Rumours and Stuff

[Poupou Escobar]

How good are our starters but?

The question was about our backups.

But our starters are fine. Sivo, Simonsson and Penisini have played in a grand final. Talagi is young but talented.

 

[hindy111]

Brisbane definitely choked. Look at them now.

Herbie,Flegger,Capewell gone. Reynolds hasn't played and Staggs is injured

 

[hindy111]

The question was about our backups.

But our starters are fine. Sivo, Simonsson and Penisini have played in a grand final. Talagi is young but talented.

That's your problem. Our starters aren't fine.
Sivo is done and why we are shopping him. He is lazy. Simmonson is fine but bog average and doesn't make most sides backline.
Penisini is a good young talent. Average season. Blaize is our best but will be a fullback meaning we have space for 3 backs

 

[yy_cheng]

That's your problem. Our starters aren't fine.
Sivo is done and why we are shopping him. He is lazy. Simmonson is fine but bog average and doesn't make most sides backline.
Penisini is a good young talent. Average season. Blaize is our best but will be a fullback meaning we have space for 3 backs

we do have lomax

 

[hindy111]

we do have lomax

I forgot lol.
Lomax,Blaize,Pensini is a good start. I could live with that with Guth and Sivo/Simmonson for a year

 

[84 Baby]

Now let's extend Russel for another 3yrs NOW!!!!

At the right price he’s decent squad filler, heck if he was worst player in top 17, that’d be ok

 

[yy_cheng]

I forgot lol.
Lomax,Blaize,Pensini is a good start. I could live with that with Guth and Sivo/Simmonson for a year

Guth is a hard one.

I still reckon he should be 9 and Hands subbing him from 14.

1. Blaize/Lomax
2. Would love Vinavalu
3. Penisini
4. Blaize/Lomax
5. Sivo/Simmo

Sivo is still good 10m out
With Lomax in the team, he can take one of the hitups that Sivo is shit at.
Sivo usually gets bombed to so he doesn't need to take a 2nd hitup

 

[Joshuatheeel]

Now let's extend Russel for another 3yrs NOW!!!!

that wouId a pretty great outcome. WouIdnt be expensive. Goes ok, but wouIdnt expect to be starter. Gives us much needed depth in the backs for next few years, which we need.

hope it happens

 

[Gronk]

Now let's extend Russel for another 3yrs NOW!!!!

Enough with the silly talk.

 

[Stevie]

Why aren't we able to of wrapped him up?
Why has Penrith wrapped up the Mclean brothers till 2028 and Strom same with Wishart, Faalogo etc?

Who the f**k is running this circus

Ryles has gotta go.

 

[JokerEel]

Right so the Panthers don't have the best talent pool or attract the best juniors from other areas. They just have normal ones and teach them real good.

Are you guys on crack ?

What we don't have the best talent pool either or juniors?

Must be all that crack I am smoking..

Nothing to do with coaching at all ffs

 

[Stevie]

I haven’t been this excited about an appointment since Daniel Anderson took over in 2009.

Ryles will be good for us. I’d be very surprised if he failed.

I’m with you. I think we’ve won the lottery. He’s going to be elite.

 

[hindy111]

that wouId a pretty great outcome. WouIdnt be expensive. Goes ok, but wouIdnt expect to be starter. Gives us much needed depth in the backs for next few years, which we need.

hope it happens

I agree. He is a good back up. If Dunster wasn't for his horiffic injury he also would of been. I have no idea how good AMS or R.Pensini is. Maybe the same level. Russel and d Dunster where hyped up coming thru also

 

[The Predictor]

Maybe you should seek others to agree with you that Moses and Brown have never won us a game vs decent teams.



Disagreeing for the sake of disagreeing ? Twit. I just call out stupid posts.

Your fella troll agrees. must feel good…..something is blossoming

 

[The Predictor]

If you disagree you're a mean girl
Do you want to be labelled a mean girl? If not agree with the twit

Mean Girl!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

 

[King-Gutho94]

Have a look at their record without him compared to their record with him. It's about 20% worse.

Penrith go from winning 85% to 65%.

That's still 16 wins a season on average.

Our record without Gutherson since 2017 is 55% worse. We go from 55% to 0%. 0 wins from 10 games he has missed since 2017.

Our record without Moses since he arrived is 23% worse we go from 56% to 33%. 8 wins from 24.

So going off those facts that's almost double the amount of games Penrith still win on average without Cleary then what we do without Moses.

65% Penrith win without Cleary to 33% Parra win without Moses

 

[Legal Eel]

Yep. Really poor and disingenuous to claim that 2024 finally revealed Arthur's quality as a coach after the highs of 2019-2022.

No 2019-22 was just as instructive.

I believe a better coach would have won a premiership in that span with this squad at its peak.

he was merely adequate - and you are the only one who will read that as a glowing endorsement.

 

[Legal Eel]

No chance. To'o's go forward is so good they prioritised him over Crichton. He would be on huge money, if you include his Keno TPA.

No.

on this one I know he took slight unders to remain in the Penrith system

 

[Hindmarshisgod2]

I’m with you. I think we’ve won the lottery. He’s going to be elite.

Sigh....


Us eel fans are suckers for getting our hopes up......

God I wish your right.

 

[Gronk]

No 2019-22 was just as instructive.

I believe a better coach would have won a premiership in that span with this squad at its peak.

he was merely adequate - and you are the only one who will read that as a glowing endorsement.

If we had a better coach, we would have beaten Storm / Penrith in the 2020 GF or Penrith in one of the 21 or 22 grand finals ?

Ok that's not one I have heard before, as previously many on here claimed we had been overachieving.