Round 14 v Silvertails

[The yak]

I hope we get Garner and Huth back. I doubt Moses plays.

 

[Iamback]

I hope we get Garner and Huth back. I doubt Moses plays.

Huth was 11 days due to HIA. So he should be right

 

[ColdWetPanther]

If this week didn't shake it nothing will.

I didn’t think Tago was that bad this week. Outside of the two drops what did he do so badly?

 

[age.s]

I didn’t think Tago was that bad this week. Outside of the two drops what did he do so badly?

I feel like this most weeks, but he did pretty much nothing except drop the ball. Lack of involvement isn't all his fault, but when you don't do anything but drop the ball in a game like that you deserve a bit of stick.

That said, the criticism of his is hugely hyperbolic on the whole.

 

[ColdWetPanther]

Panic button can't be pressed.

Further spine changes would be a mistake. We need to be realistic and let the combinations continue to build.

Other results over the weekend definitely provided some perspective on how tough Origin is. I agree with you comment below about not backing up also.

 

[Bred not Bought]

I didn’t think Tago was that bad this week. Outside of the two drops what did he do so badly?

Gave away 2 dumb penalties too.

He either has the dropsies or gives away dumb penalties each game.
Then there is the lazy shirt grabbing.

It really is low rubbish he should be getting out of his game.
For someone that deep reflects on himself. Lapses of concentration shouldn't be an issue.

 

[murraymob]

I didn’t think Tago was that bad this week. Outside of the two drops what did he do so badly?

Pretend to play the ball

 

[Iamback]

Gave away 2 dumb penalties too.

He either has the dropsies or gives away dumb penalties each game.
Then there is the lazy shirt grabbing.

It really is low rubbish he should be getting out of his game.
For someone that deep reflects on himself. Lapses of concentration shouldn't be an issue.

It was the timing of them for me. Down 12-10 we finally got the ball back. 2nd tackle knock on

We defended that. Got a roll on at the halfway 3rd tackle knock on any chance to build some pressure was gone.

followed that up with a penalty that set

 

[YoungPanther]

Huth was 11 days due to HIA. So he should be right

Sat behind him on Saturday and he said he would be playing this week.

 

[Panfa]

Is patea available to play 1st grade,he would be a weapon off the bench. Strong runner with a great offload on him.He would be great for 2nd phase,on the weekend there were 3 blokes on him and he still managed to get the ball away strong kid.

 

[The yak]

Is patea available to play 1st grade,he would be a weapon off the bench. Strong runner with a great offload on him.He would be great for 2nd phase,on the weekend there were 3 blokes on him and he still managed to get the ball away strong kid.

He was promoted to the top 30 according to Zero Tackle

Luron Patea will remain at Penrith on a long-term deal until the end of the 2027 NRL season and will also be part of the club's Top 30 roster for the remainder of this season.

Panthers promote young prop to Top 30, extend contract

He is a U19s NSW Blues representative.

www.zerotackle.com

 

[Iamback]

After Round 11 anyone can play in NRL regardless of their contract

 

[Iamback]

Sat behind him on Saturday and he said he would be playing this week.

He didn't seem that bad no surprise. Those who are out cold are the ones that have longer out

 

[Fangs]

After Round 11 anyone can play in NRL regardless of their contract

@murraymob

 

[The Realist]

I feel like this most weeks, but he did pretty much nothing except drop the ball. Lack of involvement isn't all his fault, but when you don't do anything but drop the ball in a game like that you deserve a bit of stick.

That said, the criticism of his is hugely hyperbolic on the whole.

I agree with that sentiment. He was making some tough carries and decent yardage with them. However if you have a couple of howlers, you better make up for them with some brilliance.

The problem is the howlers are there (and more frequent) but the brilliance is gone.

That awful Play the Ball 3 metres off our own line is what I am betting most people remember from him in that game.

 

[ColdWetPanther]

I agree with that sentiment. He was making some tough carries and decent yardage with them. However if you have a couple of howlers, you better make up for them with some brilliance.

The problem is the howlers are there (and more frequent) but the brilliance is gone.

That awful Play the Ball 3 metres off our own line is what I am betting most people remember from him in that game.

Don’t get me wrong, horrible moment.

 

[Aliceinwonderland]

Don’t get me wrong, horrible moment.

To quote one of my favourite comedians.....who are we hating on this week ?

ME ?

 

[Aliceinwonderland]

 

[Whino]

To quote one of my favourite comedians.....who are we hating on this week ?

Manly. Scum and I want to beat them.

 

[Aliceinwonderland]

Manly. Scum and I want to beat them.

I was referring to individual Penrith players that some folks 'get a set against'.

It was an attempt to be slightly lighthearted.