What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Rd8: Parramatta v Dragons LIVE GAME DAY thread May 5th 2019

hindy111

Post Whore
Messages
63,263
Don’t forget the binning as well

Game was done by then. Lets be serious for 5 f**king mins. I mean Frizzel is there best forward and Norman is there dominant half. Great comeback win sure. Had those two played the full 80mins is the result different? A high chance it is.
 

strider

Post Whore
Messages
79,024
I think it is a stupid rule but the rule is if the ball leaves the in gaol (in play) in order for it to be ruled dead it must bounce first, a player cannot step out and touch the ball dead.

I can't explain the logic but i just know it is the rule. I don't know if it applies to anywhere other than the in goal i have just seen it applied multiple times over the years.
I dont believe that it MUST bounce dead. I believe it is at the discretion of the referee as to whether it is out of play.

I used to believe it had to bounce, but remember cases where a ball had clearly gone past the pane of the deadball line and a player grabs it before it bounces. The ref still called it dead cos no player was going to get it.

I dont believe todays was a chance of any st george player getting it ... but i guess it was still there abouts the field of play
 

84 Baby

Referee
Messages
29,908
Game was done by then. Lets be serious for 5 f**king mins. I mean Frizzel is there best forward and Norman is there dominant half. Great comeback win sure. Had those two played the full 80mins is the result different? A high chance it is.
We scored our first points when they were both on field. Norman was still on field when we took lead.

I guess we can’t take in to account Canbra and Dogs results against Moanly because of all of Manlys injuries?
 

strider

Post Whore
Messages
79,024
So, I ask again, I think I've seen it happen with players catching bombs. Or am I mistaken?
You cant put your foot out and touch the ball that is still in the field of play in the ingoal area, like you can in the normal field of play .... but as i said in the previous post, i dont believe the ball must bounce to be considered dead, it just needs to have crossed out of the plane of the ingoal bounds and not be still able to be played at by an attacker
 

TheParraboy

Moderator
Staff member
Messages
69,094
Game was done by then. Lets be serious for 5 f**king mins. I mean Frizzel is there best forward and Norman is there dominant half. Great comeback win sure. Had those two played the full 80mins is the result different? A high chance it is.


plays violin
 

Happy MEel

First Grade
Messages
9,869
Game was done by then. Lets be serious for 5 f**king mins. I mean Frizzel is there best forward and Norman is there dominant half. Great comeback win sure. Had those two played the full 80mins is the result different? A high chance it is.
You can’t ignore the fact that Norman went off after Sivo snapped him in half!!

That was an outstanding shot.
 

hindy111

Post Whore
Messages
63,263
Funny how you keep finding reasons to put the side down...

Stick to Penrith.

No. Last season when we where losing I pointed out how nothing went our way. And at start of this season Inalso told everyone we would be decent. And how our signings and less injuries would make a huge difference. I also said we should start with Sivo and that MJ was not done while every merkin said he was past it. Luck has been on our side this year but we also have yet to see us with our top 17.

Can we win comp? Bar Roosters and Souths we have as much chance as anyone else. I do like Sharks however.
 

strider

Post Whore
Messages
79,024
Game was done by then. Lets be serious for 5 f**king mins. I mean Frizzel is there best forward and Norman is there dominant half. Great comeback win sure. Had those two played the full 80mins is the result different? A high chance it is.
Yet when we lost our best forward (Brown) 10 mins into the game in round one you dont think its an excuse for the Panthers to get a leg up .... bit of consistency mate
 

84 Baby

Referee
Messages
29,908
Fun Fact:

We beat Storm by 4 points next week, we over take them into the top 4

How likely is that opportunity after 9 rounds at the start of the year?
Not even. A 3 point win will do it. Also if we win and Canbra lose by combined 19 points we over take them too
 

hindy111

Post Whore
Messages
63,263
Yet when we lost our best forward (Brown) 10 mins into the game in round one you dont think its an excuse for the Panthers to get a leg up .... bit of consistency mate

Yes. It shows how poor they are and how not listening to the duke and bringing in Bennet f**ked them. Now hope they rot like an apple.
 

IFR33K

Coach
Messages
17,043
impressed with the food today

Mate had the chicken deluxe sandwich, filling was quite generous $7.50
I had the Italian sandwich was was very nice as well same price

He is a coffee nut and searched everywhere and found only one place that sold coffee at the stadium and the queue was very long (this was during the wenty game). So not sure if there is a demand to put in more sections with coffee

Having sat at the Cronin terrace in our first game, we had GA tickets today (North side) and it threw me off a little.The GA section is actually on the higher tier (steep steps) of the stadium, whereas I assumed it would be the bottom deck. No complaints, view brilliant, we were about halfway up


Ordered coffee and waited a full hour for it. No bs. And it tasted friggen horrible.
 

IFR33K

Coach
Messages
17,043
Game was done by then. Lets be serious for 5 f**king mins. I mean Frizzel is there best forward and Norman is there dominant half. Great comeback win sure. Had those two played the full 80mins is the result different? A high chance it is.


Ffs :face_palm:♂️
 

Latest posts

Top