What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Rumours and Stuff

Stevie

Bench
Messages
3,198
In hindsight, we shouldn’t jump at shadows after losing a fringe first grader in Dunster (although we all believe he’d become a 1st grader) and a winger at that.

As everyone has said, we can fill with a Opa or Russell who essentially just need to make their tackles, catch the high balls and finish off backline movements.

Waqa and Co will need to step up perhaps to assist rucking it out but they would have anyway with a rookie winger over the course of a game.

The positive is we have a good and very settled halves and spine healthy and ready to go. Sivo will likely be a welcome edition back but we have a great forward pack and settled spine.

Having a fill in wing for a couple months will NOT be an excuse. Oh… and who knows we may just uncover a star?!
 

TheRam

Coach
Messages
13,911
To be fair Naiduki and Komolafe are not anywhere near 1st grade yet.
Russell and Loizou would be in front of them and I'm not a fan of playing Waqa on the wing as left centre is his spot and he was fantastic when he was moved there.
I watched the manly tigers trial and manly have about 6 wingers including Saab and Garrick who look the goods. This Vega character who scored a hat trick is on a train and trial contract was super impressive. They also had a Tupoulitou and the young tearaway Koula I think his name is. They all showed intent and hunger.
We do need another winger.
I think Perham could also do a job there if need be.

I have mentioned this kid a few times on here. He will be a gun and was a player I wish we poached. Won't get the chance to now once he starts playing NRL. Speed, speed, speed and class.
 

Soren Lorenson

First Grade
Messages
7,620
I have mentioned this kid a few times on here. He will be a gun and was a player I wish we poached. Won't get the chance to now once he starts playing NRL. Speed, speed, speed and class.
He already re signed with Manly till end of 2024 a few weeks ago. We may have tried to get him, who knows. He's been with Manly since he was 14.
 

Poupou Escobar

Post Whore
Messages
92,273
In hindsight, we shouldn’t jump at shadows after losing a fringe first grader in Dunster (although we all believe he’d become a 1st grader) and a winger at that.

As everyone has said, we can fill with a Opa or Russell who essentially just need to make their tackles, catch the high balls and finish off backline movements.

Waqa and Co will need to step up perhaps to assist rucking it out but they would have anyway with a rookie winger over the course of a game.

The positive is we have a good and very settled halves and spine healthy and ready to go. Sivo will likely be a welcome edition back but we have a great forward pack and settled spine.

Having a fill in wing for a couple months will NOT be an excuse. Oh… and who knows we may just uncover a star?!
The Inuit word for crisis is the same as their word for opportunity. Meanwhile the silly merkins have 13 different words for snow.
 

Stevie

Bench
Messages
3,198
Dunster ceiling isn't that high. At best he could be an average NRL winger. Russel might even offer more imo.
If we landed Oates or Issako I'd say we are stronger.
With all due respect but how the f**k do you speak with such authority on a young kid who’s played half a season?

Of course we may be stronger with one of two established NRL players for that position straight away but unless you have a crystal ball then you really have nowhere near the certainty in which you spew. Give the kid a chance FFS.
 

Poupou Escobar

Post Whore
Messages
92,273
With all due respect but how the f**k do you speak with such authority on a young kid who’s played half a season?

Of course we may be stronger with one of two established NRL players for that position straight away but unless you have a crystal ball then you really have nowhere near the certainty in which you spew. Give the kid a chance FFS.
It was obviously his opinion. Merkins shouldn't have to start every post with "IMO..."
 
Top