- Messages
- 19,764
Idris is the Panthers equivalent to Tony Williams.
Idris has a good dig. His timing is a bit off, but you can't fault his effort. When he clicks he will be a weapon.
Idris is the Panthers equivalent to Tony Williams.
Latimore, Plum > Grant, McKendry, Kite in current form
Soward is paralyzed under pressure and that's admittedly a big problem (but not our only one). We signed a pretty one dimensional front row because they had a pretty simple job: make room for Soward. They haven't been performing. Mansour and Idris make more meters than our props :crazy:
Get that foundation right and we can build from there.
Taylor is capable of being pretty handy but needs to step up, Brown is alright on his feet when he's not giving away penalties, and Docker has been nothing but dependable. Kingston needs to go though. Manu and Idris need to do a lot more too.
When we're not making meters, Mansour is important; when we are, perhaps we look at some more spark out wide? He's such a talented player, but I feel like, in an ideal team, your meters aren't coming from your wingers - your points are.
Alternatively, maybe down the track Idris plays 2nd row (he's playing like a forward anyway) and we chuck some speed in the centre. Something to keep the opposition in two minds.
We're doing well at everything except for scoring points. :sarcasm:
Look at our halves... Neither run the ball. No forwards can do anything. We don't give the ball to Idris enough.
Who disagreed with you on Mansour's defence?
But that the problem - one one hand, you identify that obviously scoring points is a problem, on the other you are all keen and eager to keep all three of Brown, Docker and Taylor. I don't get that.
On a night like tonight our offensive was crying out for a line breaker and that could have been Tyronne Peachy. Docker, Taylor and Brown and all similar weights to the likes of Tyronne but none of the abovementioned three have the line breaking ability he possesses and that is largely where we fell down. No one on field to spark something out of nothing which surely you need on a night like tonight in poor wet conditions. We need to reconsider our whole attacking offensive structure.
Not by me. I love his enthusiasm, but lets face it, he has shit hands and is crap in defence. He comes in too often,Yet I mentioned him as a defensive liabilty & was caned... Well add that to the list.
I thought Soward had a pretty good game in the conditions. We were clearly under instructions to keep it simple and kick well. Soward did his part. Got us a ton of repeat sets which should have generated the pressure needed for points.
We just had so little impact in the middle. Manu was the only one in the pack who ever came close to breaking a tackle. Never felt like we ever had Souffs on the back foot, even when we were on their line it felt like we'd have to throw it around to have a chance of getting through.
Still think we were a little bit too conservative. Having a few passes sticking through the hands was the only way we were going to score points, so why not give it a go?
I can't agree with this. Idris actually rolls his sleeves up and takes the ball up, he doesn't miss many tackles or make many mistakes.Idris is the Panthers equivalent to Tony Williams.