What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Return of gaz

Ronnie Dobbs

Coach
Messages
17,746
HOw do they line up, hypothetically if he does come back & everyone is fit at the back end of this year?

3. Gasnier

11. Creagh
12. Scott
13. Young

14. Smith
15. Costigan
16. Green
17. Saffy

Merrin, Thorby, Fien?
 

Divine

Bench
Messages
3,271
If Gallop wants him back then a gilt-edged 3rd party deal might be the go. If at first you don't succeed...
 

TheRev

Coach
Messages
12,905
The NRL will be keen to get him back for the good publicity.. but they need to be 100% sure they dot their i's & cross their t's with the storm scandal.

We might need to let someone go early (if there was someone who wanted to leave), and Gaz if hes fair-dinkum will need to come back for sweet f-all in 2010 until we have some room in our 2011 cap, if thats even possible, I cant think of any big name players we might get rid of to make room...

Hopefully not 2 many clubs have room under their cap this year, but even if they did, Gaz has hopefully learnt his lesson (about being a money grabber), im sure he would love to play for a club thatis pushing for the premiership, instead of a Newcastle or Souths or whatever.
 

Saint Jack

Juniors
Messages
161
im sure he would love to play for a club thatis pushing for the premiership, instead of a Newcastle or Souths or whatever.

:)

We could back end it. Coops is nearing the end, and Saffy is off.
 

Divine

Bench
Messages
3,271
...I'll chip in $50


The Mercury has their say...
http://www.illawarramercury.com.au/...to-sign-mark-gasnier/1826450.aspx?storypage=0




Dragons to sign Mark Gasnier?


Plenty of Dragons fans would be salivating at the news that Mark Gasnier may be about to wear the red V again.His two-year deal with Stade Francais is over and, according to news reports, Le Gaz is keen to return home after his father-in-law suffered a health scare.
The Dragons are the frontrunners to sign the centre because, when the club let him go in 2008 it was on the condition that he not play for another NRL club before 2012.
Obviously, the biggest hurdle to jump would be the salary cap. That’s even if the club has enough money left to sign the centre with the famous last name.
One thing you can bet on - in the wake of the Storm’s salary cap rorting you can bet the Dragons will keep the financial side of Gasnier’s signing completely above board.
I have to say I haven’t been the biggest fan of Gasnier. That’s mainly because I got sick of his habit of toying with leaving the club to either go and play in the UK Super League or switch codes to rugby.
Initially the idea of him leaving bothered me but it soon became a case of ‘‘look, Mark, if you’re going to go, then just go. Quit stringing us along and make up your mind’’. I think the Australian Rugby Union felt the same way - they’ve made him several offers over the years only to have him knock them back at the last minute.
As for his ability on the field, he was great but had a tendency to try and win the game every time he touched the ball. To be fair, it seemed he was forced into that role by a game plan that must have read ‘‘if you’re in trouble on the scoreboard, give it to Gasnier’’.
I’d be very, very keen to see how Gasnier would go under Wayne Bennett, where he would be relieved of that pressure to win the match and would given a specific role to play.
He could also provide the club with that elusive ‘‘X factor’’.
But the biggest question for me is this - who misses out? Which player gets dropped to make room for Gaz? You’d be mad to drop (or even move) fullback Darius Boyd or tryscoring freak Brett Morris. No way do you drop the defensive giant Beau Scott and the similarly impregnable Matt Cooper.
Half or five-eighth are simply out of the question - I’ve got bad memories of the last time we tried that experiment. That leaves the only possible backline option is moving winger Jason Nightingale back to his previous role as a utility bench player.
That said, I’m not sure how Gasnier would go on the wing. Nor would I particularly like to see Nightingale used in the scrum again - I like his work on the wing.
But I guess, if Wayne wants Gaz he’ll work out a place to put him.




































Comment *
Please enter your Comment

Maximum of 1200 characters





beacon.gif









Mark Gasnier at his last game at WIN Stadium. Picture: WAYNE VENABLES
 
Last edited:

dragonfire

Bench
Messages
3,117
HOw do they line up, hypothetically if he does come back & everyone is fit at the back end of this year?

3. Gasnier

11. Creagh
12. Scott
13. Young

14. Smith
15. Costigan
16. Green
17. Saffy

Merrin, Thorby, Fien?

Boyd
Morris
Cooper
Gasnier
Nightingale
Soward
Hornby
Weyman
Priddis
Hunt
Smith
Creagh
Young

Scott
Costigan
Prior
Green

Yep i could live with that team. Thats 3 starting quality guys on the bench. Would be sweet to get Gasnier back. Would make it even harder for teams as we would have a structured and lethal left hand edge and then you get to deal with Soward and Gasnier on the other side of the field
 

Ronnie Dobbs

Coach
Messages
17,746
Boyd
Morris
Cooper
Gasnier
Nightingale
Soward
Hornby
Weyman
Priddis
Hunt
Smith
Creagh
Young

Scott
Costigan
Prior
Green

Yep i could live with that team. Thats 3 starting quality guys on the bench. Would be sweet to get Gasnier back. Would make it even harder for teams as we would have a structured and lethal left hand edge and then you get to deal with Soward and Gasnier on the other side of the field

Knew I was forgetting someone. Matty Prior, he's a must. What about if Fien gets back? Thats 4 starters at any other club riding the pine. Regardless, we are already flush with depth.
 

dragonfire

Bench
Messages
3,117
umm Fien/Priddis to miss out as Costigan/Young can both cover hooker. Emmett has shown he is also a guy who is top 17 material. Gotta love our depth
 

Cagey Mac

Bench
Messages
4,005
HOw do they line up, hypothetically if he does come back & everyone is fit at the back end of this year?

3. Gasnier

11. Creagh
12. Scott
13. Young

14. Smith
15. Costigan
16. Green
17. Saffy

Merrin, Thorby, Fien?
I’d be looking at something lie this

3. Gasnier

11 . Creagh
12.. Smith
13. Scott
14 Young
15. Costigan
16. Prior
17. Merrin / Green

Fein will replace Priddis when appropriate as I don’t think that we can afford a specialist hooker on the bench when we have Young available in multiple roles and Priddis has be good but Fein offers more flair and options in attack.
Saffy is gone IMO and Merrin will only get better with more game time each week
He ultimately will be the perfect bookend for Weyman
 
Last edited:

Zoggy

Juniors
Messages
223
Rothfield was on the tripple M this morning , Gus Worland asked how certain he was with Mark signing with the Dragons and Rothfield replied "90%"

Im having mixed emotions, he would be good for us but no one deserves to miss out. How do you think the players are feeling ? :?:?:?
 

SilentAssassin

Juniors
Messages
660
Boyd
Morris
Cooper
Gasnier
Nightingale
Soward
Hornby
Weyman
Priddis
Hunt
Smith
Creagh
Young

Scott
Costigan
Prior
Green

Yep i could live with that team. Thats 3 starting quality guys on the bench. Would be sweet to get Gasnier back. Would make it even harder for teams as we would have a structured and lethal left hand edge and then you get to deal with Soward and Gasnier on the other side of the field

That is an awesome team. I know everyone loves Green but the only change I'd make is Merrin for Green.
 

Cagey Mac

Bench
Messages
4,005
That is an awesome team. I know everyone loves Green but the only change I'd make is Merrin for Green.

I was touting Green as Mr Reliable but he did drop the ball three times against the Sharks
Merrin's ability to get across the line may be the difference between winning and losing come September
 

Cagey Mac

Bench
Messages
4,005
Rothfield was on the tripple M this morning , Gus Worland asked how certain he was with Mark signing with the Dragons and Rothfield replied "90%"

Im having mixed emotions, he would be good for us but no one deserves to miss out. How do you think the players are feeling ? :?:?:?

Most are aware that Gaz got screwed in his 3rd party arrangements
Look at the decimation of the team of late and we haven't had the rep season yet
Getting the entire team fit is virtually impossible and even in the best case scenario, most players benefit from a rest to recover from niggling injuries that they are normally forced to play through
 

saint-colesy

Juniors
Messages
2,110
1. Boyd
2. Morris
3. Gasnier
4. Cooper
5. Nightingale
6. Soward
7. Hornby
8. Weyman
9. Priddis
10. Hunt
11. Smith
12. Creagh
13. Young
-------------
14. Prior
15. Scott
16. Merrin
17. Green/Thorby/Costigan
 

Zoggy

Juniors
Messages
223
Most are aware that Gaz got screwed in his 3rd party arrangements
Look at the decimation of the team of late and we haven't had the rep season yet
Getting the entire team fit is virtually impossible and even in the best case scenario, most players benefit from a rest to recover from niggling injuries that they are normally forced to play through

Thats true. I was having the assumption that we will all be fit and ready to play, there will always be someone sitting out with an injury.
 

boxa777

Coach
Messages
12,388
Irrespective of whether the giant Tazo comes back, JDog Smith and Beau are not bench players.

Moving round the jigsaw to me suggests a return for Smith into the tight middle backrow and Young to the bench.
 

Latest posts

Top