Much of our forward power was derived from the combination of Vaughan and Packer. We cannot hope for our forwards to perform at this level without replacing Packer with a hard nosed prop. We do not have such a prop in-house right now and I would hate to see us waste another year or two rebuilding.We have great depth and talent in the forwards which will keep us competitive all year. It's the backs which is the worry, a lot of good first graders but no real matchwinners ( excluding Widdop in his current form )
Field and Dufty are the future but ATM they look like young kids against the men. Both are so slight in build so they may take a little longer to mature.
I feel that Sele is a great up and coming junior who is in his initial stage of first grade development - and doing well. However, he is nowhere near the calibre of Packer.The more I watch Sele the more you think we are in good shape if Packer leaves.
Sele reminds a little of Tony Carroll ex Broncos player.
Sele, Kerr and Lawrie our three young props. How long do you think these guys will take to be ready for first grade? Sele is already doing well coming off the bench and Kerr and Lawrie are looking really good playing for Illawarra.
I agree re Simms, but he isn't an international. Oh wait....Fiji?Sele will move into Simms role and Simms to step up into starting spot..IMO could work
i rate Simms as a charging front rower he has agro in him and has pace as well - what he did in that Country game 2 weeks ago was amazing - 5 line breaks for a forward is unheard of...
Vaughan
Mciness
Simms
Frizzel
Thompson
JDB
Bench take your choice
LAM
Sele
Host
Lawrie
Luciano
Kerr
Young firebrand bench just the way u want it!! no plodders all young hot heads!
To me he looks a bit small compared to other forwards so I don't think he will be able to cover the front row. (I have no stats to back this up, just what it looks like at the game and on TV so I could be very wrong haha)
Poor Host has been McGregored...the kid is an out-and-out edge backrowers, yet McMoron leaves him on the bench for 70-80 minutes a game, and when he does come on it's filling in at prop. Complete mess.Fair enough. My point is, as is per my OP... Don't care how much 20's you've watched. Sele has had far less taste of 1st's than Host, yet is easily the better prospect... Host MAY come on. But this thread is merely a nod to Sele's performances on the field. Which imo, far exceed Host's.