What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Rumours and Stuff

lingard

Coach
Messages
11,439
And Sean Russell is my favourite up and coming player. He reminds me of a young Brett Kenny.
I remember the first time I ever saw Brett Kenny play - I think it was his first grade debut - at Cumberland Oval. He played outside centre, with Cronin inside centre. Towards the end of the game I said to my father, "This bloke will play for Australia one day". My father kind of looked at me, but didn't disagree; he just said, "He's pretty good, alright".
 
Messages
17,663
I remember the first time I ever saw Brett Kenny play - I think it was his first grade debut - at Cumberland Oval. He played outside centre, with Cronin inside centre. Towards the end of the game I said to my father, "This bloke will play for Australia one day". My father kind of looked at me, but didn't disagree; he just said, "He's pretty good, alright".
Russell has certainly got the same effortless running style.
 

Poupou Escobar

Post Whore
Messages
92,372
Was his defence poor on the edge? I seem to recall our left edge defence being quite good. We certainly won a lot of games when he was on the edge.
The good teams all carved us up - out wide - when he was defending on the edge. Why do you think he was moved back to the middle?
 

Poupou Escobar

Post Whore
Messages
92,372
Penisini wasn’t carving up as part of the first grade squad like Papali’i or Sam Walker were at the time he was re-signed. I don’t understand your position either. Are you saying we should re-sign players early or not? If we should wait until they’ve proven they didn’t fluke half a season then the “experts” at the Eels shouldn’t have re-signed Penisini and the Roosters shouldn’t have re-signed Sam Walker and should have waited until they’d proven themselves at the end of their second season.
Penisini and Walker were both off contract when they re-signed (unlike Papali'i who had over 18 months to run on his contract at the start of this year). Walker actually re-signed in May, and had been free to negotiate with other clubs for almost six months ffs. Neither player re-signed as early as you think Papali'i should have been locked up. You'll also note neither Penisini nor Walker signed long term extensions, though no doubt their clubs would have preferred that they did. In fact Robinson said here that he wanted Walker retained for 10 years but the player's management knew it wasn't in his best interest to sign too long too early: https://www.nrl.com/news/2021/05/13/walker-re-signs-with-roosters-until-end-of-2023/

Walker is just lucky that he has good advisors (unlike Papali'i) who won't let him go to a club that will tank his career AND also won't let him commit long term to unders. Maybe Papali'i's advisors only had that on their mind?
 

yy_cheng

Coach
Messages
18,734
Penisini and Walker were both off contract when they re-signed (unlike Papali'i who had over 18 months to run on his contract at the start of this year). Walker actually re-signed in May, and had been free to negotiate with other clubs for almost six months ffs. Neither player re-signed as early as you think Papali'i should have been locked up. You'll also note neither Penisini nor Walker signed long term extensions, though no doubt their clubs would have preferred that they did. In fact Robinson said here that he wanted Walker retained for 10 years but the player's management knew it wasn't in his best interest to sign too long too early: https://www.nrl.com/news/2021/05/13/walker-re-signs-with-roosters-until-end-of-2023/

Walker is just lucky that he has good advisors (unlike Papali'i) who won't let him go to a club that will tank his career AND also won't let him commit long term to unders. Maybe Papali'i's advisors only had that on their mind?
But maybe money was his short term objective to set his mum up so that's why he took it
 

Pazza

First Grade
Messages
9,982
The good teams all carved us up - out wide - when he was defending on the edge. Why do you think he was moved back to the middle?

I remember he was getting carved on the edge towards the end of the year. But i also remember the guy was playing 70 - 80 mins running for 200m per game and carrying a huge load while Cartwright was lucky to get 5mins a game at some points.

BAs use of the bench never seems to be logical
 

Noise

Coach
Messages
18,235
Russel might be a superstar.
Nathan Davis was also rated the best back since Hayne on here.
Tanginoa the best since Hindmarsh.

Till they make it best to keep open mind on them.
You could write an encyclopedia on all the juniors that were going to be superstars that have been mentioned on here.
 

84 Baby

Referee
Messages
29,954
You could write an encyclopedia on all the juniors that were going to be superstars that have been mentioned on here.
But it’s also not like all the players who did make it weren’t also mentioned on here.
Also we’re not the only team in the only sport where promising youngsters fail to turn into superstars
 

Poupou Escobar

Post Whore
Messages
92,372
Too many middles is never enough.
On the other hand, every middle forward looks like a gun when he's running at halfbacks. You only need two edge forwards on the field and the key requirement is that they can defend there. If you really need Paulo or Papali'i running at halves you can put him there in the red zone. He doesn't need to wear 11 or 12, and you certainly don't want him there when the defence is under pressure.
 

Latest posts

Top