Q: Best club over the last 5 years?

[stormbati]

correct - the Storm have won one premiership.

Thank you for clarifying that.

Oh, no, sorry let me clarify.

The Storm won the 2007 and 2009 Premierships by defeating Manly and Parra respectively.
The Storm were later caught of salary-cap rorting and were stripped of both those premierships.
So I was lucky enough to witness these GF's and experienced great joy from it. You'd have to win one to understand.
I also know what it's like to have Premierships taken away.

 

[muzby]

Oh, no, sorry let me clarify.

The Storm won the 2007 and 2009 Premierships by defeating Manly and Parra respectively.
The Storm were later caught of salary-cap rorting and were stripped of both those premierships.
So I was lucky enough to witness these GF's and experienced great joy from it. You'd have to win one to understand.
I also know what it's like to have Premierships taken away.

no-one is questioning whether the storm actually won a game of football on the first weekend in october in 2007 & 2009..

where the debate lies is your belief that these ill-gotten premierships are the basis for making the storm the best team over the past 5 years..

they cheated. fact.

therefore they cannot be classed as the best..

 

[stormbati]

no-one is questioning whether the storm actually won a game of football on the first weekend in october in 2007 & 2009..

where the debate lies is your belief that these ill-gotten premierships are the basis for making the storm the best team over the past 5 years..

they cheated. fact.

therefore they cannot be classed as the best..

Yes, correct. We are not premiers. I can still watch it with great joy

 

[DJShaksta]

Oh, no, sorry let me clarify.

The Storm won the 2007 and 2009 Premierships by defeating Manly and Parra respectively.
The Storm were later caught of salary-cap rorting and were stripped of both those premierships.
So I was lucky enough to witness these GF's and experienced great joy from it. You'd have to win one to understand.
I also know what it's like to have Premierships taken away.

Okayyyyy...........
So basically, the Storm have won one premiership.

 

[Hutty1986]

Oh, no, sorry let me clarify.

The Storm won the 2007 and 2009 Premierships by defeating Manly and Parra respectively.
The Storm were later caught of salary-cap rorting and were stripped of both those premierships.
So I was lucky enough to witness these GF's and experienced great joy from it. You'd have to win one to understand.
I also know what it's like to have Premierships taken away.

:lol::lol::lol: Are you actually serious?

Your team of salary cap cheats might as well have been out on the harbour in GI's speedboat those Sunday afternoons because what your illegally-assembled side did then means sweet f*ck all.

I honestly can't tell if you believe the deluded, blind dribble you are posting

 

[gUt]

Nothing like winning a premiership! Even when its taken away from you. Better that than never winning at all eh

Definitely not.

 

[oval]

Great photo. Nothing like winning a premiership! Even when its taken away from you. Better that than never winning at all eh

Some say it is better to have loved and lost than to have never loved at all...

 

[stormbati]

Some say it is better to have loved and lost than to have never loved at all...

Exactly my brother

 

[melb_belle]

Exactly my brother

I have to disagree, I would rather have not been rorting the cap and lost those 2 GF's instead of having them striped last year.
The feeling of having those striped last year and all the salary cap drama was a lot worse than losing the GF against Manly in 08.

 

[stormbati]

I have to disagree, I would rather have not been rorting the cap and lost those 2 GF's instead of having them striped last year.
The feeling of having those striped last year and all the salary cap drama was a lot worse than losing the GF against Manly in 08.

traitor, im having some trolling fun

 

[Jason Maher]

The answer to the OP question is obviously Souff Sinney. Look how many members they have!

 

[muzby]

traitor, im having some trolling fun

trolling is no excuse for stupidity..

 

[Pittwater Legend]

If you asked me which team could possibly rort the cap and get pumped by 40-0 in a grand final my answer would be lol@souffs.

 

[Patorick]

Top 8 win/loss percentages over the past 5 years (draw counts as half a win and half a loss):

1. Melbourne - 72.1%
2. Manly - 65.9%
3. Dragons - 57.9%
4. Brisbane - 57.1%
5. Tigers - 53.2%
6. Warriors - 50.8%
7. Titans - 46.8%
8. Eels - 46.0%

Souths were 13th with 44.2% in case you were wondering.

So yeah.

 

[Hutty1986]

Top 8 win/loss percentages over the past 5 years (draw counts as half a win and half a loss):

1. Manly - 65.9%
2. Dragons - 57.9%
3. Brisbane - 57.1%
4. Tigers - 53.2%
5. Warriors - 50.8%
6. Titans - 46.8%
7. Eels - 46.0%

Souths were 13th with 44.2% in case you were wondering.

So yeah.

That's an interesting read. Geez that's pretty bloody good consistency from Manly during that time

 

[kbw]

I have to say Melbourne, regardless of their "indesgressions".

No way would it be Saints, win 1 GF and choke 4 out of 5 years, don't make a great team

 

[Fibroman]

pitching wedge

 

[Matt23]

pitching wedge

:lol:

 

[Jason Maher]

I have to say Melbourne, regardless of their "indesgressions".

No way would it be Saints, win 1 GF and choke 4 out of 5 years, don't make a great team

Does this shit need to be brought up in every single f**king thread? :roll:

 

[muzby]

Does this shit need to be brought up in every single f**king thread? :roll:

because unfortunately some people are a one trick pony, and they can't discuss anything else..


oh yeah..

lol@souffs..