RD7 V Tigers ANZ Stadium

[emjaycee]

Haha - the "shit judge" thing was a sly reference to Maroubra Eel.

But that's certainly some food for thought there - I have been thinking for a while now we need a quality starting prop to help Mannah out a bit more. We might then see what he is REALLY capable of.

Maybe not a Big Bopper, but Mossop???

 

[Maroubra Eel]

Haha - the "shit judge" thing was a sly reference to Maroubra Eel.

But that's certainly some food for thought there - I have been thinking for a while now we need a quality starting prop to help Mannah out a bit more. We might then see what he is REALLY capable of.

Hey leave me out of it buddy.

 

[Y2Eel]

You're not a shit judge mate, and I didn't criticise Mannah. Was responding to the usual criticism on this site of any player who is favourably compared to one of our club favourites. But to be honest, if I were,say, Manly looking for a new prop I'd be interested in both players, but for the same wage I'd be very tempted to go for Woods (I might of course end up with egg on my face). Mannah is certainly a 'metre eater' but he does so with his 'head down' mainly. Woods 'seems' more dangerous when on the charge. Now of course, Mannah might also look a very different player if he was paired with a big bopper at the other prop position.

When was Woods favorably compared to Mannah?

I just mentioned Mannah as i believe he outplayed him , Which he did...

Maybe Mannah needs to start acting like a turd to get noticed? Get his leadership skills from Woods maybe?

 

[Barry O'Speedwagon]

When was Woods favorably compared to Mannah?

I just mentioned Mannah as i believe he outplayed him , Which he did...

....Well you mentioned it in the context of 'not getting' the Origin talk re Woods, and followed it up with the assertion that Mannah outplayed him. There ain't too many free prop spots in the Origin team (Gallen has one surely).

They're different styles of prop, and I can perfectly understand why selectors might opt for Woods.

 

[Y2Eel]

....Well you mentioned it in the context of 'not getting' the Origin talk re Woods, and followed it up with the assertion that Mannah outplayed him. There ain't too many free prop spots in the Origin team (Gallen has one surely).

They're different styles of prop, and I can perfectly understand why selectors might opt for Woods.

I mentioned Mannah played better than him on Monday... Thats because he did, no one else said a thing about Woods outplaying him or deserving the NSW spot more than Mannah besides you...


I was responding to the Woods two Finger salute to the crowd...

 

[Barry O'Speedwagon]

I mentioned Mannah played better than him on Monday... Thats because he did, no one else said a thing about Woods outplaying him or deserving the NSW spot more than Mannah besides you...


I was responding to the Woods two Finger salute to the crowd...

Here's what you said immediately following the post about the two finger salute:

"Guy is the biggest toss pot.. Do not understand the NSW talk either outplayed by Mannah.."

Toss pot comment is clearly about the 2 finger salute (and you're dead right). So what does the 'NSW talk' sentence refer to if it is not about whether he or not he is more deserving than Mannah?

 

[Eelementary]

Maybe not a Big Bopper, but Mossop???

Maybe - he's not "huge", but he's a solid bloke and a real workhorse. He's a quality player IMO.

 

[Eelementary]

Hey leave me out of it buddy.

Couldn't resist.