Hayne v DCE

[El Diablo]

:lol:

 

[Avenger]

Diablo is on that loud minority that thinks we the silent majority actually give a f**k.

 

[El Diablo]

stop replying then

 

[Avenger]

Dont you dare cheer form him next year you turncoat.

 

[hindy111]

Out of the 12 victories we had this season, Hayne got us home on his own in at least 8 of them.

What about the games we lost?

Anyhows why couldn't we keep Hayne.Get rid of Norman and Sandow and have Matterson and DCE? Id imagine sandow and normans 1.1million would go a long way towards this.
Id prefer Foran thou to DCE.

 

[Poupou Escobar]

Hayne will never win a premiership

DCE turns up every game as opposed to Hayne who goes missing

I disagree he goes missing. Maybe in 2010 but this year and in 2011 he turned up every week. In 2012 and 2013 he was injured.

Agreed he will probably never win a premiership, at least at Parra. And I doubt we'll win one as long as Hayne is on the books.

No quality players want to take unders to come here and play with him. They want some of the big money they know Hayne is on.

 

[hindy111]

Hayne is greedy.Isnt he from housing commission? Should be happy with a place to live and food on table.

 

[El Diablo]

I disagree he goes missing. Maybe in 2010 but this year and in 2011 he turned up every week. In 2012 and 2013 he was injured.

Agreed he will probably never win a premiership, at least at Parra. And I doubt we'll win one as long as Hayne is on the books.

No quality players want to take unders to come here and play with him. They want some of the big money they know Hayne is on.

i don't think you can build a team around Hayne either

 

[forward pass]

Looking at the poll El d - It looks like everyone agrees with you.

 

[El Diablo]

i guess that's why we haven't won a premiership since he's been in the side

 

[TheParraboy]

I have no problem paying hayne top dollar.He performs nearly every game.

I do have a problem paying Hoppa-Norman lussick and sandow good dollars.They are all average hot and cold and could get better value for half the cost.Your a fool if you think Hoppa provides good value.

well said champ

 

[gustarny]

Id take Bj Leilua on one third the coin Hoppa is on.Hey but That is on this years form. I am expecting Hoppa to step it up bigtime in 2015.

 

[Tony Bongo]

This poll would be much more interesting if it was on the Manly Forum.

 

[Suitman]

This poll would be much more interesting if it was on the Manly Forum.

:lol: True!!

 

[hindy111]

I still think Hayne will get better.Imagine him behind a pack that rolls forward every game.
Lets face it our pack is very hot and cold.Next year it should be more solid

K.Edwards-Mau-Tepai - Pauli Pauli- have played under 15 games.All will improve ten fold.Kenny's last 3 games where top notch.

Jnr Paulo-terepo - under 25 games

Gower 40 games.realy this was his first year in first grade-He will improve too

Lussicks-cant go worse and looking for a contract.Be back to his best.

Mossop-Will add something.

Peats - De gois been good but peats is the better player.

Mannah is the only guy who wont be any better next year IMO.But do a job.
Plus we may have Watmough ; )

 

[Poupou Escobar]

Peats - De gois been good but peats is the better player.

Here's an interesting yet potentially meaningless stat about Nathan Peats:

Total games:

55 Souths
10 Parra

Total wins:

33 Souths (60%)
6 Parra (60%)

That's a pretty good winning percentage. Better even than Anthony Watmough (58%).

 

[Suitman]

Nerd.

 

[ParraEelsNRL]

Don't care, just glad we off loaded the spoon.

 

[byrner]

i guess that's why we haven't won a premiership since he's been in the side

I think your on to something. We haven't won a premiership since he has been born either, its all his fault!

 

[emjaycee]

Here's an interesting yet potentially meaningless stat about Nathan Peats:

Total games:

55 Souths
10 Parra

Total wins:

33 Souths (60%)
6 Parra (60%)

That's a pretty good winning percentage. Better even than Anthony Watmough (58%).

Sample size Pou.