What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

loosehead 1998 article: The Worst St George team of all time"

Uplifting

Juniors
Messages
457
graham wynn? he may have played on for too long but from '79 to '85 he was sensational - aus & nsw rep too don't forget!
Osbourne - had discipline problems, but was a damn fine prop when on song
steve linnane - rookie of the year in '85 & season's leading try scorer.
peter gill was not a hooker - he was a lock & second rower
And Djura was a 5/8
 

to_ddeath

Coach
Messages
11,908
Other nominees since the JVs creation include Junior Langi, Solomon Haumono, Daniel Heckenberg, Luke Branigan, Wes Pattern, Lee Hookey, Willoe Peters, Wade Forrester, Ben Jeffries, Craig Stapleton, Jamie Fitzgerald, Wise Katierevata, Andrew Bobbin, Garry McBride, Nathan Tutt, Shane Loata, Jason Kent, Michael Howell, Leo Clarke, Damien Bower, Hassan Saleh, Brett Firman, John Cross, Chris Nero, Peter Ellis, Ryan Tandy, Dean Byrne, Henry Penenara, David Howell, Ian Donelly, Ryan Howell, Tony Jensen, John Carlaw, Daniel Holdsworthy, Wheatley (first name long forgotten), Lachlan Russell, Andrew Frew, Shane Martene, Nick Youngquest, John Wilshire, Quentin Pongia, Robbie Simpson, Luke McDougall, Keith Leiliua, Richie Williams, Simon Woolford, Adam Peek, Tony Caine, Sam Isemonger, Tom Hewitt, Ben Ellis, Andrew Price, Corey Payne, Daryl Millard, Colin Best, George Ndara, Lee Tee Maari, Chris Shepherd, Ricky Thorby, Stuart Webb, Michael Lett, Ben Rogers, Nick Emmett, David Gower, Michael Greenfield, Peni Tagive, Cameron King, Bronx Goodwin, Jack Bosden, Chase Stanley, Kyle Stanley, Jeremy Latimore, Nathan Green, Atila Vea, Jack Stockwell, Bronson Harrison, Michael Henderson, Josh Drinkwater, Dylan Farrell, Sam Williams, Shane Pumipi, Craig Garvey, Eto Nabuli, Rory O'Brien, Heath L'estrange, Luke Page, Mark Ioane, and Dunamis Lui,


Some recruited locally, some not.

None were worthy of donning the iconic Red V jumper.

All filler, no killer. Enjoy the trip down Memory Lane.

So basically anyone but Marketo and Quinlan....

Riiiiighteo


T.
 

The_Team_Won

Juniors
Messages
529
graham wynn? he may have played on for too long but from '79 to '85 he was sensational - aus & nsw rep too don't forget!

Got to agree 100% whatever brain dead moron put Wynn on that list knows sweet FA about the Dragons or rugby league for that matter.
 

ouryears

Bench
Messages
3,195
Seemingly I am harsh with the Stanley brothers, but Chase should never been regained following his failed Melbourne foray, and Kyle's career was stifled by injury too.

As for the others you've mentioned, Hookey failed to each any great heights, Best's defensive liabilities are reminiscent of MacDonald, and Latimore has been through more clubs than Tiger Woods.
Agree with every name on your list
Plus that Canberra winger a few years back, must get his name
 

ouryears

Bench
Messages
3,195
M
Other nominees since the JVs creation include Junior Langi, Solomon Haumono, Daniel Heckenberg, Luke Branigan, Wes Pattern, Lee Hookey, Willoe Peters, Wade Forrester, Ben Jeffries, Craig Stapleton, Jamie Fitzgerald, Wise Katierevata, Andrew Bobbin, Garry McBride, Nathan Tutt, Shane Loata, Jason Kent, Michael Howell, Leo Clarke, Damien Bower, Hassan Saleh, Brett Firman, John Cross, Chris Nero, Peter Ellis, Ryan Tandy, Dean Byrne, Henry Penenara, David Howell, Ian Donelly, Ryan Howell, Tony Jensen, John Carlaw, Daniel Holdsworthy, Wheatley (first name long forgotten), Lachlan Russell, Andrew Frew, Shane Martene, Nick Youngquest, John Wilshire, Quentin Pongia, Robbie Simpson, Luke McDougall, Keith Leiliua, Richie Williams, Simon Woolford, Adam Peek, Tony Caine, Sam Isemonger, Tom Hewitt, Ben Ellis, Andrew Price, Corey Payne, Daryl Millard, Colin Best, George Ndara, Lee Tee Maari, Chris Shepherd, Ricky Thorby, Stuart Webb, Michael Lett, Ben Rogers, Nick Emmett, David Gower, Michael Greenfield, Peni Tagive, Cameron King, Bronx Goodwin, Jack Bosden, Chase Stanley, Kyle Stanley, Jeremy Latimore, Nathan Green, Atila Vea, Jack Stockwell, Bronson Harrison, Michael Henderson, Josh Drinkwater, Dylan Farrell, Sam Williams, Shane Pumipi, Craig Garvey, Eto Nabuli, Rory O'Brien, Heath L'estrange, Luke Page, Mark Ioane, and Dunamis Lui,


Some recruited locally, some not.

None were worthy of donning the iconic Red V jumper.

All filler, no killer. Enjoy the trip down Memory Lane.
Matt Groat, Daniel Vidot
 

ALSGI

Bench
Messages
3,101
Tony Smith has to be in this team. Only player I’ve ever known to draw boos from the crowd when his brother Brian would enevitably have him replace someone usually in the second half.
 

muzby

Village Idiot
Staff member
Messages
45,965
There’s no harm in reinvigorating debate during the off season. At least a thread such as this offers meaningful conversations...unlike your posts.
Then why do you waste so much time, effort & clear frustration on my posts?
 

muzby

Village Idiot
Staff member
Messages
45,965
How's that novel going?
images


I love that scene..
 

muzby

Village Idiot
Staff member
Messages
45,965
One could ask the same question to yourself.
What a silly concept.

If I didn’t spend time and effort on my own posts, I’d just be posting up the first random thing that pops into my head, that would probably have no relevance to anyone.


That’s what Twitter is for.
 

Latest posts

Top