What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Inglis to Souths..

rnb11

Juniors
Messages
820
as for the "imposter" tag, you're just a petty little loser. You don't know me, you don't know that i've been a souths fan for as long as i've known of footy. so get a life, it's better than throwing uneducated insults at people you don't know.

lol
 

AlwaysGreen

Immortal
Messages
49,807
As for the "imposter" tag, you're just a petty little loser. You don't know me, you don't know that I've been a Souths fan for as long as I've known of footy. So get a life, it's better than throwing uneducated insults at people you don't know.

.
I apologise. You're a hypocritical imposter.
 

rnb11

Juniors
Messages
820
I'm "okay with" doing what it takes to win a premiership. Having Inglis and giving up Champion for him helps us in our chase for a premiership in my view. And because of that I'm completely for the move.

And we are not a "disgrace", we (like every other club) are simply making the best 25 man squad we can that will hopefully win us a grand final in October. That's what we're doing, that's what everyone else does.

You will never have a good solid 25 players when you spend majority of your salary cap on 4-5 guys. Souths would have to be one of the most unbalanced and pathetically constructed teams in the competition. You don't win premierships by having a few stars and the rest park footballers unless your stars are your halves which unfortunately for you, they most definitely are not. I wonder when Russel will be putting his money towards a player that can actually win a premiership since every big name recruit so far hasn't got you very far.
 

seaeagle sam

Guest
Messages
1,027
When we got Champion to talk to Inglis we had no idea we'd be letting go of anyone.

For this to be true Souths didn't/doesn't know the salary cap and third party rule (despite the fact the NRL especially outlined it after the Brisbane debacle or it lied to its own fans, the general league public and tried to deceive the salary cap auditor.
 

BunniesMan

Immortal
Messages
33,709
For this to be true Souths didn't/doesn't know the salary cap and third party rule (despite the fact the NRL especially outlined it after the Brisbane debacle or it lied to its own fans, the general league public and tried to deceive the salary cap auditor.
We had different issues to Brisbane's. Gallop has since said the 3rd party deals themselves weren't the issue but the fact that he was supposed to make 200k from 3rd party deals in his first year and just 190k under the cap. That was the problem.

Souths didn't know that would be a problem because the NRL in it's eternal wisdom decideds on a case by case basis what the minimum some players can be paid.
 

Galeforce

Bench
Messages
2,602
lots of stupid comments all round in this thread.
folks talking about heart and all that stuff.
Two equal players , the heart difference will most likely win in the end.
a team with lesser skilled players may win a big game on heart against the odds. However they will not win most of the games against the odds.

Anyone here knocking Souths for signing Inglis and then releasing Champion to go to Melbourne for more money to close the deal -- if you would not support your club doing that , well good on ya. Hard decision for Souths , however I support it as the right one , the professional one.professional teams win competitions. Souths have set the platform over last three years to have a real shot in 2011. One player does not win a competition by themselves, however inglis adds cream to a nice mix of players.
 

the1

Juniors
Messages
150
lots of stupid comments all round in this thread.
folks talking about heart and all that stuff.
Two equal players , the heart difference will most likely win in the end.
a team with lesser skilled players may win a big game on heart against the odds. However they will not win most of the games against the odds.

Anyone here knocking Souths for signing Inglis and then releasing Champion to go to Melbourne for more money to close the deal -- if you would not support your club doing that , well good on ya. Hard decision for Souths , however I support it as the right one , the professional one.professional teams win competitions. Souths have set the platform over last three years to have a real shot in 2011. One player does not win a competition by themselves, however inglis adds cream to a nice mix of players.

Good post
 

Godz Illa

Coach
Messages
18,745
In the Rusty-commissioned Souffs puff-piece “The Book Of Feuds”, there’s a line in the Roosters chapter suggesting that the Roosters “had lost their soul”. Now, if Nick Politis had nothing better to do on weekends he could offer some unknown freelance (aka unemployed) writer a few coins to write his own stroke-book, and he could very easily plagiarise that same phrase in describing the Rabbitohs. They’ve lost their soul.

Where is it? When these apparently imminent premierships roll in, where will the so-(laughably)called pride of the league find their pride?

Their captain, their leader, is a johnny-come-lately Bulldog whose only decent season in 07 (leading to a rare finals appearance – the Bunnies sole September sojourn in 20 years) was enough to earn him not only the captaincy but seemingly a four year paid vacation. He’s now a has-been at 28. Surely once that mammoth contract runs out he’ll be granted the same fond farewell as his predecessors, those beloved former Souths captains Peter Cusack and Bryan Fletcher - i.e sh*t-canned and sent to England.

The coaching conveyor belt continues on unabated. John Lang, a two year veteran in the head coach hot seat of Souffs, has mercifully been advised of his termination well in advance. Jason Taylor (07-09), Shaun McRae (05-06), Arthur Kitinas (04), Paul Langmack (03-04) and Craig Coleman (02) weren’t so fortunate. If a coach typically provides direction for a club, then it’s no surprise that somewhere in that aimless maze of coaching schizophrenia, that the Souffs soul has been lost - along with countless, countless games of football.

The playing group, surely, are where the soul is at! That abundant, fertile nursery of local juniors, all of them coming up through the grades together and making the big time. Those promising youngsters who came into the NRL during the Souffs dark days (umm, I may need to be more specific here... but carry on) who are now a few years older and have still done pretty much nothing in the NRL. John Sutton, a player who has remarkably managed to tread water his entire career. He’s inconsistent, they say. No, he’s just average, we say. Then there’s the other local juniors... [scans list] oh yes – Nathan Merritt. What a good guy at scoring tries he is. Also loves to point fingers at cameras after scoring tries. Not so good at tackling or making rep teams, but loves to point fingers at racist rep selectors after missing those teams. Who else. McPherson, Falloon, Corrigan. Who? Craig Wing! No he was canned. David Fa’alogo – Mascot junior! Not Jason Taylor’s favourite player, but he was canned because they signed the butterfingered Pom. Buddy Gordon, Eddie Paea – hmm both better halfbacks than Chris Sandow but no. Beau Champion. Ahh yes, Beau Champion. Here we have the latest chapter in the tale of latter-day South Sydney soul destruction. A cocky kid from the very nucleus of Bunnies heartland – La Perouse. A raw player, patiently slow-cooked into a genuine first grade centre. Yet, here he is, being treated like nothing more than a cell on an Excel spreadsheet. Ctrl-X. The sums weren’t adding up. Ctrl-X. Rusty says he’ll never do chequebook rugby league like the Roosters, but Excel spreadsheet rugby league is worse. At least in a cheque there is an inherent promise, and the promise is kept. In the new soulless Bunnies, you’re only a Ctrl-X away from being unceremoniously dumped when something better comes along.

I think if the current group of players did some soul-searching they may all eventually follow the sage advice offered to Joe Galuvao, when Rusty wanted to Ctrl-X him with a year left on his contract – quit Souths and join a seminary.
:lol:

that post:

ctrl-c
+
ctrl-v
 

RedVee

First Grade
Messages
6,886
i honestly think if Souths can get some consistency and some luck with injuries they are a good chance in 2011.

Agreed, though the danger is if the signing of the big $ players cuts their quality of depth too much. Inglis, Asotasi, Crocker, Burgess, & even Luke & Merritt to an extent, would be a fairly large chunk out of the cap.

IMO one of the keys to Saints 2009 consistancy was the eradication of the old 'big6' thinking. What we lost in big names and rep players was covered by a greater ability lower down the roster. The players that came into the squad and off the bench were closer in ability to those that they replaced when injuries and rep duties hit us. Souths seem to be moving towards the 'Big6' model. Mind you we got close under that model and if we had Bennett in those days perhaps it may have paid off.
 

Bumble

First Grade
Messages
7,995
The question remains - how many more pages/thread closures will we endure before the Loudstrats and AlwaysGreens of the world stop taking the most obvious troll of all time's bait?
 

BunniesMan

Immortal
Messages
33,709
lots of stupid comments all round in this thread.
folks talking about heart and all that stuff.
Two equal players , the heart difference will most likely win in the end.
a team with lesser skilled players may win a big game on heart against the odds. However they will not win most of the games against the odds.

Anyone here knocking Souths for signing Inglis and then releasing Champion to go to Melbourne for more money to close the deal -- if you would not support your club doing that , well good on ya. Hard decision for Souths , however I support it as the right one , the professional one.professional teams win competitions. Souths have set the platform over last three years to have a real shot in 2011. One player does not win a competition by themselves, however inglis adds cream to a nice mix of players.
I agree with every word of this. Says exactly what I'm thinking.
The question remains - how many more pages/thread closures will we endure before the Loudstrats and AlwaysGreens of the world stop taking the most obvious troll of all time's bait?
I'm not a troll. I actually consider the "loudstrats and alwaysgreens of the world" to be more troll than me.
 

AlwaysGreen

Immortal
Messages
49,807
The question remains - how many more pages/thread closures will we endure before the Loudstrats and AlwaysGreens of the world stop taking the most obvious troll of all time's bait?
My theory is that BunniesGimp isn't intelligent or witty enough to be a troll. I continue to respond to his nonsense because I pity the fool.
 

Ziggy the God

First Grade
Messages
5,240
In the Rusty-commissioned Souffs puff-piece “The Book Of Feuds”, there’s a line in the Roosters chapter suggesting that the Roosters “had lost their soul”. Now, if Nick Politis had nothing better to do on weekends he could offer some unknown freelance (aka unemployed) writer a few coins to write his own stroke-book, and he could very easily plagiarise that same phrase in describing the Rabbitohs. They’ve lost their soul.

Where is it? When these apparently imminent premierships roll in, where will the so-(laughably)called pride of the league find their pride?

Their captain, their leader, is a johnny-come-lately Bulldog whose only decent season in 07 (leading to a rare finals appearance – the Bunnies sole September sojourn in 20 years) was enough to earn him not only the captaincy but seemingly a four year paid vacation. He’s now a has-been at 28. Surely once that mammoth contract runs out he’ll be granted the same fond farewell as his predecessors, those beloved former Souths captains Peter Cusack and Bryan Fletcher - i.e sh*t-canned and sent to England.

The coaching conveyor belt continues on unabated. John Lang, a two year veteran in the head coach hot seat of Souffs, has mercifully been advised of his termination well in advance. Jason Taylor (07-09), Shaun McRae (05-06), Arthur Kitinas (04), Paul Langmack (03-04) and Craig Coleman (02) weren’t so fortunate. If a coach typically provides direction for a club, then it’s no surprise that somewhere in that aimless maze of coaching schizophrenia, that the Souffs soul has been lost - along with countless, countless games of football.

The playing group, surely, are where the soul is at! That abundant, fertile nursery of local juniors, all of them coming up through the grades together and making the big time. Those promising youngsters who came into the NRL during the Souffs dark days (umm, I may need to be more specific here... but carry on) who are now a few years older and have still done pretty much nothing in the NRL. John Sutton, a player who has remarkably managed to tread water his entire career. He’s inconsistent, they say. No, he’s just average, we say. Then there’s the other local juniors... [scans list] oh yes – Nathan Merritt. What a good guy at scoring tries he is. Also loves to point fingers at cameras after scoring tries. Not so good at tackling or making rep teams, but loves to point fingers at racist rep selectors after missing those teams. Who else. McPherson, Falloon, Corrigan. Who? Craig Wing! No he was canned. David Fa’alogo – Mascot junior! Not Jason Taylor’s favourite player, but he was canned because they signed the butterfingered Pom. Buddy Gordon, Eddie Paea – hmm both better halfbacks than Chris Sandow but no. Beau Champion. Ahh yes, Beau Champion. Here we have the latest chapter in the tale of latter-day South Sydney soul destruction. A cocky kid from the very nucleus of Bunnies heartland – La Perouse. A raw player, patiently slow-cooked into a genuine first grade centre. Yet, here he is, being treated like nothing more than a cell on an Excel spreadsheet. Ctrl-X. The sums weren’t adding up. Ctrl-X. Rusty says he’ll never do chequebook rugby league like the Roosters, but Excel spreadsheet rugby league is worse. At least in a cheque there is an inherent promise, and the promise is kept. In the new soulless Bunnies, you’re only a Ctrl-X away from being unceremoniously dumped when something better comes along.

I think if the current group of players did some soul-searching they may all eventually follow the sage advice offered to Joe Galuvao, when Rusty wanted to Ctrl-X him with a year left on his contract – quit Souths and join a seminary.


I read through this drivel and wasted a minute of my life.

Why don't you read the post above mine, it renders this tripe meaningless.
 

grouch

First Grade
Messages
8,393
In Souths' Top 25, 14 are Juniors.
hahaha yeah right, and Greg Inglis is a Queenslander.

Asotasi - NZ. Burgess - Eng. Corrigan - Gosford. Crocker - Qld. Geddes - St George. Inglis - Bowraville. Lowe - Qld. Luke - NZ. Mundine - St George. Ross - Qld. Sandow - Qld. Simpson - Qld. Stuart - Cronulla. Taylor - Qld. Tyrrel - Qld, Wesser - Qld.

Make that 9 out of 25.
 

Latest posts

Top