Rumoured & Confirmed Signings - Part 5

[MugaB]

I put $50 on Parra for spoon. I got $32 so I need Tigers to learn how to tackle

We could lend them a few players, (ala Harry Grant at the tigers style), just until the seasons over, it could also work as good punishment for our players to never cross Ivan, or he'll send you to tigertown

 

[Iamback]

We could lend them a few players, (ala Harry Grant at the tigers style), just until the seasons over, it could also work as good punishment for our players to never cross Ivan, or he'll send you to tigertown

As shit as Tago has been, He'd still be the best player on their roster even in current form

 

[Chins get the wins]

As shit as Tago has been, He'd still be the best player on their roster even in current form

How dare you do Api like that!

 

[BossleyPanther]

If you could bring 1 player back between Spencer or Crichton who would you bring back?

 

[Westernised Panther]

If you could bring 1 player back between Spencer or Crichton who would you bring back?

Tough question.

I’d go with Crichton, based on the fact that centres is our weak area, given than Tago isn’t firing on all cylinders at this point.

 

[Munky]

Critta easily.

Spencer doubles the momentum of whichever team has the ball.

Rolls over the opposition hooker and utility with ease. Absolutely horrible for his ruck defence and leaves a load of space in behind.

A good chance we only have one premiership without Critta's clutch plays in the 2021 finals series and 2023 GF.

 

[age.s]

How dare you do Api like that!

Apis been rocks and diamonds at best this year.

 

[Chins get the wins]

Apis been rocks and diamonds at best this year.

No he's been fantastic but it's f**king hard when you are in such a bad side

 

[soc123_au]

If you could bring 1 player back between Spencer or Crichton who would you bring back?

Critta and it's not even close. Spencer is a luxury, a nice one of you can afford it, but Critta will win you more games.

 

[Chins get the wins]

Critta and it's not even close. Spencer is a luxury, a nice one of you can afford it, but Critta will win you more games.

Choosing to give Tago the big bucks over Critter isn't looking smart

 

[soc123_au]

Choosing to give Tago the big bucks over Critter isn't looking smart

Mostly came down to bad timing I think. It looks terrible looking back though.

 

[Chins get the wins]

Mostly came down to bad timing I think. It looks terrible looking back though.

Club got greedy and tried to keep too many. If they pick either Critter or Luai we keep the one we want

 

[BxTom]

Critta and it's not even close. Spencer is a luxury, a nice one of you can afford it, but Critta will win you more games.

Also to be consider is the fact that Spencer can be hard to control.

 

[Whino]

If you could bring 1 player back between Spencer or Crichton who would you bring back?

Crichton every day of the week and twice on Sundays.

He is a proven match winner and his peak is still to come. It shits me he is no longer a Panther.

 

[GowersDallyM]

Choosing to give Tago the big bucks over Critter isn't looking smart

It's a tough one.. Tago is still very young and raw plus has the ability to play backrow at a pinch, he is on what 600k over the next few years whilst the dogs paid what 800k minimum for Critter!

Critters value has absolutely sky rocketed after this season with how the dogs and going and how Nsw went so if he continues his worth will be 1mill maybe even 1.2? Could we afford to keep him longer than say 3 years? Definitely not if our young blokes all turn into guns which is happening so you need money to keep them.

Yeah we lost gun players and even star players but we've managed to keep probably the best 1, 7, 13 in the game for probably all their careers. You can't keep a centre on 1mill a year in this team.

 

[BossleyPanther]

Yes most of you say a though one, it's true. Both have something very different to offer and last night's game had me torn.

Glad original is over and hope it's only 2 weeks for Dylan.

 

[Vic Mackey]

Announced that Penrith have signed our jnr backrower Zak Clarke, not sure what type of deal. Hes ok, bit small but has some has skill. Maybe Penrith can do something with him.

 

[soc123_au]

It's a tough one.. Tago is still very young and raw plus has the ability to play backrow at a pinch, he is on what 600k over the next few years whilst the dogs paid what 800k minimum for Critter!

Critters value has absolutely sky rocketed after this season with how the dogs and going and how Nsw went so if he continues his worth will be 1mill maybe even 1.2? Could we afford to keep him longer than say 3 years? Definitely not if our young blokes all turn into guns which is happening so you need money to keep them.

Yeah we lost gun players and even star players but we've managed to keep probably the best 1, 7, 13 in the game for probably all their careers. You can't keep a centre on 1mill a year in this team.

The point is we probably could have kept Critta on Tago's money if the timing had worked out. What happens with the next contract is neither here nor there. Dollars wise it hasn't worked for Critta ether, if he had extended for a year and was negotiating now he would be commanding more than what he is getting from the Dogs.

It's all just speculation though on how it would have worked out. The main thing is if we could turn back the clock with hindsight, do you keep Tago at his current contract, or let him walk if you could keep Critta for the same give or take 10 to 15%.

 

[soc123_au]

Announced that Penrith have signed our jnr backrower Zak Clarke, not sure what type of deal. Hes ok, bit small but has some has skill. Maybe Penrith can do something with him.

If he turns out to be somewhere near Garner I'll be happy.

 

[soc123_au]

Also @Vic Mackey you would have been harder than the Pope at a Wiggles concert watching your new 7 last night I imagine? Great to see him silencing the haters.