What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Jarryd Hayne - Make him an Eel for Life

Chipmunk

Coach
Messages
17,406
I really find it difficult to believe that the club wants Hayne to sign and doesn't ( didn't ) have 500k earmarked to sign him.

One of those things simply cannot be true, unless perhaps the decision was made some time ago he wasn't wanted, and now that has changed.

And that would contradict all the noise coming from both parties through out the season.

I believe the club just presumed that someone would be knocking down our door to take one of our underperforming overpaid players like Norman, Moses, Jennings, French, or Takairangi of our hands.
 

Stagger eel

Moderator
Staff member
Messages
65,794
You're missing my argument. We have 28 players and only one recognised hooker. If Pritchard replaces Mahoney as Avenger indicated, we still only have one Hooker in the squad.

So position 29 is really only going to be a hooker.

Mahoney will 99% likely take position 29 in the roster, which leaves us only one spot left. Why would we fill that spot in the middle of November when we don't have to until the end of June?

Meaning there is no spot for The Plane until we get rid of someone. The salary cap space is fairly irrelevant.

I take your point and totally agree but why can’t Hayne take spot 29?

1 of the last 2 spots is definitely a hooker whether it’s Reed or someone else’s no question about it but there’s no reason why Hayne can’t take the other spot...
 

Chipmunk

Coach
Messages
17,406
That would likely be because we have not agreed to terms with him.

I don't believe we have given him an actual contract. Id say we've told him the money we're planning to offer him, but until someone f**ks off, there is no spot in the squad so there is nothing to offer.
 

Chipmunk

Coach
Messages
17,406
I take your point and totally agree but why can’t Hayne take spot 29?

1 of the last 2 spots is definitely a hooker whether it’s Reed or someone else’s no question about it but there’s no reason why Hayne can’t take the other spot...

Because surely no club in their right mind, or has used every cent of their salary cap, would fill position 30 in the roster in the middle of November when they don't have to until the end of June.

The issue that the only recognised hooker in the 28 squad is the most injury prone player in the club and struggles to string a month of football together in a row makes it more problematic. As a result, we're already committed to 29 players even though they're not in the squad, but it will definitely have to be a hooker.
 

Gronk

Moderator
Staff member
Messages
77,887
We can also retire Gower at any time bc he has a post career gig with the club anyway.
 
Messages
19,394
I don't believe we have given him an actual contract. Id say we've told him the money we're planning to offer him, but until someone f**ks off, there is no spot in the squad so there is nothing to offer.

Sure. But it's also rare to put a contract in front of someone when you know that there's 0% chance that they'll sign on the terms specified. It's a waste of legal fees for a start.
 

Stagger eel

Moderator
Staff member
Messages
65,794
Because surely no club in their right mind, or has used every cent of their salary cap, would fill position 30 in the roster in the middle of November when they don't have to until the end of June.

The issue that the only recognised hooker in the 28 squad is the most injury prone player in the club and struggles to string a month of football together in a row makes it more problematic. As a result, we're already committed to 29 players even though they're not in the squad, but it will definitely have to be a hooker.

Are assuming that there’s not going to be any departures before June ? ....it may take until June next year but I think there’ll be plenty of movement in and around the squad in the next 9 months... and reed will be part of that even he’s sitting outside it at the moment
 

Avenger

Immortal
Messages
34,217
Are assuming that there’s not going to be any departures before June ? ....it may take until June next year but I think there’ll be plenty of movement in and around the squad in the next 9 months... and reed will be part of that even he’s sitting outside it at the moment
I read somewhere that Schneider is a better prospect than Mahoney.
 

Chipmunk

Coach
Messages
17,406
Are assuming that there’s not going to be any departures before June ? ....it may take until June next year but I think there’ll be plenty of movement in and around the squad in the next 9 months... and reed will be part of that even he’s sitting outside it at the moment

The club assumed that some of their overpaid underperforming players would be snapped up by now, which is the predicament they've got themselves in. Given those circumstances, they obviously can't take the risk with adding to the squad at present as having only one recognised hooker in the squad at the moment, they've sort of snookered themselves until someone f**ks off.

I dare say if someone like Hoffman, French or Jennings had been moved on then both The Plane and Mahoney would already be filling spots 28 and 29 in the roster.
 

Chipmunk

Coach
Messages
17,406
Sure. But it's also rare to put a contract in front of someone when you know that there's 0% chance that they'll sign on the terms specified. It's a waste of legal fees for a start.

I'd still say we've made an offer contingent on someone f**king off, so essentially we've offered him nothing until that happens.
 

Latest posts

Top