Jarome Luai

[OldPanther]

Depends what you like. I think a ballplaying FB is better then trying to get either of those 2 to pass it. Though Edwards did play halves as a junior so who knows how he will finish up. I like Dallen as a centre

He might move as he gets older and loses a bit of pace.

 

[mxlegend99]

I love both at fullback. Different strengths obviously. But considering all options available at wing and fullback, I don't see a stronger back 3 for us than Edwards at fullback and Mansour/DWZ on the wings.

 

[betcats]

Can we genetically engineer a footy player with both of them as the template?

Well I know Edwards work ethic/attitude would be the perfect starting place.

Don’t get me wrong I rate edwards highly I just love Dallins explosiveness and aggression.

 

[unKwn]

Edwards at fullback for me. I think he's great there

 

[OldPanther]

Well I know Edwards work ethic/attitude would be the perfect starting place.

Don’t get me wrong I rate edwards highly I just love Dallins explosiveness and aggression.

Imagine that work ethic with Dallin's physique. Oh boy.

You're not wrong about his attributes. I just think they are loser than you think. I'm sure Dylan is a very good runner. Wish they both nee how to pass though.

 

[Matthew Ellis]

Imagine that work ethic with Dallin's physique. Oh boy.

You're not wrong about his attributes. I just think they are loser than you think. I'm sure Dylan is a very good runner. Wish they both nee how to pass though.

Edwards has mentioned he's working on it during pre season. I've noticed he's done a few good short passes which he didn't do in previous years. He just needs to perfect cut outs now.

When he first played first grade Cooper Cronk said Billy Slater could only pass well a metre in any direction and he had to train hard to improve that.

 

[OldPanther]

Edwards has mentioned he's working on it during pre season. I've noticed he's done a few good short passes which he didn't do in previous years. He just needs to perfect cut outs now.

When he first played first grade Cooper Cronk said Billy Slater could only pass well a metre in any direction and he had to train hard to improve that.

Yeah it's easy to forget how the elite players started out and developed over a 10 year career.

 

[Matthew Ellis]

About Jarome not playing every game in reserve grade like he did against the Warriors. It's a team sport, players don't play in a vacuum. I doubt our reserve grade forward pack dominated any team like we did to the Warriors in the reserve grade games he played.

 

[herbert henry1908]

Luai might get more games with Maloney’s injury last night. It’s only minor but I could see him being rested another week.

 

[mxlegend99]

About Jarome not playing every game in reserve grade like he did against the Warriors. It's a team sport, players don't play in a vacuum. I doubt our reserve grade forward pack dominated any team like we did to the Warriors in the reserve grade games he played.

Actually our reserve grade pack are f**king animals that dominate games regularly. One thing our lower grade halves have not done is play behind a beaten pack very often.

We look like men playing children most weeks.

 

[betcats]

Luai will be a better player than Cleary you heard it hear first.

 

[OldPanther]

Luai will be a better player than Cleary you heard it hear first.

He has better vision.

 

[betcats]

He has better vision.

Yeah he has things that can’t be coached. A great kicking game, looked better than Nathan’s has all season and he has a great attitude.

 

[Fangs]

Brilliant again. What a player.

Other clubs will be circling as we speak.

 

[betcats]

Brilliant again. What a player.

Other clubs will be circling as we speak.

We need to prioritise keeping Cleary and Luai they are perfect for each other .

If it means getting rid of Maloney for next year f**king do it, it will pay off.

 

[mxlegend99]

Luai will be a better player than Cleary you heard it hear first.

He is more likely to go the way of Mitchell Moses. When shit goes right it looks great. But when it goes wrong not so much.

Fantastic defence though. Comparing Luai to Cleary is like comparing Presto to Gowie. They're completely different players.

Moylan though is finding some serious form. Everyone here hates him and tties to discredit everyghing he does. But we win that game if Moylan wasn't in their team.

 

[betcats]

He is more likely to go the way of Mitchell Moses. When shit goes right it looks great. But when it goes wrong not so much.

Fantastic defence though. Comparing Luai to Cleary is like comparing Presto to Gowie. They're completely different players.

Moylan though is finding some serious form. Everyone here hates him and tties to discredit everyghing he does. But we win that game if Moylan wasn't in their team.

I thinkLuai has the right attitude and better coaching than moses, that will show the difference in those two.

They are different players that is true but Luai just has a much higher ceiling if all goes right for both of them. You can’t teach his vision or instincts, you can teach a great attitude and how to direct a team which he already has in his bag anyway. Luai can be a straight up 7 and control and direct the team like Cleary if we need him to be, I don’t think Nathan can provide the creative and attack that Jerome does though. That’s just what I think tho.

 

[mxlegend99]

Luai looks more like a 6 to me. Cleary runs a team. Luai reacts to what he sees. Its ady yo say he player has good vision when he's in good form. But those dorts of players tend to have dips in form where very little goes right too.

I think they would compliment each other well. But I think in a full season Cleary would easily lead a team to more victories. Lusi is more exciting though. But excitement doesnt always mean points.

 

[OldPanther]

He is more likely to go the way of Mitchell Moses. When shit goes right it looks great. But when it goes wrong not so much.

Fantastic defence though. Comparing Luai to Cleary is like comparing Presto to Gowie. They're completely different players.

Moylan though is finding some serious form. Everyone here hates him and tties to discredit everyghing he does. But we win that game if Moylan wasn't in their team.

Put Luai and Cleary together = sexy football.

Moylan is the football gods in human form.

 

[betcats]

Luai looks more like a 6 to me. Cleary runs a team. Luai reacts to what he sees. Its ady yo say he player has good vision when he's in good form. But those dorts of players tend to have dips in form where very little goes right too.

I think they would compliment each other well. But I think in a full season Cleary would easily lead a team to more victories. Lusi is more exciting though. But excitement doesnt always mean points.

I think letting them play as s traditional 7 and 6 would be brilliant for penrith long term I would love to see that.