General Discussion Thread

[Fangs]

I’m just not a fan of players running the asylum.

You can argue maybe Kevvie wasn’t the man for the job, but the way in which the players lay down at the back end of this season just doesn’t sit well with me. It’s all well and good I suppose happy to see your coach hung out to dry but there fan base deserved better.

It happened twice under his watch which is the concerning part.

No one goes to work to do a bad job. If the environment sucks you'll see standards slip and he has to be accountable for that. Probably the head office too.

If they had their time over they'd keep Ikin and ditch Walters. Ikin started sorting out their roster week 1 of his arrival. Responsible for culling a few players and bringing in Reynolds. Never should have left. It looks even worse for Walters when he was the one who wanted him gone.

 

[Iamback]

It happened twice under his watch which is the concerning part.

No one goes to work to do a bad job. If the environment sucks you'll see standards slip and he has to be accountable for that. Probably the head office too.

If they had their time over they'd keep Ikin and ditch Walters. Ikin started sorting out their roster week 1 of his arrival. Responsible for culling a few players and bringing in Reynolds. Never should have left. It looks even worse for Walters when he was the one who wanted him gone.

That is the issue as I see it the 2022. 3rd to 9th drop across the last 5 weeks of the season into this year.

Reece Walsh for example wasn't at the club in 2022, So the one thing that was the same was Walters

 

[Sime_11]

if they buy into Madge - they will be a fit team - could be a resurgence

alot of flashy players in that team though - they can blow teams away but they can also look so poor defensively

 

[age.s]

Players running the asylum only happens when the coach is out of his depth. The players aren't just built different under Bellamy, Bennett, Ivan etc.

 

[Pjf04b]

What a joke are the Dally M awards!
Yeo doesn't get a point from 12-18, while Hughes gets 27? Really?

 

[Black Diamond]

What a joke are the Dally M awards!
Yeo doesn't get a point from 12-18, while Hughes gets 27? Really?

What a joke

 

[kinghippo]

What a joke are the Dally M awards!
Yeo doesn't get a point from 12-18, while Hughes gets 27? Really?

The coaching Daily M is always cooked.
Nothing for Ivan in the last 3 years is ridiculous.
Surely Cirraldo should have got it on how it’s been judged lately.

 

[unKwn]

If Bellamy won it in 21 and 24 then ivan absolutely should have won it in 22. We only lost like 4 games all year

 

[Pjf04b]

Yeo gets 7 points from 12-24.
This is absolutely ridiculous!

 

[Pjf04b]

Ludicrous!

 

[Pjf04b]

I bet we only get 2 players in the team of the year - To'o and Yeo!

 

[Pjf04b]

Absolutely pathetic!
Journo favourites all the way!

 

[soc123_au]

I bet we only get 2 players in the team of the year - To'o and Yeo!

It's a media popularity contest. I dont get why it's taken seriously.

 

[Pjf04b]

I just get disappointed for people like Yeo and Ivan who genuinely deserve to get recognised but get looked over for journo pets like Tedesco, DCE, Hynes etc. There must be a better system, perhaps the old RLW system of rating all players 1-10 every game.

 

[Exsilium]

It's a media popularity contest. I dont get why it's taken seriously.

Who the f**k takes it seriously? I was busy watching mean girls and I hate chick flicks

 

[soc123_au]

I just get disappointed for people like Yeo and Ivan who genuinely deserve to get recognised but get looked over for journo pets like Tedesco, DCE, Hynes etc. There must be a better system, perhaps the old RLW system of rating all players 1-10 every game.

Using that rating system is the only way it becomes a legit award.

I think Ivan and Yeo are ok with premierships instead though.

 

[Fangs]

Its just not a serious award system. I'd be curious to know what the players think because I don't know many fans who pay attention to it.

Though at least the winner this year probably deserved it. Hughes has been very good.

 

[Iamback]

Its just not a serious award system. I'd be curious to know what the players think because I don't know many fans who pay attention to it.

Though at least the winner this year probably deserved it. Hughes has been very good.

Has the RLPA player of the year ever been the same? That tells you all you need to know