What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Rumoured / Confirmed Signings

Chimp

Bench
Messages
2,888
I guess as a Sharks fan you are only going to see it this way.
Im with the media on this one though, he’s a good signing for dragons and at great value and a loss for Sharks who I’m sure would have loved to keep him if they had the cap space.
The risk isn’t ours IMO, the risk is with the Sharks letting him go in favour of Kennedy, Trindle and Hynes.
$500k seems like quite big overs to me, especially when you consider the reports that Hunt is getting $550/$600k at the donkeys and Tricky signed with us for $650k.
DA did very well for us in his limited games, but he hardly controlled the team. If you look at things objectively and based on actual facts, there’s no evidence to suggest he can play well week in, week out - he’s never been a regular starter. And whilst he played well as a stand in, once we had a fully fit squad, he didn’t make the 17.
Forget the name or the club, $500k for any player that can’t make the top 17 at another NRL club is a big gamble.
 
  • Like
Reactions: PJ

bubs

Juniors
Messages
922
Have The Queens figured out how to spell their own team's name on their jersey yet?
That;s probably a highish priority.
 

PJ

First Grade
Messages
6,060
Have The Queens figured out how to spell their own team's name on their jersey yet?
That;s probably a highish priority.

Why, most of the morons can't read so they won't know the difference.
 

PJ

First Grade
Messages
6,060
I wonder where Flanno is expecting Atkinson to fit in.

Just signed Gutherson so not fullback.

Handbrake hijo is at 5/8 and he won't be dropped.

Just signed Illias for halfback, so not there either.

So is he going to be a benchie? I like Atkinson and hope he kicks on, seems a decent player but I will be interested to see what his role is.

To me this has a bit of Flanno wanting a name signing and also wanting to think he has hurt the Sharks.
 

Eion

First Grade
Messages
8,034
I honestly don't think $500k is a bad buy for 3 years. Yeah it is on potential but his mentality towards the game is pretty good.
If he can overcome his glaring weakness then he could be a really good player. We'll see if they are working with him on that over the off season.
Tend to agree. $500k for 3 years was too much for us for a likely reserve half and sometimes benchie. For the goons it’s probably worth the risk, hoping he can elevate to a gun half. With DAs attitude he’ll always be worth a squad spot somewhere, so can be offloaded if needed.

But I don’t see him as a week in week out top flight half unfortunately. His passing game in particular needs a lot of work, but good luck to him, seems like a good kid. The deal works for everyone.
 

Eion

First Grade
Messages
8,034
I wonder where Flanno is expecting Atkinson to fit in.

Just signed Gutherson so not fullback.

Handbrake hijo is at 5/8 and he won't be dropped.

Just signed Illias for halfback, so not there either.

So is he going to be a benchie? I like Atkinson and hope he kicks on, seems a decent player but I will be interested to see what his role is.

To me this has a bit of Flanno wanting a name signing and also wanting to think he has hurt the Sharks.
Maybe with the weight gain for Jnr, flange has designs on him moving into hooker when cooky finishes. Then DA to 6.
 
  • Like
Reactions: PJ

Crush

Coach
Messages
11,495
$500k seems like quite big overs to me, especially when you consider the reports that Hunt is getting $550/$600k at the donkeys and Tricky signed with us for $650k.
DA did very well for us in his limited games, but he hardly controlled the team. If you look at things objectively and based on actual facts, there’s no evidence to suggest he can play well week in, week out - he’s never been a regular starter. And whilst he played well as a stand in, once we had a fully fit squad, he didn’t make the 17.
Forget the name or the club, $500k for any player that can’t make the top 17 at another NRL club is a big gamble.
He wasn’t getting a start in a top 4 team so goes to a bottom 8 team to get a start, not the first time, won’t be the last.
Let’s see how he goes, as a dragons fan, I’m happy with it.
 

DJDL

First Grade
Messages
5,483
$500k seems like quite big overs to me, especially when you consider the reports that Hunt is getting $550/$600k at the donkeys and Tricky signed with us for $650k.
DA did very well for us in his limited games, but he hardly controlled the team. If you look at things objectively and based on actual facts, there’s no evidence to suggest he can play well week in, week out - he’s never been a regular starter. And whilst he played well as a stand in, once we had a fully fit squad, he didn’t make the 17.
Forget the name or the club, $500k for any player that can’t make the top 17 at another NRL club is a big gamble.

This.
 

DJDL

First Grade
Messages
5,483
I wonder where Flanno is expecting Atkinson to fit in.

Just signed Gutherson so not fullback.

Handbrake hijo is at 5/8 and he won't be dropped.

Just signed Illias for halfback, so not there either.

So is he going to be a benchie? I like Atkinson and hope he kicks on, seems a decent player but I will be interested to see what his role is.

To me this has a bit of Flanno wanting a name signing and also wanting to think he has hurt the Sharks.

Handbrake is off contract at the end of 2025.
I dare say they'l be moving him on.

But yes, I had the same thought.
 
  • Like
Reactions: PJ

PJ

First Grade
Messages
6,060
Handbrake is off contract at the end of 2025.
I dare say they'l be moving him on.

But yes, I had the same thought.
Can't see Flanno moving on the handbrake, but re Eion suggestion hooker is probably his best position
 
Messages
15,276
His passing game in particular needs a lot of work
Yep. Especially his left to right, had some real shockers through the season.
Amazing how many "eggspurts" haven't mentioned this. We saw it first hand.
Although it is definitely a problem that can be rectified.
And that is the reason why his top coin at the moment would be $500K, and as to why some think it's overs, plus the fact he has only played a handful of 1st grade games.
 
Last edited:

R-15-3

Bench
Messages
2,912
Atkinson is more a fullback imo but to sign him on $500k when untested at 1 in the top grade is a risk. Shame he wasn’t locked up another year to test him out.
 

Special K

Coach
Messages
19,576
Fantastic news.

We still have so many off contract

Jayden Berrell, Billy Burns, Kade Dykes, Tuku Hau Tapuha, Thomas Hazelton, Mawene Hiroti, Oregon Kaufusi, William Kennedy, Cameron McInnes, Ronaldo Mulitalo, Hohepa Puru, Niwhai Puru, Sam Stonestreet, Teig Wilton

In bold are the ones I would be locking down. I like Hazo but i feel he will get a much bigger offer than say Tuks who could give us similar output.
 

fizman

Bench
Messages
3,506
Maybe with the weight gain for Jnr, flange has designs on him moving into hooker when cooky finishes. Then DA to 6.
Spot on Eion, Flanno said it was always the plan to play Junior at Hooker. It all changed when the young bloke got sacked so Junior had to play in the Halves.

1. Gutho
6. Atko
7. Illias
9. Someone/ Junior

If they remain healthy, I can see them making the 8 next season.
 
Top