Round 1 V Eels

[billypilgrimnz]

Ah, pages-long Luke vs. mx. back and forths. The footy season is truly back.

 

[mxlegend99]

Holy shit.... enough with the bloody trial games... no one played well... do we drop all of them???

You said he always put in 110%. Which was a lie.

He was the worst of a bad bunch AND he no longer has a future with us.

 

[umina panther]

You said he always put in 110%. Which was a lie.

He was the worst of a bad bunch AND he no longer has a future with us.

The issue is time is running out with the cap. Gus punted on Maloney ffs. Its all in for the next few years then rebuild again. Peach has to play

 

[Luke Bowden]

You said he always put in 110%. Which was a lie.

He was the worst of a bad bunch AND he no longer has a future with us.

It was a trial, why would you go balls out and injure yourself trying to put a hit on?

That helps no one. It’s no difference to an opposed training session... All the players would have been told to take it easy and get through the game unscathed.

It’s not rocket science.

 

[mxlegend99]

It was a trial, why would you go balls out and injure yourself trying to put a hit on?

That helps no one. It’s no difference to an opposed training session... All the players would have been told to take it easy and get through the game unscathed.

It’s not rocket science.

Youre creating a story based on what you want to be true and nothing more What I said is atleast based on facts.

You claim to know the coaches instructions. And what players are thinking at different times of different days duting different events.

You did the same thing with Moylan. Trying to spin the story as if you know anything when its all fiction.

 

[Luke Bowden]

Youre creating a story based on what you want to be true and nothing more What I said is atleast based on facts.

You claim to know the coaches instructions. And what players are thinking at different times of different days duting different events.

You did the same thing with Moylan. Trying to spin the story as if you know anything when its all fiction.

I’m not claiming anything, you are. Stop putting words in my mouth. Where have i “Claimed” anything like that. I thought you were better than that. Obviously not.

I’m saying that trial form means nothing, never has, never will. Especially for established first graders.

Players sign contracts and leave clubs. That happens, certainly doesn’t mean they don’t care about the club they are leaving.

I see no reason to believe that Peach won’t Continue to put in like he always has.

Now, either come up with something better than, he sucked in a meaningless trail game or drop it.

Your arguement is boring.

 

[mxlegend99]

Well you're the one not allowing anyone to have an opinion on team selections or speculate on a players future because you know exactly what the coach, Gus and Peachey are all thinking at any given time.

 

[Luke Bowden]

Well you're the one not allowing anyone to have an opinion on team selections or speculate on a players future because you know exactly what the coach, Gus and Peachey are all thinking at any given time.

When did I say you weren’t allowed an opinion?

When did I say I know exactly what any of those people are thinking?

The comment I made was what Gus said on Fox sport when asked about Peachey’s offer from the tits.

Stop putting words in my mouth.

You think he shouldn’t be picked. That’s fine.

I disagree and you are unable to give a decent reason for me to change my mind.

 

[franklin2323]

The issue is time is running out with the cap. Gus punted on Maloney ffs. Its all in for the next few years then rebuild again. Peach has to play

He doesn't need to start. Once May is back and maybe not even the bench... Until then though

 

[franklin2323]

Mister perfectionist playing under a coach who expects perfection and along side his mates of 10+ years. I'm not really surprised.

If Peachey plays his best he should be there. It's a matter of if he wants it.

This year might be when Cronk drops off

 

[umina panther]

He doesn't need to start. Once May is back and maybe not even the bench... Until then though

100%.

 

[mxlegend99]

When did I say you weren’t allowed an opinion?

When did I say I know exactly what any of those people are thinking?

The comment I made was what Gus said on Fox sport when asked about Peachey’s offer from the tits.

Stop putting words in my mouth.

You think he shouldn’t be picked. That’s fine.

I disagree and you are unable to give a decent reason for me to change my mind.

That’s nonsense. He’s a Panther till he leaves next season. He has no loyalty to the Titans until he starts with them. He’s a professional athlete for pity sake.

He’s signed a 1.5m 3 year contract with the Titans, starting next year. It’s all about money for Peachey and setting his family up. That deal is done.

Why does anyone think he now has some sort of allegiance to the Titans?? He’s just completed an off-season with his best mates and is about to start the year! All he would be worried about is winning the comp with the rest of his team mates. Not what his future team is up to.

It was a trial, why would you go balls out and injure yourself trying to put a hit on?

That helps no one. It’s no difference to an opposed training session... All the players would have been told to take it easy and get through the game unscathed.

It’s not rocket science.

Your argument for any reason put forward is making up what people were/are thinking.

You did the same thing in the Sharks forum when the Sharks fans thought Moylan would get an early release.

Fact is no one knows any of those things. We're all taking guesses basically at what's motivating these people.

 

[mxlegend99]

This year might be when Cronk drops off

We can only hope.

Be hilarious if Cronk turns to shit and Pearce has a career best season.

 

[umina panther]

We can only hope.

Be hilarious if Cronk turns to shit and Pearce has a career best season.

Both are the same level player imo

 

[franklin2323]

Both are the same level player imo

Look at the Storm record without Smith.. Cronk isn't getting that space at Roosters. At 34 not going to be easy

 

[franklin2323]

100%.

We need an eye to next year. I wouldn't have him in the centres even in NSW Cup. We need our fringe guys getting better... He does have a place on the bench though. Bench or not playing at all would be my option

 

[mxlegend99]

Look at the Storm record without Smith.. Cronk isn't getting that space at Roosters. At 34 not going to be easy

Jake Friend is a lot better than any backup Storm hooker though.

 

[Luke Bowden]

Your argument for any reason put forward is making up what people were/are thinking.

You did the same thing in the Sharks forum when the Sharks fans thought Moylan would get an early release.

Fact is no one knows any of those things. We're all taking guesses basically at what's motivating these people.

Moylan didn’t even know until the day it was announced.

Stop jumping at shadows and enjoy the football.

The glass isn’t always half empty!

 

[mxlegend99]

Moylan didn’t even know until the day it was announced.

Stop jumping at shadows and enjoy the football.

The glass isn’t always half empty!

Right. So Gus, his manager and the Sharks all negotiated it behind his back and told him the day it was announced.

Oh and the media somehow knew but the guy central to it all had no idea.

 

[Aliceinwonderland]

Right. So Gus, his manager and the Sharks all negotiated it behind his back and told him the day it was announced.

Maybe he has the memory of a goldfish then