Boyd is priority for me.
As far as "game-winning" talent goes, Boyd has more in his little finger than Kade. Kade is on his way to being the best forward in League, but the Sharks have "the best Front Row" in football, and look at where they are.
Add to that, we have Bennett coming on board, we do not NEED a 5 star prop. WB could make me a SOO prop if he wanted.
Guys like Boyd dont come along very often. We will forever regret missing out on him if he ends up at the Titans.
CLARIFICATION: The above in no way implies that I am against signing Kade Snowden, quite the opposite in fact. But a Front rower isnt going to win you a competition on his own.
all fair points, there is a good chance Bennett can find cheaper options to do the job up front, or make more of our own options. they obviously wouldn't be as incredible as Snowy, but honest toilers no doubt. there's a good chance we could pocket the Boyd money and Bennett might make a Boyd out of one of the talents we have now. the truth is that we can sort of answer anything with "Bennett waves his magic wand". it's almost our new deus ex machina for premiership success... except it's probably not that contrived, because we know he's going to do it in at least some areas. i didn't think i would be before we signed him, but i'm a little concerned about the expectation around Bennett - my own included. the higher the expectation, the further the fall.
still, i expect us to be competing for the trophy within the next year or 2. i trust Bennett, but i'm wary. there's something about things being too good to be true at the moment... but Bennett will need to bring some troops with him. i'll be pretty bloody disappointed if we end up with a bunch of fringeys like every other year. i'm sure Bennett will be able to get value out of them, but geez it'd have to be a bit of a failure if we don't get a big name this time. i'd still take Snowy first, i'm a big believer in having a big, strong pack of forwards that does plenty of work on both sides of the ball... and i'd probably set aside a big paycheque for at least one of them. i also think our roster can compete for premierships without Boyd, but not without a strengthening of the pack. all of this, and of course i just really want Snowy home. i honestly can't see him being anything less than
the prop of the current generation that's starting to blossom, and he should be playing at home.