RIP NRL

[carcharias]

H

He was yelling "is it 6 again?" while waving his arm. Given the noise in the stadium it's fair to assume that most Raiders players would take that as 6 again. They weren't standing around talking, they were trying to run a final play.

So he didn’t actually say 6 again nor was it 6 again?

Who’s to say Raiders don’t drop ball the next tackle anyway
Or kick it dead?
Or throw a pass that Latrell intercepts and goes the length?

It probably had no impact on the outcome of the game.

 

[carcharias]

When the Cronulla groupie enters the argument you know the thread has reached it's nadir.

31 pages of crying

Haha

Love it.

 

[AlwaysGreen]

31 pages of crying

Haha

Love it.

29 of those by the roosters

Love

It

 

[carcharias]

Yeah right

 

[carcharias]

Just watched the replay
As if Whighton didn’t know it was the 5th.
You can clearly hear the ref yell 5.
He is holding his arm up for long enough for them to know it is the 5th
You can’t hear him say “6 again” or even “is it 6 again “.

 

[Generalzod]

Fox sports idiots are calling it the worst decision ever lol

 

[carcharias]

Fox sports idiots are calling it the worst decision ever lol

You can tell by the way pretty much none of the raiders complained.
They f**king heard him call 5.
It was like a half arsed cricket appeal when everybody knows it was missing the stumps by a foot.

 

[Maximus]

FFS Cronk got 10 in the bin for hardly anything
That was embarrassing
That’s not rugby league
That’s f**kin shit

Yet a ref call that was almost instantaneously corrected is the major talking point.
Did he even say 6 again??
Is there any audio of it?

Why are you commenting if you don't actually know what happened?

 

[Maximus]

Just watched the replay
As if Whighton didn’t know it was the 5th.
You can clearly hear the ref yell 5.
He is holding his arm up for long enough for them to know it is the 5th
You can’t hear him say “6 again” or even “is it 6 again “.

Which video are you watching? He clearly says 6 again, then pauses and says is it

https://www.foxsports.com.au/video/league/nrl/six-again-refs-audio!749967

 

[carcharias]

Can’t hear 6 again or is it 6 again

Definitely hear him yell
last
Last one
To both players who had the ball.

 

[gerg]

Aggrieved but you can bet your bottom dollar not one other person would have felt sorry for us nor would there have been the media frenzy we saw.

If it went against us and we weren't good enough to defend it then so be it.

Most rugby league fans have absolutely no sympathy for Roosters, Broncos or Storm, and I have absolutely no idea why....

 

[carcharias]

Why are you commenting if you don't actually know what happened?

I didn’t hear him say it.
I asked was there audio of it that I hadn’t heard.
Is that ok with you?

 

[Maximus]

Can’t hear 6 again or is it 6 again

Definitely hear him yell
last
Last one
To both players who had the ball.

Watch the one I just linked. It's the actual refs audio. Like I said, why are you commenting when you don't know what actually happened?

 

[Maximus]

I didn’t hear him say it.
I asked was there audio of it that I hadn’t heard.
Is that ok with you?

Well maybe rather than coming in saying it didn't happen, you should have listened to literally everyone in this thread who said it happened, and the clear video/audio evidence of it happening.

 

[Canard]

Watch the one I just linked. It's the actual refs audio. Like I said, why are you commenting when you don't know what actually happened?

The kid is a low effort troll, ignore him.

 

[DeeJ]

So he didn’t actually say 6 again nor was it 6 again?

Who’s to say Raiders don’t drop ball the next tackle anyway
Or kick it dead?
Or throw a pass that Latrell intercepts and goes the length?

It probably had no impact on the outcome of the game.

I've thought about this. Handing over the ball on the 10m line with their defensive line reset is actually a decent option.

It was good ball play by Radley who opened them up a few tackles later.

 

[carcharias]

Well maybe rather than coming in saying it didn't happen, you should have listened to literally everyone in this thread who said it happened, and the clear video/audio evidence of it happening.

I didn’t say it didn’t happen ya f**king dope

I actually asked if it happened
You even quoted me asking

FFS
The refs audio is not what the players hear either.
So I’d say the ch9 version would be way closer to what they would’ve heard.

Regardless
The correct call was made and they had plenty of time to kick.

 

[The Rosco]

Just watched the replay
As if Whighton didn’t know it was the 5th.
You can clearly hear the ref yell 5.
He is holding his arm up for long enough for them to know it is the 5th
You can’t hear him say “6 again” or even “is it 6 again “.

You can hear him "ask" is it 6 again. Then he clearly gives the signal for 6 again. This arm/hand signal is held up long enough and clear enough to denote 6 again. Before the changing of any minds.

 

[Walt Flanigan]

Lol you bored Carch?

All good, I’m sure the Sharks next atrocity isn’t too far away...

 

[Generalzod]

I really don't know how it was called six again when clearly it wasn't, I knew it and I've already gone through a half of a bottle of Ouzo.