What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Rumours and Stuff

Poupou Escobar

Post Whore
Messages
91,124
I don't think you can get and keep the type of playing roster you mention without getting the admin side right. Just like Melbourne, Roosters and Brisbane have.
This is the point. Merkins can see that we need better management, but they think that just means replacing the coach. The fact is there is a whole bunch of other 'management' functions that these other clubs have that we don't, and I don't think it's in the club's power to get them. Can we get well-connected board members who love the club? Can we get wealthy fans happy to divert profits from their companies into 'legit' TPAs for our players? Can we compete for the best CEOs, heads of football or coaches? IMO if we could we already would have.
 

hindy111

Post Whore
Messages
62,867
This is the point. Merkins can see that we need better management, but they think that just means replacing the coach. The fact is there is a whole bunch of other 'management' functions that these other clubs have that we don't, and I don't think it's in the club's power to get them. Can we get well-connected board members who love the club? Can we get wealthy fans happy to divert profits from their companies into 'legit' TPAs for our players? Can we compete for the best CEOs, heads of football or coaches? IMO if we could we already would have.


Who signed

Watmough,Foran,MJ,Moses and extended Norman. I wont use Evans as he isnt really a big money signing. Ore then likely a 300-350k who plays like a 150-200k and had 1 season so still hope.

The others on I guess well over 700k. Of all of them why does BA want gone prior to contract up. Does it represent 5 mistakes?
Sure you can bounce guys who where a success like Brown or Gutho, but they where low risk. We signed heaps of those just like Frank,Matagi etc.Some worked some didnt......

Id also throw in Hoffman however he may only be on 250k so not terrible. Still to much for a Wenty player as is Evans.

Of the 5 big guns BA wants all gone prior to end of contract. Thats 5 big mistakes whoever signed them.

Being generous with Hoff and Evans.
 

hindy111

Post Whore
Messages
62,867
I just feel none of BA big signings did much. Beau Scott was another but atleast he finished his contract and had 1 good year out of 3. His 2nd was average and this season was the super top up year.

Someone is signing these guys so whoever is needs to be accountable.
 

emjaycee

Coach
Messages
13,811
Who signed

Watmough,Foran,MJ,Moses and extended Norman. I wont use Evans as he isnt really a big money signing. Ore then likely a 300-350k who plays like a 150-200k and had 1 season so still hope.

The others on I guess well over 700k. Of all of them why does BA want gone prior to contract up. Does it represent 5 mistakes?
Sure you can bounce guys who where a success like Brown or Gutho, but they where low risk. We signed heaps of those just like Frank,Matagi etc.Some worked some didnt......

Id also throw in Hoffman however he may only be on 250k so not terrible. Still to much for a Wenty player as is Evans.

Of the 5 big guns BA wants all gone prior to end of contract. Thats 5 big mistakes whoever signed them.

Being generous with Hoff and Evans.
Not sure blaming Foran's meltdown on BA is fair. Better to blame one of his former Manly team mates.
 

emjaycee

Coach
Messages
13,811
This is the point. Merkins can see that we need better management, but they think that just means replacing the coach. The fact is there is a whole bunch of other 'management' functions that these other clubs have that we don't, and I don't think it's in the club's power to get them. Can we get well-connected board members who love the club? Can we get wealthy fans happy to divert profits from their companies into 'legit' TPAs for our players? Can we compete for the best CEOs, heads of football or coaches? IMO if we could we already would have.
We could have at any time since DF was booted out . The problem is that everyone who could have done something about it was there for the wrong reasons. Now at least we have a board of professionals who aren't hooked on the smell of linament.
 

hindy111

Post Whore
Messages
62,867
Someone amswer my question. Who signed these guys? And why do they end up not wanting them before contracts up? All I am asking.

I wasn't dissapointed with Moses, but at sametime I want to keep him and Norman next season. I feel its silly to shop them around.
 

emjaycee

Coach
Messages
13,811
Or maybe it is simply a matter of getting closer to the final roster and then announcing it, instead of drip feeding it out there.

Especially when there are players that may be re-signed if no better alternative is found.
 

emjaycee

Coach
Messages
13,811
Someone amswer my question. Who signed these guys? And why do they end up not wanting them before contracts up? All I am asking.

I wasn't dissapointed with Moses, but at sametime I want to keep him and Norman next season. I feel its silly to shop them around.
You try answering them and then tell us what the answers are mate.
 

Latest posts

Top