have managed to replace them and remain consistently dominant.

“It’s a strong side,” winger Brian To’o said of the parting Panthers. “I think that is a pretty solid team. A few of our brothers have departed and gone onto bigger and better things and I couldn’t be more happy for those guys.”

Prop James Fisher-Harris added: “They would go good.”

Parting Panthers ... the gun team that has left since the 2020 grand final

1 Daine Laurie

2 Charlie Staines

3 Brent Naden

4 Paul Momirovski

5 Josh Mansour

6 Matt Burton

7 Sean O’Sullivan

8 James Tamou

9 Apisai Koroisau

10 Tevita Pangai Junior

11 Viliame Kikau

12 Kurt Capewell

13 J’Maine Hopgood

14 Tyrone May

15 Jack Hetherington

16 Zane Tetevano

17 Robert Jennings

Whenever an established name has left, a capable replacement has quickly emerged. Sunia Turuva, Izack Tago, Mitch Kenny and Lindsay Smith are all products of the best junior nursery in the country, while the likes of Jack Cogger, Zac Hosking and Luke Garner have fitted in seamlessly since arriving from other NRL systems.

The players believe it’s a product of Penrith’s next-man-up mentality.

“Every team wants to have that, I first heard that with Melbourne,” Luai said. “Especially with Origin, a lot of players have been in that side over the years and it’s definitely been a focus coming into that period.

“It’s been built here now. With all the guys that are leaving or have left, we’re still here on the biggest stage, it speaks for itself. You have to earn that spot, it comes from a lot of hard work.

“Just the way people speak about the jersey before they put it on is pretty special.

“Cogs, Garner, Hosking had a lot to say before they had even played, how prestigious it was to be at this club and how special it was to put on that jersey. That stuff is pretty cool to hear.”

Fisher-Harris said many players had taken less to stay than they could have got at rival clubs.

“A lot of us came through together so we just want to stick together,” he said. “It’s hard in this business, we all have families to feed and sometimes you have to think of the bigger picture. We’ve got kids in school and stuff like that, depends on how old we are. Everyone is trying our best to stick together.”
 

Hooked

Juniors
Messages
1,203

Article in full.

Penny pinchers: Why players are taking huge pay cuts to join Penrith​

By Dan Walsh and Adam Pengilly

September 27, 2023 — 11.00am
Daine Laurie will return to Penrith next year for about $150,000 – less than half his salary at Wests Tigers this year.

Paul Alamoti heads west from Canterbury for roughly half the $450,000 of his most recent Canterbury contract.

Zac Hosking turned down a larger offer from Canberra.
Tyrone Peachey was ready to walk away from the game, before taking $100,000 less than the $375,000 he was guaranteed in his Tigers contract.

Luke Garner took a pay cut, though not as steep, to make the same move from wooden spooner to potential premiership winner in a year.
Should Peachey, the 18th man for Sunday’s grand final, play in a Panthers win, the pair would join Brenko Lee (Titans to Storm in 2020) and Harvey Howard (Magpies to Broncos in 2000) in trading last for first within 12 months during the NRL era.

The premiership rings Penrith collect for fun are an incentive. But just as it was previously with Craig Bellamy at Melbourne and Trent Robinson at the Roosters, so too is a chance to learn from the best.
“I love hearing that because when I first came into grade, it was the opposite,” captain Isaah Yeo says.


“Players were taking less to play at other clubs, whether it was the Storm or the Roosters.

“To have sustained success is obviously a big factor, but it’s a really good tip of the cap to the club’s status. It’s taken a long time.
“Especially given Penrith, from the outside looking in, it’s got a reputation as not the greatest destination for people to come. It’s got a rep though because it’s western Sydney and it’s not near a beach.
“But for people to come out here, they then don’t want to leave once they’re out here, which is a tip of the cap to the community as well and how far the club has come.”

Star five-eighth Jarome Luai faces a well-documented contract conundrum. When the season ends, he can formally negotiate with rival clubs, who will offer seven-figure salaries.
What price can you put on the Panthers effect?

For players like Laurie and Alamoti, a $200,000 sacrifice on one deal is made with the examples of Sean O’Sullivan and Jack Cogger in mind.
Cut-price contracts for an opportunity in the NRL’s best system can work out eventually for players with potential that, for whatever reason, is yet to be truly realised.

“I’m such a better footy player than I was this time last year, my footy knowledge has grown so much just by being around this group and these coaches,” Garner says.
“It’s not really a lightbulb moment, probably more just you pick things up over time. I’m fitter and stronger. You put the work in and it pays off.”
Even Hosking, who earned more as a carpenter than a fringe NRL player earning $1000-a-week on train-and-trial deals, had little hesitation when Penrith called.
“It was still an easy decision to take Penrith, with the greatest respect to other clubs, because when it comes to your footy, you know you’re in the best position possible,” Hosking says.
Meanwhile, Peachey’s pay cut – as part of a trade with Charlie Staines – required the NRL salary cap auditor’s approval.

Once facing early retirement, the former NSW Origin utility has been so revitalised by his time at Penrith, he’s eyeing a post-career move into coaching.
“I was hating life, I was hating footy and it wasn’t fun any more,” Peachey says.
“My body wasn’t too bad but my heart wasn’t in footy. But to come back to Penrith, I was nervous every day before pre-season. They’re just animals out here.
“You just don’t want to let anyone down. The system here just brings the best out in you.

“Everyone here rips in, the juniors are guns coming through and you just don’t want to let anyone down. The system here just brings the best out in you.”

 
Messages
3,229
Article in full.

Penny pinchers: Why players are taking huge pay cuts to join Penrith​

By Dan Walsh and Adam Pengilly

September 27, 2023 — 11.00am
Daine Laurie will return to Penrith next year for about $150,000 – less than half his salary at Wests Tigers this year.

Paul Alamoti heads west from Canterbury for roughly half the $450,000 of his most recent Canterbury contract.

Zac Hosking turned down a larger offer from Canberra.
Tyrone Peachey was ready to walk away from the game, before taking $100,000 less than the $375,000 he was guaranteed in his Tigers contract.

Luke Garner took a pay cut, though not as steep, to make the same move from wooden spooner to potential premiership winner in a year.
Should Peachey, the 18th man for Sunday’s grand final, play in a Panthers win, the pair would join Brenko Lee (Titans to Storm in 2020) and Harvey Howard (Magpies to Broncos in 2000) in trading last for first within 12 months during the NRL era.

The premiership rings Penrith collect for fun are an incentive. But just as it was previously with Craig Bellamy at Melbourne and Trent Robinson at the Roosters, so too is a chance to learn from the best.
“I love hearing that because when I first came into grade, it was the opposite,” captain Isaah Yeo says.


“Players were taking less to play at other clubs, whether it was the Storm or the Roosters.

“To have sustained success is obviously a big factor, but it’s a really good tip of the cap to the club’s status. It’s taken a long time.
“Especially given Penrith, from the outside looking in, it’s got a reputation as not the greatest destination for people to come. It’s got a rep though because it’s western Sydney and it’s not near a beach.
“But for people to come out here, they then don’t want to leave once they’re out here, which is a tip of the cap to the community as well and how far the club has come.”

Star five-eighth Jarome Luai faces a well-documented contract conundrum. When the season ends, he can formally negotiate with rival clubs, who will offer seven-figure salaries.
What price can you put on the Panthers effect?

For players like Laurie and Alamoti, a $200,000 sacrifice on one deal is made with the examples of Sean O’Sullivan and Jack Cogger in mind.
Cut-price contracts for an opportunity in the NRL’s best system can work out eventually for players with potential that, for whatever reason, is yet to be truly realised.

“I’m such a better footy player than I was this time last year, my footy knowledge has grown so much just by being around this group and these coaches,” Garner says.
“It’s not really a lightbulb moment, probably more just you pick things up over time. I’m fitter and stronger. You put the work in and it pays off.”
Even Hosking, who earned more as a carpenter than a fringe NRL player earning $1000-a-week on train-and-trial deals, had little hesitation when Penrith called.
“It was still an easy decision to take Penrith, with the greatest respect to other clubs, because when it comes to your footy, you know you’re in the best position possible,” Hosking says.
Meanwhile, Peachey’s pay cut – as part of a trade with Charlie Staines – required the NRL salary cap auditor’s approval.

Once facing early retirement, the former NSW Origin utility has been so revitalised by his time at Penrith, he’s eyeing a post-career move into coaching.
“I was hating life, I was hating footy and it wasn’t fun any more,” Peachey says.
“My body wasn’t too bad but my heart wasn’t in footy. But to come back to Penrith, I was nervous every day before pre-season. They’re just animals out here.
“You just don’t want to let anyone down. The system here just brings the best out in you.

“Everyone here rips in, the juniors are guns coming through and you just don’t want to let anyone down. The system here just brings the best out in you.”

Thanks. I'm unsure how to copy, and paste, on a mobile.
 

Hooked

Juniors
Messages
1,203
Thanks. I'm unsure how to copy, and paste, on a mobile.


Most phones have a copy all button after holding down on one word. Or you can just do a few lines.
It can be a pain in the arse at times, to drag a few lines when lining them up.

Maybe the links below can help explain it better.


Here is a link if using an android phone to copy and paste.


Or IPhone

 

Latest posts

Top