What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Inglis wants Johns out of league

Big Pete

Referee
Messages
29,115
:lol: Some of you really are puppets of the media.

'Read headlinez, post opinionz, think laterz'.
 

stormbati

Bench
Messages
3,089
of course everyone who has played footy has said it. Just like when they say I have the merkin in they yellow boots, or that red headed merkin.
I don't know what comp you guys play in but I don't know anyone who would tolerate it. They must not hear you when you say it
 

j0nesy

Bench
Messages
3,747
Yeah not a big fan of women bashers either. Why stop at racism let's get rid all the bad guys.
 

maccattack

Juniors
Messages
1,250
http://www.foxsports.com.au/story/0,8659,27312560-5018866,00.html

Timana Tahu's meeting with the NRL's Indigenous Council etc...




Fantastic. Go for it G.I.

What a great time we belatedly live in. This is long long overdue. People come first. Thats what this is about. Not football.

Its about the people of this country waking up and realising we are in this together.

I'm so proud that these boys are leading the way.

Inglis is a true champion in the true sense of the word.
 

Didgi

Moderator
Messages
17,260
So how bad a crime is depends on how much someone decides to take exception to it?

Are you saying if Tahu hadn't been in the room to hear what Johns said it would have been alright to say?

Who witnessed it doesn't change the severity of what either of them did.

Greg Inglis physically belted his girlfriend. Johns called someone a black merkin behind their back.

Just because Inglis is more upset about being called a black merkin by someone in a different state than his girlfriend was about being bashed in the face doesn't mean he's any better.

What the?

No one is saying Johns was fine to say what he said. Many think it's been blown out of proportion, but not that it was right to say.

So it's what, karma? Hypocrisy? High-horseness?

My one and only point is that never mind his previous charges, he should have the right to make a stand about what he believes in, just like if Joey takes offence next week because someone makes a comment about his massive arse he should be able to stand up and say 'that's wrong' (my examples are on fire tonight).

Btw if Tahu doesn't hear it that doesn't mean it's right, it means it stays as a joke between teammembers/friends instead of blowing up so much.
 

bartman

Immortal
Messages
41,022
Really, if Andrew Johns was to disappear completely from rugby league tomorrow... would it be any great loss?

Would it be any loss at all, except for the guy's (already overflowing) bank balance? Move on Joey, there's 16 x 25 current rugby league players running around, many of whom will need turn at a post-league career in years to come. Don't hog all the opportunities for yourself, the game's looked after you quite well already. Now move along...
 

gallagher

Juniors
Messages
1,800
Really, if Andrew Johns was to disappear completely from rugby league tomorrow... would it be any great loss?

Would it be any loss at all, except for the guy's (already overflowing) bank balance? Move on Joey, there's 16 x 25 current rugby league players running around, many of whom will need turn at a post-league career in years to come. Don't hog all the opportunities for yourself, the game's looked after you quite well already. Now move along...
Cut a legend from the game based on one comment?? Hoiw about we cut Harry Flopper and Hayne from the game for attrocities to NSW!
 

bartman

Immortal
Messages
41,022
It's been more than one comment... unless you've been asleep for a few years.

Johns has got his fair share of coin out of the game already, time to move over so some other guys get their turn to shine.
 

gallagher

Juniors
Messages
1,800
It's been more than one comment... unless you've been asleep for a few years.

Johns has got his fair share of coin out of the game already, time to move over so some other guys get their turn to shine.


What else has he said that you or Inglis witnessed?
 

20knights10

Juniors
Messages
1,632
It's been more than one comment... unless you've been asleep for a few years.

Johns has got his fair share of coin out of the game already, time to move over so some other guys get their turn to shine.
Assume I've been asleep. What other comments has he made that warrant a forced early retirement bart?
 

Tommy Smith

Referee
Messages
21,344
You are a moron.
I knew my opinion wouldn't be popular as they're always a 'politically correct free zone' so by all means call me a moron. But feel free to also argue the merits of my post.

What parts do you not agree with?

That talk of Andrew Johns not being allowed to have any involvement within Rugby League anymore is abit harsh for making a racist comment? Heck, Paul Gallen and Bryan Fletcher did the same and were still allowed to play the game! No-one asked for them to be barred from Rugby League. Neither were they the victims of two-week long witch-hunts. On the contrary as i recall it Bryan Fletcher was suspended for a week, required to do abit of work in the community and made a personal apology to Dean Widders which was accepted and both men moved on. The perfect solution.

Perhaps it was my assertion that most white people have called someone a "black merkin" at some point in their life? Id be willing to bet everything i own that most people - black, white, asian, hispanic - have made a racist jibe at some point in their life...

Maybe it was when i said that white people are dealt with more harshly, or at least more rigorously monitored than other races when it comes to racism? Again i think thats pretty stock standard. Living up here in Tville its not uncommon to read stories of Indigenous youths/gangs attacking or gang bashing a white bloke; and yet ive never ever heard the term "racist attack" attached to it. Quite frankly i suspect it's because the media are afraid to even mention the idea. Conversely... But that's just one example, and no doubt a controversial one which will lead to me being called a narrow-minded racist.

But more than likely it was when i stated that both Tahu and Inglis need to drink a glass of harden the f**k up. By all means they both had the right to feel insulted and offended by the comment. They also had the right to receive a sincere personal apology from Johns and an assurance from he and the NSWRL that such behaviour would not be tolerated in the future.

But as soon as they both began to act like Holocaust survivors - that is when Tahu abandonded his teammates without any attempt at resolution, needed time off training to deal with the 'trauma' and acted like a petulent turd against the Knights with his intentional high shot which can no doubt be attributed to that aforementioned trauma; and when Inglis started talking about perhaps leaving the game and being completely oblivious to the irony of his comment that Joey should be thrown out of the game despite being anything but a clean skin himself - well IMO that's when they both went way too far and took a case of minor racism (on a scale of 1-5 i'd give it a 1) and turned it into something far greater than it really needed to be.

So again, just to reiterate my initial point - both Timana and GI need to drink a glass of harden the f**k up. Oh and Joey, in future pal, if you're going to make a non-vicious racist remark at least have the nouse to make sure that there aren't any 'blacks' around at the time! (can i say that or is it 'coloureds' these days?) That way you can at least use the "if a tree falls in the woods and no-one is around to hear it..." excuse.
 
Last edited:

Perth Red

Post Whore
Messages
69,869
I knew my opinion wouldn't be popular as they're always a 'politically correct free zone' so by all means call me a moron

mark rudd you are a moron!
 

Loudstrat

Coach
Messages
15,224
Really, if Andrew Johns was to disappear completely from rugby league tomorrow... would it be any great loss?

Would it be any loss at all, except for the guy's (already overflowing) bank balance? Move on Joey, there's 16 x 25 current rugby league players running around, many of whom will need turn at a post-league career in years to come. Don't hog all the opportunities for yourself, the game's looked after you quite well already. Now move along...

What league legend can the game do without? Is Joey the only one to disgrace himself? Punt Joey from the game, also remove Langer for the nude chicken dance, Blocker for thumping someone a few years ago, Tallis for glassing a barman, a hundred others for bankruptcy etc etc.

As flawed as they may be, we need our legends.
 

gronkathon

First Grade
Messages
9,266
Didn't Gallen say the exact same thing that Johns did?

As an aside what is next? Some Lebanese-Australian people complaining about Beau Ryans depiction of them on The Footy Show? Stereotyping is a form of racism after all.

Difference is it makes you all laugh so therefor it is acceptable. Double standards ahoy on the HMS Precious Weak C&#T
 

Didgi

Moderator
Messages
17,260
The difference is between one is said to hurt and insult, and one is said to be humourous, not to marginalise anyone. He depicts everyone sarcastically ("curl up in my eyebrows" "bad eighties haircut").
 

Latest posts

Top