Most Overated Player

[pennywisealfie]

Jarryd hayne could eb the greatest to play the game

and that comment right there is why he is considered to be overrated. Hes played half a season really really well. that doesnt come close to even the Langers and Sterlings who had a whole career of awesomeness, let alone the Lewis' and the Johns'

 

[Jeremy_hindmarsh]

Matt cooper is over rated!!!

 

[pennywisealfie]

Matt cooper is over rated!!!

you're overrated

 

[Doggiesfan09]

Jarryd hayne could eb the greatest to play the game

After 10 good games geez talk bout jumping the gun , i find this hilarious, he is in great form but FMD dont startb saying that sh*t for another 5 years

 

[Doggiesfan09]

Matt cooper is over rated!!!

IMO yes he is so over rated its not funny, but thats my opinion

 

[nomarg]

Easily Hayne-

yes he is having a great run - but greatest player to play the game......ROFL!


Shouldn't this be a poll.....

 

[Non Terminator]

Jarryd hayne could eb the greatest to play the game

Could be, yes.
But he'll need to pull form for more than half a year for a title like that, considering all of the legends you and I never saw play the game.

Braith Anasta

You might laugh at this suggestion and tell me everyone knows he is an overpaid log but just a few seasons back people were trying to sell him as the form player of the comp and an origin shoe in.

"Rated by those in the know" LOL

Rorters fans... f**king imbeciles.

He was one of the only players that actually gave a flying f*ck about representing the Roosters this year. His form was great last year, I don't recall many saying he was a shoe in.

He is barely rated these days anyway, so that further downs it.

 

[simmo1]

Hindmarsh and Ennis.

 

[timka4]

Jamal Idris

 

[CycloneSteve]

Mullen....lol....dont you actually have to be rated first to be considered over-rated??

Mullen will have 5-6 good games a year. The rest he is just a passenger. He has work to do in order to maintain some consistency.

Most over-rated IMO is Justin Hodges...

 

[Big Pete]

This year?

Ryan Hoffman
Brett White
Matt Cooper
Corey Parker
Dave Taylor
Shane Tronc
Antonio Kafusi
Carl Webb
Wade McKinnon
Steve Matai
Matt Orford
Josh Perry
David Williams
Frank Pritchard
Anthony Laffranchi
William Zillman
Steve Simpson
Setaimata Sa
James Aubusson
Colin Best
Chris Sandow
Roy Asotasi (Going by 09 form)
Daine Laurie
Terry Campese

 

[pennywisealfie]

This year?

Ryan Hoffman
Brett White
Matt Cooper
Corey Parker
Dave Taylor
Shane Tronc
Antonio Kafusi
Carl Webb
Wade McKinnon
Steve Matai
Matt Orford
Josh Perry
David Williams
Frank Pritchard
Anthony Laffranchi
William Zillman
Steve Simpson
Setaimata Sa
James Aubusson
Colin Best
Chris Sandow
Roy Asotasi (Going by 09 form)
Daine Laurie
Terry Campese

are you kidding? i agree with taylor, but corey parker is mad underrated!

 

[Big Pete]

That's what people say, but they only say that after one or two good games, they forget the 8 or so before hand where he's a complete passenger.

 

[Spot On]

J. Mullen has failed to live up to the wraps from his buddy A. Johns. Nearly got a start at Origin this year. Please. Never again.

 

[nomarg]

J. Mullen has failed to live up to the wraps from his buddy A. Johns. Nearly got a start at Origin this year. Please. Never again.

A Johns and M Johns Wrap anyone from the knights as future NSW superstars

Seu Seu
Uate
Mullen

There must be 1000 of them

 

[ostrich20]

This is probably more of not living up to the hype, but my vote goes to Frank Pritchard.

 

[nomarg]

This is probably more of not living up to the hype, but my vote goes to Frank Pritchard.

He is a complete waste of talent- Makes 2 good runs a game and people rave about him- where was he the other 78 minutes...

 

[user_nat]

That's what people say, but they only say that after one or two good games, they forget the 8 or so before hand where he's a complete passenger.

Really..? I don't think Parkers had a particularly bad game this season. Even when we were getting smashed, he was one of the only players who looked to be trying.

 

[Eelementary]

I agree.

As soon as his manager come out and said he was the greatest to play the game he became the most over rated player.

Don't make like you wouldn't sell your own mother to have him in whichever team it is you follow.

 

[Jeremy_hindmarsh]

he will be worth well over 800k for any club that wants to by him