Rotten Rooster said:Its obvious you have over rated yourself, havent you got anything better to do then bag players, turn it up mate.
haha get off tha pingers ya wanker!
Rotten Rooster said:Its obvious you have over rated yourself, havent you got anything better to do then bag players, turn it up mate.
Sir Biffo said:1. Rhys Wesser - watch him flounder at origin level
2. Luke Lewis - "hey do you know who i was" ... best days well behind him
3. Matt Gidley - see Luke Lewis
4. Ryan Cross - thinks he is an absolute superstar. I find it funny at origin time when he acts like he's been robbed for not getting a start!
5. Bryan Carney - he's good, but the amount of wraps he gets for doing run of the mill stuff is extraordinary!
6. Braith Anasta - because his name is Braith Anasta
7. Brett Kimmorley - hack.
8. Josh Perry - mostly over-rated by himself
9. Shaun Berrigan - I know he's only played hooker for a while ... but he doesn't offer that much there in my opinion
10. Brent Kite - nuffy
11. Nathan Hindmarsh - like Carney, gets huge wraps for doing nothing at all. 45 of his 50 tackles he is normally 2nd or 3rd man in
12. Craig Fitzgibbon - same as Hindmarsh, always 3rd man in a tackle. His best days were long ago when he was actually effective in attack.
13. Trent Waterhouse - how does this bloke keep getting in rep train on squads! He offers nothing!
14. Craig Wing - just go to yawnion you clown
15. Glen Morrison - like Cross, thinks he is clearly the best player in the world and can't understand why the selectors dont pick him
16. Anthony Watmough - nuffy
17. Brett Finch - need I say more?
lucablight said::lol:
Immortal said:They are both equally good in defence, I don't think anyones ever seen Wes make a mistackle, he does more hit-ups than Grothe, which prolly means he makes more metres, plus he can kick goals.
ParraDude_Jay said:Makes more metres than Grothe? :lol: Have you actually watched a game? Grothe on the wing is like another backrower when coming out of your own end of the field. Way too quick and strong for opposition to handle, plus he can slip some good offloads away.
Naiqama is nothing IMO.
Rabbitohs2005 said:im not denying he can be a freak, im just saying how inconsistent he is, when players not rated as highly, are more consistent, its only when JT is red-hot, is when he smokes players like Joe Williams, Todd Carney and Jeremy Smith etc
he has done SFA since origin though, and he only is good, when the cowboys are in form, i can think of other halfbacks, that play well, even when their team is out of form....
Believe it or not, Aaron Payne could be classed a better player than JT, payne has been consistently good for the cowboys in their bad 2006, JT was only good for the first half dozen rounds. then he has been out of form for the rest of 2006, when not injured
Payne has made a mark in this comp, and i rate him as one of the best hookers in the comp
JT form-wise doesnt even deserve his spot in the Prime Ministers Team, but his reputation has put him there
JT imo, has alot of tons of work to do, before he is classed a great player
Players: (That can still play decent for a losing team (cricket score wise))
Andrew Johns (best player in the world, hasnt really had a form slump in his life)
Joe Williams (is a very un-established player yet, but he tries his heart out in souths massacres this year, has actually been pretty good for us, in our losses he has featured in)
Craig Gower (maybe not in his career best form, but at least he is consistently good for the Panthers, he still played ok, in the Panthers Average Performances this year)
JT may be better than Gower, Williams and alot of other halfbacks in the comp, but really notice how in-experienced players like joey and todd carney are still consistent even while being flogged in the process
what JT does when the Cowboys are red-hot, is truly magic
but JTs Form relies on the Cowboys Form Too Much...
but his inconsistently really, i just think he isnt as good as what most people believe him to be, at least overall
hebdog85 said:haha get off tha pingers ya wanker![/quot
such a tough pussy behind a key board, get mummy yo change your nappy it smells
Well Baily is bloody goodharmichael said:1.Karmichael Hunt
2.Quinn
3.Brent Tate
4.Luke lewis
5.Tupou
6.Anasta
7.Orford
8.Luke Bailey (ray warren used his name in the same sentence as webcke and lazarus..OMG)
9.Craig Wing
10.Morley
11.Waterhouse
12.Carlaw
13.Dean Young
harmichael said:1.Karmichael Hunt
2.Quinn
3.Brent Tate
4.Luke lewis
5.Tupou
6.Anasta
7.Orford
8.Luke Bailey (ray warren used his name in the same sentence as webcke and lazarus..OMG)
9.Craig Wing
10.Morley
11.Waterhouse
12.Carlaw
13.Dean Young
harmichael said:8.Luke Bailey (ray warren used his name in the same sentence as webcke and lazarus..OMG)
13.Dean Young
Immortal said:LOL, wrong thread Rabbitoh2005.
Rabbitohs2005 said:yeah right