What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Penrith v Bondi Battlers (Finals Week One)

Chins get the wins

First Grade
Messages
8,508

The Penrith Panthers are looking to solidify themselves as one of the greatest teams of all time as they aim for a fourth-straight Premiership in 2024.

However, the powerhouse club has gone through its share of struggles in recent weeks, winning just two of their last four games whilst putting on disappointing performances in the process.
Although the club has been decimated by injuries and a significant absence of star Nathan Cleary, the Panthers enter a rare territory as they go into the finals series not as the favourites.

Panthers legend and current deputy chairman Greg Alexander was quizzed on the side’s recent form by SEN’s Andrew Voss and opened up on the club’s Premiership hopes.
“They’re in the poorest shape than they have been in the last four years going into the finals,” Voss said.

“When I say poorest, I’m not saying they’re poor but they’re in poorer shape than their high, lofty standards of the last four years.

“They’ve played in the last four Grand Finals in a row but this is the worst shape they’ve been going into finals.”

“I don’t think you’re wrong about that,” Alexander replied.

“I think it’s been evident over the last six weeks, even the wins that they’ve had, a miracle win against the Eels, a Nathan Cleary miracle against the Dolphins, they’ve lost two games and South Sydney are sitting (towards) the bottom of the table, it’s hard to get a gauge on how your team is going when you play Souths or a side down the bottom.

“If you’re talking about the Premiership bus, it was wobbly on Saturday night.”

Alexander admitted that whilst he isn’t ready to write off any teams yet, he did concede the Melbourne Storm are now the favourites to take it all out.

“I’m not going to write teams off yet but they (Melbourne) are favourites,” Alexander continued.

“But Penrith… their execution was off, there’s a few players that need to lift their form dramatically, you can’t win a comp off the back of someone going ok, you can’t even have one player in your team that’s just not playing his best, it just doesn’t happen.

“Nathan (Cleary) coming back in won’t rescue the side unless the rest of the team do their job.”

The Penrith Panthers open up the 2024 NRL Finals series against the Sydney Roosters at home on Friday night.
We don't even need Nathan IF the side actually put in 100%. We own Easts
 

Goonji

Juniors
Messages
461
Left field, start Jerome at halfback and Trent Toelau at five eight. Bring Nathan on after 20 minutes.
 

Iamback

Referee
Messages
20,444

The Penrith Panthers are looking to solidify themselves as one of the greatest teams of all time as they aim for a fourth-straight Premiership in 2024.

However, the powerhouse club has gone through its share of struggles in recent weeks, winning just two of their last four games whilst putting on disappointing performances in the process.
Although the club has been decimated by injuries and a significant absence of star Nathan Cleary, the Panthers enter a rare territory as they go into the finals series not as the favourites.

Panthers legend and current deputy chairman Greg Alexander was quizzed on the side’s recent form by SEN’s Andrew Voss and opened up on the club’s Premiership hopes.
“They’re in the poorest shape than they have been in the last four years going into the finals,” Voss said.

“When I say poorest, I’m not saying they’re poor but they’re in poorer shape than their high, lofty standards of the last four years.

“They’ve played in the last four Grand Finals in a row but this is the worst shape they’ve been going into finals.”

“I don’t think you’re wrong about that,” Alexander replied.

“I think it’s been evident over the last six weeks, even the wins that they’ve had, a miracle win against the Eels, a Nathan Cleary miracle against the Dolphins, they’ve lost two games and South Sydney are sitting (towards) the bottom of the table, it’s hard to get a gauge on how your team is going when you play Souths or a side down the bottom.

“If you’re talking about the Premiership bus, it was wobbly on Saturday night.”

Alexander admitted that whilst he isn’t ready to write off any teams yet, he did concede the Melbourne Storm are now the favourites to take it all out.

“I’m not going to write teams off yet but they (Melbourne) are favourites,” Alexander continued.

“But Penrith… their execution was off, there’s a few players that need to lift their form dramatically, you can’t win a comp off the back of someone going ok, you can’t even have one player in your team that’s just not playing his best, it just doesn’t happen.

“Nathan (Cleary) coming back in won’t rescue the side unless the rest of the team do their job.”

The Penrith Panthers open up the 2024 NRL Finals series against the Sydney Roosters at home on Friday night.

Yet another hater
 

maple_69

Bench
Messages
4,595
Damn I just clocked that Yeo is going to draw level with Scarts for most capped Panther in this game. What an achievement and what a man. Already a legend but another 5 years at this level (the bloke is built so well) and he’ll be a great of the game. Will be interesting to see if he or Nath ends up with the record. Would have said Nath a year ago but looking more likely Yeoy will hang onto it.
 

Munky

Coach
Messages
12,223
Damn I just clocked that Yeo is going to draw level with Scarts for most capped Panther in this game. What an achievement and what a man. Already a legend but another 5 years at this level (the bloke is built so well) and he’ll be a great of the game. Will be interesting to see if he or Nath ends up with the record. Would have said Nath a year ago but looking more likely Yeoy will hang onto it.

Yeoweh is the best player of the 2020s.

Has dominated the comp for five straight seasons.

Everything about his game his absolutely elite.
 

Fangs

Coach
Messages
13,946
On Cleary playing from the bench with Toelau starting.

Whats the idea? To not let him get too much attention early? He is our number one guy. I think it doesn't matter how many minutes he plays he is going to be heavily targeted (Especially by Angus Crichton).

Cleary's kicking is one advantage we have over the Roosters and we lose that benching him at any point.

I think the start is important against the Roosters. We can play from behind and win but that is hardly a plan. You get your best guys out there from the start don't you?

Also good luck to Toelau if it happens. I have no good reason to doubt him other than the fact he has played only 9 games. You are giving the bloke a big job in a very important match.
 

Panther Pete

Juniors
Messages
1,798
Not this year
I disagree. I am sure we turned it on against the Sharks for 80 mins and maybe against the Roosters and Dragons for 40 mins. Other than that we are light years from where we were in the past few seasons.
EDIT - I just looked it up and we got beaten by Dragons and just limped home against the Roosters. Obviously my memory is not as good as I thought.
 
Last edited:
Top