Legend,
An excellent initiative indeed,this thread.
From my perspective, and that is one of chronic lurker and occassional contributor to this forum, and also one who was a nominated and defeated candidate(rightly so) as a manager of this site not long after you established it,may I offer the following observations.
1.This forum seems to have taken a life of its own in an elite manner.The reason for its creation was to exclude the "I love Girds" and other teeny bopper shit.I reckoned at the time that may be a mistake.I mean "I love Girds" could grow into a person who becomes a long term member.
2.The majority of members here write detailed posts, on varying topics that are very well argued and after a lengthy period,it may become a case of familiarity breeds contempt.
3.This thread in itself has been a forum for the Broncos fans to spell out their disenchantment.If they are that concerned then one would have thought it would be worthy of its own thread.If that is the only issue to deal with then really this thread would not be in existence.
4.To me, interestingly enough, the contributors on this forum are more reasoned and generally willing to accept anothers point of view.I don't have a problem with some creative abuse and a person expressing their point of view passionately.
5.Crucially,this site has lost some entertainment value.It is a bit like the ABC news, respected,informative and reliable.That is great for the regulars,but never likely to attract and keep the ratings higher than an expected level.
6.Simply put,there is notenough footytalk.For footy talk,I go to WORL and only the Dragons site.I could put a post here about Farrar being sacked(hopefully it is true) and it would radidly sink.
7.To me there have been some defining threads that have caused some folk to lose faith in their fellow posters(I am one of those).The thread that caused me to think that there are better places to spend time was the one about the cops.Some argued vehemently about their sanctity and piousness and took the issue personally, when others said they were just corrupt.I mean that is, Iknow, a simplification, but the level of immaturity displayed by people who joined a community for more intellectual stimulationwas surprising.
8.My personal point of view is that basically, I really enjoy my time here, but it is a fairly predictable forum, but I like the ABC news.
9.Please do not hesitate to criticise anything I have said.