What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

I Dont' Like Cricket, Oh No, I Love it, Yeah

Incorrect

Coach
Messages
12,733
The variable is that it is a drop in wicket to appease the AFL so we really don't know what it will do on Day 5.
It looked pretty benign late on Day 4 so this might be our killer if it doesn't deteriorate. The weather is fine tomorrow and not overly hot so not sure whether it will do that.
f**k the AFL.
In saying that, the Melbourne pitch was always a nothing pitch anyway.
Thank goodness the SCG Trust has always refused the AFL's requests for a drop-in.
The Adelaide drop in pitch is fine now and producing good Test wickets and the evolution of the preparation of that drop in over the last decade plus has been learned from by the MCG curator. The early MCG drop in pitches were like a slab of concrete until they introduced the Adelaide Ovals preparation and methods. I heard Les Burdett talking about it during the second test...
 

Eelogical

Referee
Messages
23,326
The variable is that it is a drop in wicket to appease the AFL so we really don't know what it will do on Day 5.
It looked pretty benign late on Day 4 so this might be our killer if it doesn't deteriorate. The weather is fine tomorrow and not overly hot so not sure whether it will do that.
f**k the AFL.
In saying that, the Melbourne pitch was always a nothing pitch anyway.
Thank goodness the SCG Trust has always refused the AFL's requests for a drop-in.
He who dares, wins. it was a great fightback from the lads. Cummins, as a captain deserves this if his tactics are spot on tomorrow. Also, those half chances need to be taken when they present themselves.
 

Suitman

Post Whore
Messages
56,027
The Adelaide drop in pitch is fine now and producing good Test wickets and the evolution of the preparation of that drop in over the last decade plus has been learned from by the MCG curator. The early MCG drop in pitches were like a slab of concrete until they introduced the Adelaide Ovals preparation and methods. I heard Les Burdett talking about it during the second test...

I'd agree with that, in that all the drop in pitches have improved over the years. Although, Perth is not the pacey bouncey wicket we once knew at the WACA.
I've actually thought that this Melbourne drop-in pitch has been the best I've seen. A bit in it for everyone.
In saying that, I love the tradition that Sydney is always a spinners pitch and I'd hate to see us lose that and end up with a pitch that we see everywhere else (climatic conditions excluded).
 

Eelogical

Referee
Messages
23,326
The only thing I will give that state is the attendances. They have been amazing.
87000 day 1.
85000 day 2.
68000 day 3.
46000 day 4.
Tomorrow could be big.

Can't wait for the Ashes next year and the Barmy Army, although I can't see as many Poms at the tests as Indians there this year.
Who says test cricket is dead?
Should be a 250K total test turnout by the end of day five. If only I had a Chaat stall at the MCG.
 

King-Gutho94

Coach
Messages
15,595
This has been one of the great test matches we have seen in this country in my time.

Both teams fighting for every run it seems but also the momentum swings across the 4 days.

Both teams have had periods where they have imploded and conversely dominated.

333 should be enough I reckon if we held the trophy Cummins would have declared last night.

But the fact we couldn't lose has probably erred on the side of caution with Sydney still to play in the back pocket.

Ideally we want to be 2-1 up with rain always about in Sydney and it being a dry deck in recent years its struggled to get results from it even with the weather.
 

Gazzamatta

Coach
Messages
15,650
I dont mind the decision to continue to bat. Regardless, India will go for the win and those few extra runs might see some pressure and resultant rash shots. It should be a thrilling days play. I just hope Cummins has a better plan to attack India's tail.
Can't wait.
 

King-Gutho94

Coach
Messages
15,595
I dont mind the decision to continue to bat. Regardless, India will go for the win and those few extra runs might see some pressure and resultant rash shots. It should be a thrilling days play. I just hope Cummins has a better plan to attack India's tail.
Can't wait.
Well the plan to the tail hasn't changed for a long time.

Maybe just line and length that gets the good batsman out might be worth a go to the tail.
 

King-Gutho94

Coach
Messages
15,595
I'd agree with that, in that all the drop in pitches have improved over the years. Although, Perth is not the pacey bouncey wicket we once knew at the WACA.
I've actually thought that this Melbourne drop-in pitch has been the best I've seen. A bit in it for everyone.
In saying that, I love the tradition that Sydney is always a spinners pitch and I'd hate to see us lose that and end up with a pitch that we see everywhere else (climatic conditions excluded).
Sydney hasn't really been a spinners deck for years imo.

Its generally dry and flat but it hasn't really turned.

Lyon averages 40 with the ball there and its his worse ground in Australia

Kuldeep Yadav in 2019 for India is the only opposition spinner to take a 5fer there in the past 15 years and that was in the sandpaper summer without Smith and Warner.

We had a batting lineup of Marcus Harris, Shaun Marsh's last test, Marnus was plucked from Redlands to bat at 3 in that game, Pete Handscomb, Tim Paine, Travis Head was still pretty raw then as well.

Like it was one of the worst sides we have put out for a test match in Australia in my life. Thank f**k it rained for 2 days and saved us from an innings defeat.
 
Top