Misty Bee said:
If Mal Meninga and Laurie Daley had to choose between the 1989 grand final and a test match played on the same day, what should they do? PLay for their country, and not honour a contract(and snub the club and their fans), or play in the GF and snub their country?
These players didnt sign a contract before knowing that there is a clash with their country, so the hypothetical is useless. In this instance, johns knows full well there is a international being played. If Daley and Meninga had signed those deals with Canberra knowing a potential GF/Australian clash stands in the way, without a shadow of a doubt, they play for Australia. However if they signed a contract and then some ding bat scheduled it poorly, they play for canberra and fulfill their contract.
But regardless your hypothetical is junk. Firstly there is a policy about not selecting ESL players, so there is no schedule clash, 2ndly your hypothetical states the scheduling would interfere in NRL GF, which WOULD NEVER HAPPEN, as they know a large part of the Aust team will come from those GF teams.
Basically your trying to justify Johns stance with a crazy scenario that would never happen. And wont happen for a good reason. Johns plays for warrington over the first test. Simple IMO, he is forced retirement from Australian jersey, if he cant show it the respect it deserves, then he doesn't fit the criteria of being Australian IMO and there for can never represent us again.