Most Overated Player

[Apey]

Steve Simpson

Not sure if he's really rated any more. Defensively he is still in the top 2 from the Knights, however offensively he is past it.

 

[badav]

Don't make like you wouldn't sell your own mother to have him in whichever team it is you follow.

Parramatta has never won a comp or finished first with Jarryd Hayne in the side, so i can't really see how you would want or need to sell your mother to have him in your side.

Not saying they that they won't but i think some people have busted their nut way too early off the back of half a season of good form.

3 months of good form and suddenly your the best player to lace up a boot in 101 years. Give me a f'n break.

 

[nomarg]

he will be worth well over 800k for any club that wants to by him

A season-

Pitty the club that would pay that much- unless they are in a salary cap free comp.....

 

[CJG 182]

Naaaah!! but he's like had 10 weeks of good form he's like the greatest player ever mate.:crazy:

 

[nomarg]

Greatest in any code - according to Gus Gould

 

[Dazzat]

Kurt Gidley

 

[dollyhands]

Matt Orford.

Orfag for sure

 

[Kenny Powers]

Jamie Soward

 

[Liam]

Greatest in any code - according to Gus Gould

Gus wrote an article on Shane Perry?

 

[nqcowboy87]

israel "look and leap" folau

 

[Eelementary]

Parramatta has never won a comp or finished first with Jarryd Hayne in the side, so i can't really see how you would want or need to sell your mother to have him in your side.

Not saying they that they won't but i think some people have busted their nut way too early off the back of half a season of good form.

3 months of good form and suddenly your the best player to lace up a boot in 101 years. Give me a f'n break.

People saying he's the best ever are fools.

But I doubt you could successfully argue that, based on form, he is not the best player running around at this point in time. At the very least the best back.

And I stand by what I said - all other 15 NRL clubs would kill to have him in their side.

Moimoi and Hindmarsh have never won a title, either. I suppose they're sh*t too?

 

[legend]

Luke Bailey and Jarrod Mullen IMO.

 

[jimmyo]

Benji Marshall.

Brett Finch - if anyone, anywhere has ever rated him, that would make him over rated.

 

[lifesgood]

folou, inglis, JT

U r kidding arent you??

LOL



over rated player

David Williams

 

[MacDougall]

Benji Marshall.

Brett Finch - if anyone, anywhere has ever rated him, that would make him over rated.

Benji might have been the correct answer before this season or even maybe halfway through, but once the six was back on his back he pretty much played the way people rate him.

My answer is Darren Lockyer.

 

[Eelementary]

Benji might have been the correct answer before this season or even maybe halfway through, but once the six was back on his back he pretty much played the way people rate him.

My answer is Darren Lockyer.

I'd take Marshall in a heartbeat.

 

[mxlegend99]

Kurt Gidley and David Williams.

I'm worried that NSW will pick one or both of them again next year and eliminate any chance NSW have of ending the QLD dominance.

 

[skeepe]

Nathan Hindmarsh
Kurt Gidley
Frank Pritchard
Nathan Hindmarsh
Krisnan Inu
Jarrod Mullen
Nathan Hindmarsh
Steve Simpson
Akuila Uate
Nathan Hindmarsh
Chris Houston
Zeb Taia
Nathan Hindmarsh
Richie Fa'aoso
Danny Wicks
Nathan Hindmarsh
David Williams
Brett White
Nathan Hindmarsh

 

[Eelementary]

Where do you stand on Alan Tongue, Craig Fitzgibbon and the other workaholic back-rowers, skeepe?

I'm curious - I'm not having a go or anything.

 

[Flapper]

Braith Anasta

You might laugh at this suggestion and tell me everyone knows he is an overpaid log but just a few seasons back people were trying to sell him as the form player of the comp and an origin shoe in.

"Rated by those in the know" LOL

Rorters fans... f**king imbeciles.

The only answer.