No I really don’t understand how a couple of teenagers from SG Ball would be better than the experienced deadshits in reserve grade. They might be going okay in Jersey Flegg but the step up from there to playing against adults is enormous. If they were ready to play against men they would be playing reserve grade, like other Flegg-eligible reserve graders Loizou, Mataele, Brazel, Betham-Misa and your mate AMS. Or like Flegg-eligible first graders Penisini and Russell. Those youngsters you mention might well be better players in the future but we need a Sivo replacement next week ffs.
Dunster and Blake might have played some poor games in first grade but they have also played some great games in first grade.