Short term, players may say f**k you I’m not playing for Rouse Hill or Wentworthville, but firstly that’s only a chance they leave your junior catchment (I.e. only if they identify that it’s the Eels fault, and guess what it’s not, to the point we’re dead to them that even a 1st grade contract won’t entice them back), secondly being from a shitty club what’s the likelihood those players were much chop anyway, and thirdly even if they were good, how likely are they to make NRL?
On top of that, having less teams forces the good players into same team/grade and that raises the standard.
Plus how many junior clubs do the Roosters have? Melbourne? Heck we have more than grand finalists Souffs. Has maintaining that been beneficial to us?
How many non-Rouse Hill juniors from similar age group to Jrthur, Penisini or Russell are in the mix for NRL? f**ken Penisini will be in our top 17 next year. Do you want to claim we hitched our wagon to the wrong train there?
Finally surely the failing clubs are failing because they aren’t as good. Why do love mediocrity so much?