Knight Russell Packer jailed for two years

[Hutty1986]

lol, Inglis charged a few bucks and turned up to some group meeting for an hour or 2. Such a suitable punishment for bashing his missus

 

[Bring it home Knights]

:lol:

there would be two different charges

what a stupid analogy

i've never even heard of anyone being fined for 1kmh over

perhaps you shold read up on the assault that occurred. the victim required surgery

You obviously don't know of how speeding fines work in Melbourne then. If you do 1km over you can get fined, just like my fathers ex gf did.

So to try and get my head around what you were saying earlier. If I bash someone and they need some minor surgery on a broken nose. Are you saying the penalty should be the same as if I bash someone to the point where they need surgery for 6 broken bones, and 2 kidneys that have been beaten so badly that the person needs dialysis for the rest of their life. Are you saying that both charges of GBH should cop the same sentence? Because going by what you wrote earlier, you do believe that is the case.

What was wrong with my analogy from earlier? I thought it demonstrated your black and white thinking to a tee :?

 

[Porkie]

El drongo getting reamed again:lol:

Forum's greatest chin leader.

 

[The Elephant In The room]

You obviously don't know of how speeding fines work in Melbourne then. If you do 1km over you can get fined, just like my fathers ex gf did.

So to try and get my head around what you were saying earlier. If I bash someone and they need some minor surgery on a broken nose. Are you saying the penalty should be the same as if I bash someone to the point where they need surgery for 6 broken bones, and 2 kidneys that have been beaten so badly that the person needs dialysis for the rest of their life. Are you saying that both charges of GBH should cop the same sentence? Because going by what you wrote earlier, you do believe that is the case.

What was wrong with my analogy from earlier? I thought it demonstrated your black and white thinking to a tee :?

"Thinking" might be a bit generous.

 

[Porkie]

lol, Inglis charged a few bucks and turned up to some group meeting for an hour or 2. Such a suitable punishment for bashing his missus

He was protecting her from harming herself.

What a bloke.

 

[magpie4ever]

El drongo getting reamed again:lol:

Forum's greatest chin leader.

That is gold.:lol:

 

[El Diablo]

You obviously don't know of how speeding fines work in Melbourne then. If you do 1km over you can get fined, just like my fathers ex gf did.

So to try and get my head around what you were saying earlier. If I bash someone and they need some minor surgery on a broken nose. Are you saying the penalty should be the same as if I bash someone to the point where they need surgery for 6 broken bones, and 2 kidneys that have been beaten so badly that the person needs dialysis for the rest of their life. Are you saying that both charges of GBH should cop the same sentence? Because going by what you wrote earlier, you do believe that is the case.

What was wrong with my analogy from earlier? I thought it demonstrated your black and white thinking to a tee :?

because as it turns out GBH is worse than what Packer was charged with

and you did your analogy having not done any research on the GBH conviction and what happened to the victim because you tried to pass it off as a minor offence similar to being over the speed limit by 1kmh

 

[Spot On]

seems you are right

Did it hurt your fingers when typing the above Fonzie?

 

[magpie4ever]

because as it turns out GBH is worse than what Packer was charged with

and you did your analogy having not done any research on the GBH conviction

But the AFL guy has not been sentenced, yet. Maybe, the AFL has a edict not to comment until the final outcome is known (rightly or as I believe, wrongly).

Depends on State Laws (they're all different), but you are right regards NSW laws - GBH and assault Packer pleaded guilty too.

 

[El Diablo]

But the AFL guy has not been sentenced,

he has been found guilty though

Packer was not allowed to be registered even before he went court

 

[magpie4ever]

Did it hurt your fingers when typing the above Fonzie?

Hey Spotty, did you crack a woodie when Dangles admitted error?

 

[El Diablo]

you crack one when you read my posts

 

[magpie4ever]

he has been found guilty though

Packer was not allowed to be registered even before he went court

Maybe, it is just the way the Mexicans do their shit (wait for the final result - ie: sentence, before taking action.)

Who knows, they are weird pricks.

 

[El Diablo]

Maybe, it is just the way the Mexicans do their shit (wait for the final result - ie: sentence, before taking action.)

Who knows, they are weird pricks.

it's in WA

still doesn't explain why he hasn't been deregistered

this is what the victim thinks http://www.perthnow.com.au/news/wes...breaking-his-jaw/story-fnhocxo3-1226786975658

 

[magpie4ever]

you crack one when you read my posts

Dude, your posts are like anti-vigara unless, you're a far right wing gay lesbian neo nazi conversative.:lol:

Yea Tony.:lol:

 

[magpie4ever]

it's in WA

still doesn't explain why he hasn't been deregistered

this is what the victim thinks http://www.perthnow.com.au/news/wes...breaking-his-jaw/story-fnhocxo3-1226786975658

Because the powers that be are f**king Mexicans, as said, weird.

 

[The Elephant In The room]

he has been found guilty though

Packer was not allowed to be registered even before he went court

So the NRL has to copy the AFL in all respects now?

I'd suspect one of the difference (apart from the aggregated nature of the Packer assault) was the fact that he plead guilty, whilst the AFL guy plead not guilty, claiming self defense.

 

[El Diablo]

Dude, your posts are like anti-vigara unless, you're a far right wing gay lesbian neo nazi conversative.:lol:

Yea Tony.:lol:

i little birdy told me you voted for him

 

[El Diablo]

So the NRL has to copy the AFL in all respects now?

I'd suspect one of the difference (apart from the aggregated nature of the Packer assault) was the fact that he plead guilty, whilst the AFL guy plead no guilty, claiming self defense.

so what?

he was found guilty

Ferguson pleaded not guilty

should he be allowed to play?

 

[The Elephant In The room]

Out of interest El D, are you claiming Packer got treated harshly by the NRL for failing to register his contract whilst he was still in trial, or are you arguing the AFL were too lenient for not deregistering the WA guy?