Misanthropes Distraction Mafia Game Thread

[KeepingTheFaith]

Or some of us were at cricket training.

WarriorDutchy role claimed Drew. Drew would be FFB. No one had disputed his claim. Why do we think he's not town?

That's the real reason mafia are holding off imo, they know if they're the ones who tip it it'll stick out like dogs balls.

BM/CJ imo wouldn't push so hard if they were mafia, but should be "checked out" to be sure.

 

[Apey]

Yes with the game mix-up inactivity is even less convincing than it was before.

 

[KeepingTheFaith]

Where did this 'hoppity' come from

Some rambling drunk fool.

 

[cjrankin]

Well seeing as I'm vanilla it's time to hypothesise and muse a little.

People with under 10 posts

1. Bazzi (5) - cjrankin, town. Post condition of calm your tits at least once each day phase or something similar. Could be made up, but I doubt it.

2. SGLC (4) - meh, nothing much, voted mickyj but so did a lot of us.

3. Misanthrope (4) - fairly inactive for obvious reasons. I'm thinking town just because I buy into the giving him a more vanilla role (which still could be mafia though) because of his known inactivity.

7. butchmcdick (6) - hasn't offered much to analyse, mostly off-topic posts, could be town could be mafia.

16. Jason Maher (6) - Not a whole lot here either, fairly well expected to be inactive these days. Claims role is shit. Claims this when mafia Don. Who knows.

19. afinalsin666 (1) - made 1 post to vote for mickyj. Hard to read into a lynch when the catalyst is an investigation, even if it's a flimsy one. Like JM, typically inactive lately.

20. Bazal (7) - similar vein to butchmcdick imo.

21. Pugzley (4) - see JM & afs and an upcoming Smiley mention too. meh, who knows.

23. Smiley (4) - pretty confident he is town. I think he called the one-off mass-roleblock based on him asking whether mafia have two kills for Night 2.

24. Beeker (0) - has not posted once. Either vanilla townie or mafia, highly doubt he has a power role he needs to send in by himself.

Conclusion: I got nothin'. Very rarely in any games are mafia made up of only active players or only inactive players. It is usually a mix.

So from all that, my number one choice of inactives would be...

Beeker - 0 posts, not adding anything for town, unlikely to have a power role so if he isn't mafia a valuable town role hasn't gone to waste

pugz jumping on ktf lynch on page 8 was a little strange imo.

 

[HowHigh]

I'm happy to vote Pugz

 

[HowHigh]

Or just a no vote seeing as this doesn't really look like going anywhere

 

[KeepingTheFaith]

Me too. Voting for me, pfftt. All I did was lynch PP, not even sure why I'm still in this game, I already got the win.

 

[Smiley]

23. Smiley (4) - pretty confident he is town. I think he called the one-off mass-roleblock based on him asking whether mafia have two kills for Night2

:thumb

 

[Apey]

Detective Apey has your back bro.

 

[BunniesMan]

lol at wp's backtracking. How does somebody "misread" 50% for 10%

I'm gonna use the BM method.

When I come up town, lynch Hoppity.

I am very confident you will not come up town. But even if you do, like I've said before, you're the lead suspect. Does that make it a certainty? No. You may not be mafia, you might just be stupid.

The facts are you went out of your way to mislead us. You led us to lynching a town. I've explained how your play so far could be a baddies tactic.

People know the entirety of my argument. If they vote with me they are voting with the full facts as I know them. Unlike when you led us.

Where did this 'hoppity' come from

KTF's post condition in a previous game was being drunk. Part of his drunk ramblings was insisting on calling me 'hoppity'.

Well seeing as I'm vanilla it's time to hypothesise and muse a little.

People with under 10 posts

1. Bazzi (5) - cjrankin, town. Post condition of calm your tits at least once each day phase or something similar. Could be made up, but I doubt it.

2. SGLC (4) - meh, nothing much, voted mickyj but so did a lot of us.

3. Misanthrope (4) - fairly inactive for obvious reasons. I'm thinking town just because I buy into the giving him a more vanilla role (which still could be mafia though) because of his known inactivity.

7. butchmcdick (6) - hasn't offered much to analyse, mostly off-topic posts, could be town could be mafia.

16. Jason Maher (6) - Not a whole lot here either, fairly well expected to be inactive these days. Claims role is shit. Claims this when mafia Don. Who knows.

19. afinalsin666 (1) - made 1 post to vote for mickyj. Hard to read into a lynch when the catalyst is an investigation, even if it's a flimsy one. Like JM, typically inactive lately.

20. Bazal (7) - similar vein to butchmcdick imo.

21. Pugzley (4) - see JM & afs and an upcoming Smiley mention too. meh, who knows.

23. Smiley (4) - pretty confident he is town. I think he called the one-off mass-roleblock based on him asking whether mafia have two kills for Night 2.

24. Beeker (0) - has not posted once. Either vanilla townie or mafia, highly doubt he has a power role he needs to send in by himself.

Conclusion: I got nothin'. Very rarely in any games are mafia made up of only active players or only inactive players. It is usually a mix.

So from all that, my number one choice of inactives would be...

Beeker - 0 posts, not adding anything for town, unlikely to have a power role so if he isn't mafia a valuable town role hasn't gone to waste

At this stage it's a small sample size. I'm confident there's at least one bad guy in there and maybe more. It'll take more time to put faith in the numbers.

Or some of us were at cricket training.

WarriorDutchy role claimed Drew. Drew would be FFB. No one had disputed his claim. Why do we think he's not town?

Why is this an assumption? We have know idea how Socs mind has designed the scum faction. Drew (the role) could be bad for all we know.

 

[soc123_au]

On the Beeker inactivity I was contemplating a mod kill. I think the best result would be to sub him out for a dead player. Any of you dead merkins want another life? First to claim it gets it.

 

[BunniesMan]

pugz jumping on ktf lynch on page 8 was a little strange imo.

FYI, pages are different for everybody. Some people have custom settings. When pointing out a specific post you're better off mentioning the post number

 

[KeepingTheFaith]

If you bring back PP I'm so adding you to the list Soc.

 

[Bazal]

Why is this an assumption? We have know idea how Socs mind has designed the scum faction. Drew (the role) could be bad for all we know.

I'm not sure Drew and Mis have ever been more than just FFB friends. Why would Drew be in a faction of people trying to seduce Mis? Occams Razor, BathMan.

 

[KeepingTheFaith]

Apey named 11 people and you're sure at least one of them is mafia? Oh Hoppity. lol.

 

[Scott Gourley's Lovechild]

I've been inactive because I was in Orange for work from Sun-Tue. I'm back home now, so I can annoy you all with many posts.

With that said, I'm off to bed.

 

[Apey]

On the Beeker inactivity I was contemplating a mod kill. I think the best result would be to sub him out for a dead player. Any of you dead merkins want another life? First to claim it gets it.

I'm not dead but I'll take it. :sarcasm:

 

[cjrankin]

pugz post is #120 fyi

 

[BunniesMan]

PLEASE bring pp back!

I'm not sure Drew and Mis have ever been more than just FFB friends. Why would Drew be in a faction of people trying to seduce Mis? Occams Razor, BathMan.

Can people easily name 5 roles that would be there?

Apey named 11 people and you're sure at least one of them is mafia? Oh Hoppity. lol.

You're number 2 on my list, town murderer.

 

[Misanthrope]

Has KTF been cleared? He killed PP on day one and then basically danced around all happy happy.