PJ Marshal
Coach
- Messages
- 13,525
well your suggestions for possible tahu replacements havnt been any good, nor do they give ben smith any justice...tbh i even doubt you watch any parra games with great depth
PJ Marshal said:well your suggestions for possible tahu replacements havnt been any good, nor do they give ben smith any justice...tbh i even doubt you watch any parra games with great depth
PJ Marshal said:well your suggestions for possible tahu replacements havnt been any good, nor do they give ben smith any justice...tbh i even doubt you watch any parra games with great depth
PJ Marshal said:wing is past his used by date...and he isnt a centre why would you replace a centre with a hooker :s seriouslly all those years of going to parra stadium havnt done much for your knowledge of the game
besides you judge your knowledge by how many games you go to than geeez become a coach
PJ Marshal said:craig wing made his name as a hooker lol...and played his best rep footy off the bench as a hooker for the blues n australia
and at the very most exmtreme emergency was shifted into the three quater line
versatile he may be but he isnt a long term replacement...he isnt a specialist centre..therefore to replace tahu youd want to either blood a promising threeqauter like we have inu or purchase a player in that position who is on the market.
as for finch well he has a good game every 7 or 8 if your lucky...im dubious over him from a footballing perspective but in terms of what we got...who else u wanna have there? sure blake green could be promoted but hey finch hasnt been anywrose than half of our squad n whos to say greens the answer. Maybe he will be in a few weeks time will tell....this isnt Rugby League on PS2 mate
Smartman said:The 2 players you guys mentioned (Roberts & Wing) off contract?
DanceMaster2000 said:Sorry mate, Wing made a name for himself before he even played First Grade, then bolted onto the scene with some great try's in the centre/halves position.
Finch is a half back imo, however, I doubt he has the ability to create something from nothing, where as Tim Smith does. However I still think Finch will be an asset somewhere down the line. Blake on the other hand is a solid player, but imo lacks that X factor, but i still feel he'll be pretty reliable in firsts.
Personally i'd have Mateo at 5/8 with Smith, reunite the old Flegg days when they were dynamic together. Mateo I have a huge wrap on.
DanceMaster2000 said:Those 4 you mention are hardly taking up there cap, Soward might be handy though...
Nutley wont go after 1 seasonm Beattie & Fitzgibbon aren't on a fortune i'm led to believe also...
TheParraboy said:fitzgibbon not on a fortune? led to believe from who?
he is probably equivalent to the roosters what Hindy is to us
regular aussie and State player whilst with the roosters
kicker
captain
PJ Marshal said:craig wing was consider an overated player back in those days mate..he didnt make a name for himself until 2002...sure he was on the scene before then but that was about it
beleive me by all means build a sinking ship with wing in your threeqauter line, you be putting a nail in a coffin of parras future
mateo is very much dymock styles and adds an extra dimension at lock....really a lock these days is a ball playing foward rather than a work horse back in the hey days of ray price n wayne pearce....so moving him to 5/8 imo wud be restricting his ability to just ball playing rather than a damaging runner of the ball ala wags n hindmarsh of 00-02