"Not held"?

[YEHHHBOYYYD]

How is that a question?

...and yet I am the moron?


The ref hadn't called held.
It is a try.

Maybe your blokes shouldn't have blown the 10 nil lead ....and lost a home semi in doing so.

hahahahahahahahahahahhaahahahaha.

 

[carcharias]

f**king hell no shit it was a try, the ref didn't call held so he was entitled to offload. The whole point of this thread was that many felt that the ref should have called held. Maybe your blokes should go half decent for once. I feel sorry for Jeremy Smith.

well, at least Jeremy's team managed to beat the Dragons this year.

 

[Hutty1986]

well, at least Jeremy's team managed to beat the Dragons this year.

I have a really good solution for us all. We'll swap you Matt Prior for Jeremy Smith.

Solved.

 

[Fast Eddie]

Haha congrats, at least while he is at the Sharks he is always going to get plenty of rest before the four nations.

 

[YEHHHBOYYYD]

Lol. That should be on catch of the day.

 

[Rebel]

The ref hadn't called held.
It is a try.

Maybe your blokes shouldn't have blown the 10 nil lead ....and lost a home semi in doing so.

NOBODY is disputing it wasn't a try and wtf about the home semi? Nobody is even talking about that. Thats got nothing to do with anything.

Basically. What fast Eddie said. He was well within his right to play on because the ref didnt call held. The purpose of the thread was to establish if the ref should have called held or not. Not some bullshit about missing out on a home semi or if he should have played on etc.

I literally don't understand how you can miss the point.

 

[carcharias]

..it is not even the worst one Beau Scott has got away with this year.

 

[Jason Maher]

If it had been Sam Thaiday instead of Beau Scott, would there still be a thread about it?

 

[Fast Eddie]

No obviously not because everyone has it out for Beau Scott. It was all because it was Beau Scott the great NSW centre.

 

[Jason Maher]

Way to miss the point moron. If it had been any team other than Saints who benefited from the call, there wouldn't be a thread.

 

[to_ddeath]

f**k, is this thing still alive? Someone should shoot the thread, round 25 is well & truly over....


T.

 

[Bumble]

You know who else was held? Trent Barrett.

and Matt Ridge.

 

[Jason Maher]

Barrett wasn't held! We wuz robbed!

 

[Big Pete]

If Thaiday had have been involved it would be a 500 post thread.

 

[Fast Eddie]

Way to miss the point moron. If it had been any team other than Saints who benefited from the call, there wouldn't be a thread.

Yes there would.

 

[betcats]

Way to miss the point moron. If it had been any team other than Saints who benefited from the call, there wouldn't be a thread.

Bullshit.

 

[Rebel]

Way to miss the point moron. If it had been any team other than Saints who benefited from the call, there wouldn't be a thread.

Nobody cares that it was the Dragons. I would of started the thread regardless of the team. Geez, Delusions of Grandeur.

 

[betcats]

Nobody cares that it was the Dragons. I would of started the thread regardless of the team. Geez, Delusions of Grandeur.

Its that St George arrogance.

 

[Crusher]

Not held, forward passes, over the line.....its been part of the game since 1908. If you want to fix it bring in technology to not make it part of the game.

Funny thing is, a video ref can rule on off side but not on forward passes. Momentum of the ball or no momentum its still a line on the field to use as a reference point.

 

[carcharias]

Nobody cares that it was the Dragons. I would of started the thread regardless of the team. Geez, Delusions of Grandeur.

mate you need to watch some more footy ......heaps more.
That was a pass that happens every week.

wait until a team scores in a grand final after running out over the sideline in the lead up...

or a team gets 7 tackles in a grand final.

or a tackled player taps and plays on and scores with a marker ..in a grand final

or a player gets awarded a penalty try in a world cup final with about a 10% chance of actually regaining a chip kick .


oh wait...hang on.