PF 2 vs Dogs

[TheFrog]

That is a very weird way to view things. His actual ability and what he actually did has a lot more to say then a winning/losing ratio for one player.

He is very much a below average first grader.

Well I don't know why this is being argued because he is out for the season, but I guarantee you if he was available Ivan Cleary, who seems to know a thing or two about the game, would select him.

 

[Randy81]

My point is quiet simple. Being picked for NZ in the halves is not always a big thing. E.g Ben Roberts.

Lastly who exactly did NZ have to pick from? Foran and Johnson are the only quality halves they have. Benji was gone.

Backs and forwards they have some absolute stars. Though the halves depth is not like Australia. I dare say if you threw up pretty much any other teams 6 or 7 they all pretty much would of been picked if they were kiwis.

Wouldn't have a clue on the availabilty of others. Though I expect there would be a few in the nrl and alot in the esl.
Notwithstanding the selection criteria, he actually played quite well vs Australia and has put in a number of great performances in fg for us. e.g 3 tries vs Warriors. I couldn't care less what he did at Wakefield. A worthy backup in my eyes.

As for the Cartwright and Browne debate as I said fair to call it a disagreement. We will see what happens when they are both back next year! Hopefully with the Dogs defending their title!

Lol agreed - to be confirmed on the circumstances

 

[Blues Riff]

Why are you in the Panther forum, and what point are you trying to make?
The Bulldogs have more of an excuse to lose?

 

[TheViking]

Well I don't know why this is being argued because he is out for the season, but I guarantee you if he was available Ivan Cleary, who seems to know a thing or two about the game, would select him.

Because Wallace is out. He would not start at any club.

 

[TheViking]

Why are you in the Panther forum, and what point are you trying to make?
The Bulldogs have more of an excuse to lose?

It was a friendly debate. There is no excuses. It was simply pointing out that both clubs have injuries. The excuse of Isaac John being out was one I found quiet funny and pointed that out.

Didn't know I needed a pass to venture on other sides of the forum?

Can I please have one?

 

[TheViking]

Wouldn't have a clue on the availabilty of others. Though I expect there would be a few in the nrl and alot in the esl.
Notwithstanding the selection criteria, he actually played quite well vs Australia and has put in a number of great performances in fg for us. e.g 3 tries vs Warriors. I couldn't care less what he did at Wakefield. A worthy backup in my eyes.


Lol agreed - to be confirmed on the circumstances

:lol:

Thanks for the friendly debate/discussion.

I'd say good luck.... BUT we both know I don't mean it

 

[Randy81]

:lol:

Thanks for the friendly debate/discussion.

I'd say good luck.... BUT we both know I don't mean it

Lol and you know we don't need it

 

[TheViking]

Lol and you know we don't need it

Surely this time the refs will make the right calls :lol:

If Lafai's try is disallowed again I will RIOT! :lol:

 

[forby]

If he drops the ball again it will be disallowed again!

 

[murraymob]

Because Wallace is out. He would not start at any club.

seen any canberra games lately

 

[Randy81]

Surely this time the refs will make the right calls :lol:

If Lafai's try is disallowed again I will RIOT! :lol:

Don't have seperation on the way down and there won't be an opportunity to disallow haha

 

[Big Mick]

Surely this time the refs will make the right calls :lol:

If Lafai's try is disallowed again I will RIOT! :lol:

I know right that last try of the Dogs they allowed of a 2m forward pass was ridiculous! :sarcasm:

 

[TheViking]

seen any canberra games lately

Yep.

Campese is better. So is Cornish. So was Milford.

They also recruited Sam Williams back. Yet again better.

As for the Lafai try, we all know it was a try. Hell the NRL came out and admitted the ref screwed up! :lol:

Not funny

 

[MaxPower]

Yep.

Campese is better. So is Cornish. So was Milford.

They also recruited Sam Williams back. Yet again better.

As for the Lafai try, we all know it was a try. Hell the NRL came out and admitted the ref screwed up! :lol:

Not funny

I laughed.

 

[TheViking]

I laughed.

Revenge shall be sweet :lol:

 

[Randy81]

Yep.

Campese is better. So is Cornish. So was Milford.

They also recruited Sam Williams back. Yet again better.

As for the Lafai try, we all know it was a try. Hell the NRL came out and admitted the ref screwed up! :lol:

Not funny

To quote mr ricky gervais "are you havin' a laugh?"

 

[Randy81]

I know right that last try of the Dogs they allowed of a 2m forward pass was ridiculous! :sarcasm:

And it was a short pass. Went further forward then it did sideways

 

[TheViking]

To quote mr ricky gervais "are you havin' a laugh?"

Not at all. Cornish is a future gun. Sam Williams is far better. Milford certainly is too.

Campese is crap now. Isaac John was never good.:lol:

 

[murraymob]

Yep.

Campese is better. So is Cornish. So was Milford.

They also recruited Sam Williams back. Yet again better.

As for the Lafai try, we all know it was a try. Hell the NRL came out and admitted the ref screwed up! :lol:

Not funny

is mister spoon better because thats all those blokes achieved.Sam williams could not make the dragons team a reserve grader on a good day

 

[GongPanther]

Supremely confident in a Panthers win over the Bulldogs on Saturday.

Penrith to play Souths in the Grand Final.

The telling point will be that Dogs will be better for the experience.

The Dogs players will be feeling privileged to have played against a team such as this current Panthers squad after fulltime when they are lamenting their loss.

It's best to have played against,and to be defeated by such a quality outfit such as ours in this era of our sport,than not to have played at all.

Dogs lucky just to have made it this far.

Must be kind to Kennels month.:lol: