Is there one player who...

[Bumble]

I'm surprised Covell wasn't the first name dropped

I am. Half the bloody forum want his children FFS!

 

[Bazal]

Matt Petersen would be Parra's worst....

 

[CowMan]

I think Neil Sweeney too...lol

why not sweeny also

 

[lockyno1]

My side brendo:

1. David Simmons
2. Brenton Bowen (f..k it is hard to pick a cowboy)
3. Steve Matai
4. Kury Kidley
5. Chris Walker
6. Bret "The Hack" Seymour
7. Todd Carney
8. Ben Cizwalski
9. Corey Hughes/Adam Perry
10.Lee Hookey
11. Mark Riddell (only becuase of how much they are paying him)
12. Joe Williams
13. Todd Byrne

14. Daniel Fitzhenry
15. Brett Finch
16. Jane Carlaw
17. Phil Bailey

 

[Bernster]

why not sweeny also

Cos Sweens always screws up...I won't be surprised if he gets dropped to the Young Guns this weekend and Brenton Bowen gets into the starting line-up tbh...

 

[willvillain]

Matai is in sh*t-hot form. End of story.

I agree.

 

[CowMan]

I am. Half the bloody forum want his children

blended up and forced fed to firman and sweeny as punishment



that should be arranged BBSF + Covell = Brett Firman

 

[CowMan]

Cos Sweens always screws up...I won't be surprised if he gets dropped to the Young Guns this weekend and Brenton Bowen gets into the starting line-up tbh...

if BB dont make it in the cows this week ill send a evil SMS to TxT the editor for our local paper and ill also send Matty bowen a Txt in his Txt matty bowen thing in the paper and ask him " yo dawg what da sh*t with ya cuz not get ni call up sh*t wack ayit?"

 

[innsaneink]

Id have to vote for Shannon Hegarty

 

[Jordan]

Brett Firman

I don't think Firman is completely useless. I think he still has it in him.. I'd be willing to give him a while longer. Remember, he's only been with the Cowboys for half a season and was dropped pretty quickly this year. After he was dropped, he only played one game for the young guns in one month...so it's not like he could've built up some sort of form or anything.

I think Firman at his best is a more dominant player...I suppose the problem with the Cowboys is that Thurston is so dominant. Firman, to his credit, gives the ball to Thurston a lot of the time... but yeah, I do think Firman still has potential, though I admit I am starting to think I had imagined that form he showed at the Dragons a couple of years ago.

 

[Special K]

Covell as ovverated as he is is not the worst. Simmons is the worst at the sharks!

no way!

Beau Scott is the worst. Simmons is now the 2nd worst! GO SIMMO!!!!

How can you say Bailey? He has been solid to great for us this season. Seriously he may be a merkin of a player but he is the glue that holds the sharks defence together.

 

[brendothejet]

Chris Sheppard is pretty f**king useless...

 

[lockyno1]

no way!

Beau Scott is the worst. Simmons is now the 2nd worst! GO SIMMO!!!!

Either way simmons is still s..t!:lol:

 

[Jordan]

My side brendo:

1. David Simmons
2. Brenton Bowen (f..k it is hard to pick a cowboy)
3. Steve Matai
4. Kury Kidley
5. Chris Walker
6. Bret "The Hack" Seymour
7. Todd Carney
8. Ben Cizwalski
9. Corey Hughes/Adam Perry
10.Lee Hookey
11. Mark Riddell (only becuase of how much they are paying him)
12. Joe Williams
13. Todd Byrne

14. Daniel Fitzhenry
15. Brett Finch
16. Jane Carlaw
17. Phil Bailey

hmm... Brenton has been playing awesome for the young guns (he scored 4 trys in one half of football yesterday)..It's ridiculous he hasn't played first grade this year. He is definitely a player I rate.

 

[Timmah]

BRI - B Seymour
BUL - C Hughes
CAN - M Elliott (Surely that can be my vote?)
CRO - Tied L Covell/B Kimmorley
MAN - S Matai (overrated, niggly little bitch)
MEL - C Walker
NEW - It's opposite day. I'm going to say A Johns, but imply that the entire side is sh*t when he isn't there.
NZL - J Ropati
NQL - B Firman
PAR - M Petersen
PEN - L Hookey
STG - B Creagh
SOU - B Walker
SYD - B f**king Finch
WES - See 'NEW' RE: B Marshall

 

[Matta]

Wagon.

 

[lockyno1]

hmm... Brenton has been playing awesome for the young guns (he scored 4 trys in one half of football yesterday)..It's ridiculous he hasn't played first grade this year. He is definitely a player I rate.

As I said it is damn hard to pick a s..t player from NQ! Heck you have Hannay in PL!

 

[Bumble]

BRI - B Seymour
BUL - C Hughes
CAN - M Elliott (Surely that can be my vote?)
CRO - Tied L Covell/B Kimmorley
MAN - S Matai (overrated, niggly little bitch)
MEL - C Walker
NEW - It's opposite day. I'm going to say A Johns, but imply that the entire side is sh*t when he isn't there.
NZL - J Ropati
NQL - B Firman
PAR - M Petersen
PEN - L Hookey
STG - B Creagh
SOU - B Walker
SYD - B f**king Finch
WES - See 'NEW' RE: B Marshall

No way, Merritt, Mellor, Hegarty, Lowe, S.Walker, Minichiello, Manuokafoa are all worse than him.

 

[lockyno1]

Wagon.

QLD player and good utilty how is he bad at all?

 

[Bumble]

My side brendo:

1. David Simmons
2. Brenton Bowen (f..k it is hard to pick a cowboy)
3. Steve Matai
4. Kury Kidley
5. Chris Walker
6. Bret "The Hack" Seymour
7. Todd Carney
8. Ben Cizwalski
9. Corey Hughes/Adam Perry
10.Lee Hookey
11. Mark Riddell (only becuase of how much they are paying him)
12. Joe Williams
13. Todd Byrne

14. Daniel Fitzhenry
15. Brett Finch
16. Jane Carlaw
17. Phil Bailey

Umm..what? A halfback who can't tackle in the 2nd row? Switch him with Jane!