What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Rumours and Stuff

hindy111

Post Whore
Messages
63,536
Reality is.....

We have no x factor

A solid fullback and hooker. Both with below average run games. I'd say both are two of the slowest in their positions. Sure they have other strengths but they kind of just takeaway from our halves as far as kick game and passing.

Our strength is our two start props and halves.

Backlines very average. BLAKE and Penisini are the only quality.And neither are considered for origin. Nearly all 16 sides have 2 quality player in their backline.
Other forwards Lane,Papali,Brown,Matterson,Marata are good players but none are origin level. Kafusi,Makatoa are very average and don't make most teams top 17.

Look at Storm and Panthers and you see x factor and explosiveness.Storms spine and Panthers are both far superior. I agree with Pou that we just don't have that great a squad. It's about no 6 when look at who have in our top 30.

I've said this 10 x you need a 2nd rower capable of busting the line. Last one we had was Manu and KE. Throw in Semi as our x factor. That was our best chance for a title. 2017.

Do I blame BA for poor coaching? No I blame him for putting together a squad with no real explosiveness. We will bash the weak sides and grind against the top ones. Come finals it will most likely be one and done. That's if we make the top 8 which I wouldn't say is a certainty. If we lost one of our props or halves for a long period we would be at beat 50/50
 

Gronk

Moderator
Staff member
Messages
78,082
Reality is.....

We have no x factor

A solid fullback and hooker. Both with below average run games. I'd say both are two of the slowest in their positions. Sure they have other strengths but they kind of just takeaway from our halves as far as kick game and passing.

Our strength is our two start props and halves.

Backlines very average. BLAKE and Penisini are the only quality.And neither are considered for origin. Nearly all 16 sides have 2 quality player in their backline.
Other forwards Lane,Papali,Brown,Matterson,Marata are good players but none are origin level. Kafusi,Makatoa are very average and don't make most teams top 17.

Look at Storm and Panthers and you see x factor and explosiveness.Storms spine and Panthers are both far superior. I agree with Pou that we just don't have that great a squad. It's about no 6 when look at who have in our top 30.

I've said this 10 x you need a 2nd rower capable of busting the line. Last one we had was Manu and KE. Throw in Semi as our x factor. That was our best chance for a title. 2017.

Do I blame BA for poor coaching? No I blame him for putting together a squad with no real explosiveness. We will bash the weak sides and grind against the top ones. Come finals it will most likely be one and done. That's if we make the top 8 which I wouldn't say is a certainty. If we lost one of our props or halves for a long period we would be at beat 50/50
I said in the off season that we need a GOAT, but you can't snap your fingers and one appears. In the meantime you have to play footy and do your best with what you've got (unless you have a salary cap sombrero).
 

84 Baby

Referee
Messages
29,968
Reality is.....

We have no x factor

A solid fullback and hooker. Both with below average run games. I'd say both are two of the slowest in their positions. Sure they have other strengths but they kind of just takeaway from our halves as far as kick game and passing.

Our strength is our two start props and halves.

Backlines very average. BLAKE and Penisini are the only quality.And neither are considered for origin. Nearly all 16 sides have 2 quality player in their backline.
Other forwards Lane,Papali,Brown,Matterson,Marata are good players but none are origin level. Kafusi,Makatoa are very average and don't make most teams top 17.

Look at Storm and Panthers and you see x factor and explosiveness.Storms spine and Panthers are both far superior. I agree with Pou that we just don't have that great a squad. It's about no 6 when look at who have in our top 30.

I've said this 10 x you need a 2nd rower capable of busting the line. Last one we had was Manu and KE. Throw in Semi as our x factor. That was our best chance for a title. 2017.

Do I blame BA for poor coaching? No I blame him for putting together a squad with no real explosiveness. We will bash the weak sides and grind against the top ones. Come finals it will most likely be one and done. That's if we make the top 8 which I wouldn't say is a certainty. If we lost one of our props or halves for a long period we would be at beat 50/50
The reality is…

We need more throwaway lines.
 

emjaycee

Coach
Messages
13,941
Reality is.....

We have no x factor

A solid fullback and hooker. Both with below average run games. I'd say both are two of the slowest in their positions. Sure they have other strengths but they kind of just takeaway from our halves as far as kick game and passing.

Our strength is our two start props and halves.

Backlines very average. BLAKE and Penisini are the only quality.And neither are considered for origin. Nearly all 16 sides have 2 quality player in their backline.
Other forwards Lane,Papali,Brown,Matterson,Marata are good players but none are origin level. Kafusi,Makatoa are very average and don't make most teams top 17.

Look at Storm and Panthers and you see x factor and explosiveness.Storms spine and Panthers are both far superior. I agree with Pou that we just don't have that great a squad. It's about no 6 when look at who have in our top 30.

I've said this 10 x you need a 2nd rower capable of busting the line. Last one we had was Manu and KE. Throw in Semi as our x factor. That was our best chance for a title. 2017.

Do I blame BA for poor coaching? No I blame him for putting together a squad with no real explosiveness. We will bash the weak sides and grind against the top ones. Come finals it will most likely be one and done. That's if we make the top 8 which I wouldn't say is a certainty. If we lost one of our props or halves for a long period we would be at beat 50/50
Are you saying we don't have an awesome squad?
 

Twizzle

Administrator
Staff member
Messages
154,080
we do have a shit load of injuries which is very frustrating, no excuse for the Tigpies game as we had opportunities to win but I want to see our best players on the pitch and we're a long way from being at full strength

not sure I even know what our full strength backline would be right now
 

hindy111

Post Whore
Messages
63,536
we do have a shit load of injuries which is very frustrating, no excuse for the Tigpies game as we had opportunities to win but I want to see our best players on the pitch and we're a long way from being at full strength

not sure I even know what our full strength backline would be right now

Guth,Sivo,Penis,Opacic,Blake if I was to pick it.
Two power house wingers. Two great defensive centres.
 

Twizzle

Administrator
Staff member
Messages
154,080
Guth,Sivo,Penis,Opacic,Blake if I was to pick it.
Two power house wingers. Two great defensive centres.

Sivo, probably not as he refused to defend late last year, lazy prick.

I think Russell is a much better attacking option than Opa, not as good a defender though but he will only get better.

His injury was pretty bad timing as he may have been developing nicely right now
 

yy_cheng

Coach
Messages
18,734
Guth,Sivo,Penis,Opacic,Blake if I was to pick it.
Two power house wingers. Two great defensive centres.
If all fit,

Marata replace oppa i reckon. We can carry
him on the left centre. I just like him on the field more.

I reckon he is a bigger loss than paps next year. Especially that carry over points resets

Paps
Kaufusi
Grieg/maka/bryce
Hayze/rein/Russell
 
Top