I've never been more pessimistic about a season than this one. Don't get me wrong I love this team and hope they surprise me but I can't see it happening. We have gaping holes in our entire squad. As a mate of mine recently said we will start off quite spirited but be pulverised by seasons end.
If we come last again, I don't care if every player except Gutherson and Nathan Brown leave.
I can see the season going two ways. Like you described but also they could come good and surprise us all and nudge the 8. I think a couple of things will determine the end result. One Moses and can he deliver a full good consistent season? If he does, then the hard work and toil of the forwards will count for something and create more confidence and enthusiasm that the whole team will feed off which will then create a "we can win games" attitude no matter who they are playing or what the circumstance.
Unfortunately no matter what he says out loud and to the press, I always feel it doesn't really matter, his form still ends up being yoyo like. But if he does have a big season, big if, then D. Brown in particular will also get to grow into the NRL without being hammered and pressured into trying to hard and over playing his hand to try and get a shit team to fire and all the other players will put in more of the little things knowing that it won't be for nought.
The way I see it, we have a good enough team to actually make the 8, as long as Moses can have a great season.
And, which brings me to my second point, injuries. Long injuries to Moses or a couple of our bigger forwards will also derail our season. So lets see what happens. It's very exciting.