What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Kasiano charged

carcharias

Immortal
Messages
43,120
lol yeah, pretty woeful comparison. On one hand you've got a legal tackle, which is made illegal by the attacking player slipping. On the other you've got Jeremy Smith whacking a bloke in the face because he's about to get jumped on.

You have to be terribly naive to have watched Smith play and think that was an accident.

Bloke fell into smiths elbow if you want to get technical.

Who said it was an accident? I certainly didn't.


The Claim was something along the lines of Fui was on his knees so it must be an accident.

Hope he gets suspended then it will be in linè with everyone else copping
suspensions for head shots.
 

Tommy Smith

Referee
Messages
21,344
For the people who are suggesting that a penalty was sufficient - you are wrong. Because it wasn't even a penalty!

Just like the farcical penalty to Cronk in Origin. The bloke slipped and when you've already got your arm out there poised to make a tackle, exactly WTF else is the tackler supposed to do?

It was just an unfortunate incident. It happens in contact sports (i think it's still a contact sport, not sure anymore).
 

Dresden Dan

Juniors
Messages
2,366
http://www.nrl.com/kasiano-cleared-by-nrl-judiciary/tabid/10874/newsid/68706/default.aspx

Canterbury prop Sam Kasiano will be free to face Manly on Friday after being found not guilty of a grade-two careless high tackle by the NRL judiciary on Wednesday.


Kasiano was placed on report after collecting Parramatta prop Fuifui Moimoi across the head with his right arm in the opening 10 seconds of the Bulldogs' 32-12 win over the Eels last Friday.


The NRL's counsel Peter Kite said he accepted there was no suggestion of intent or recklessness from Kasiano, but the giant Kiwi had not shown the necessary duty of care to avoid forceful contact with the upper head and neck area of Moimoi.


Kite said the incident was "a good old fashioned coathanger", and that Kasiano didn't have a target, and "simply threw an arm out".


Canterbury's counsel Nick Ghabar said Kasiano did not have the time to change his line of attack as Moimoi was slipping as he was running with the ball.


He used a selection of still photographs of the incident to argue that the prop's arm would have been below the ball had Moimoi's body not been so low to the ground.


"It was very substantial drop in very quick time that caused this," Ghabar said.


"It's quite obvious that Mr Moimoi has dropped from the knees by 50cm in 0.4 seconds."


Judiciary chairman Paul Conlon sent the panel of Sean Garlick, Royce Ayliffe and Don McKinnon out of the room to ask Kite to clarify some of the elements of his argument.


And after 20 minutes of deliberation, the panel found Kasiano - who was supported by coach Des Hasler, chief executive Todd Greenberg and football manager Alan Thompson - not guilty.


"We're pleased with the verdict and looking forward to facing Manly on Friday," Greenberg said.


"We are very well versed in these situations and there is a big difference between an accident and being deliberate and those shown."


Kasiano said he was relieved to be cleared and was looking forward to helping the Bulldogs beat Hasler's former side in what is expected to be a red-hot encounter at Brookvale.


"I am very happy and can focus on the game now," he said.


Kite said the incident was "a good old fashioned coathanger", :lol::lol::lol:
 

typicalfan

Coach
Messages
15,430
good old fashioned coat hanger?? That'll do me.

It is sad when there are people in important positions in the game that actually think this.
 

Latest posts

Top