What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Rumours and Stuff

King-Gutho94

Coach
Messages
15,927
Now do Sam Walker.

Not comparing. Just saying.
Sam walker is a turnstile but he makes up for his garbage defence by being able to attack setting up tries he plays with more flair, he does some goal kicking along with kicking clutch field goals.

I am surprised Jake hasn't added Goal kicking to his reportire he would be more valuable as a backup if he was. A half-back who are also good goal kickers are gold.
 

Poupou Escobar

Post Whore
Messages
92,076
It has been pretty obvious since Potter took over from Barrett that the Dogs attack has completely changed. They were playing a very conservative style under Barrett, trying to grind a victory which was never going to work.

If nothing else I think the Dogs improvement shows that new ideas and a fresh voice can turn things around. There's obviously a question mark on whether it's sustainable long term but for now they look like they're enjoying a bit of freedom and change of tack...
Everyone's attack looks good against the Knights. We scored 39 points against them with Jake Arthur in the halves ffs
 

King-Gutho94

Coach
Messages
15,927
We're notoriously poor favourites. The more we're the underdog, the better off we will be.
Yep i agree have we lost a game this year where we were underdogs.

I reckon only Melbourne and both Penrith games is where we would have gone in as underdogs. Not many others.
 

JokerEel

Coach
Messages
13,743
Sam walker is a turnstile but he makes up for his garbage defence by being able to attack setting up tries he plays with more flair, he does some goal kicking along with kicking clutch field goals.

I am surprised Jake hasn't added Goal kicking to his reportire he would be more valuable as a backup if he was. A half-back who are also good goal kickers are gold.

Sam Walker doesn't play for the Eels if he did he would be roasted.
 

King-Gutho94

Coach
Messages
15,927
Everyone's attack looks good against the Knights. We scored 39 points against them with Jake Arthur in the halves ffs
Unlike the other night we dead set should have put 50 on Newcastle that day.

They offered no resistance in that 2nd half of that game. 39 points we let them off lightly.
 

Gronk

Moderator
Staff member
Messages
77,903
It’s 2pm 31/7, so hurry the f**k up.

Judge Judy GIF by Lifetime Telly


The journo on ch9 just said that clubs have until 5pm tomorrow.
 

Poupou Escobar

Post Whore
Messages
92,076
You didn’t answer the question. What does Occam’s razor tell you?
It tells me I'm right. What does it tell you?

Honestly, do you even understand how to apply Occam's Razor? It doesn't mean your assumptions are likely correct, because people make different assumptions.
I don’t think we should sack the coach this season if that’s what you’re getting at regarding what “supports my argument”. Does the example demonstrate my belief that the coach has a tangible effect on how the team plays? I think it does.
Of course it does. The question is whether we would be doing better under any given alternate coach.
 

Incorrect

Coach
Messages
12,866
Everyone's attack looks good against the Knights. We scored 39 points against them with Jake Arthur in the halves ffs
I'm not even talking about today's game. Have you actually been watching them play the past 2 months or just looking at scorelines and making assumptions on how they are playing? Go back and watch their game v the Bunnies. They played some awesome attacking footy, just a shame for them they can't defend for shit (a bit like us)....
 

Poupou Escobar

Post Whore
Messages
92,076
Well as I said under Barrett they lost many game by 10 points. Not blown out.
As season went on they also probably gelled a little. But also got to play the 3 weakest sides in comp. The Sharks in Extremely wet conditions. Souths without Cook or Murray.

Yes they flogged us. But they beat better sides earlier in the year.
And them flogging us (which is a data point overweighted by Eels fans) had as much to do with our f**kup as anything Mick 'Supercoach' Potter cooked up.
 

Gronk

Moderator
Staff member
Messages
77,903
Sam Walker has a lot of other strengths that contribute to him being a net positive so the Roosters are willing to wear his poor defence.
Sam walker is a turnstile but he makes up for his garbage defence by being able to attack setting up tries he plays with more flair, he does some goal kicking along with kicking clutch field goals.

I am surprised Jake hasn't added Goal kicking to his reportire he would be more valuable as a backup if he was. A half-back who are also good goal kickers are gold.
LOL I said I wasn’t comparing anything other than a 19 year old half’s defence. But hey, flame away at Jake. I guess my bad for leaving the gate open.
 

hindy111

Post Whore
Messages
63,243
And them flogging us (which is a data point overweighted by Eels fans) had as much to do with our f**kup as anything Mick 'Supercoach' Potter cooked up.

They should be a much better side next year. But they lose two of their better performers over the last 2 mths in JMK and Vaughn. I find it interesting how they will go.
 

Latest posts

Top