What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

should we be ticked off with newton

Messages
3,818
i mean..gone one day then sugns with storm the next..well i hope they can teach him to catch ..pass and not bludge in defense..maybe smith saw this and ratted his cage..but he signed with the storm the next day...it if smells fishy..then its fishy as far as i can smell
Not disappointed to lose him tho
 

CJKnight

Juniors
Messages
1,339
Jeez, what's with all the Newton-haters all of a sudden? Some blokes on this forum are so double-minded when it comes to things like this. You guys should be ashamed of yourselves.

Newton was no SBW or Ben Kennedy, but he was there for us week-in, week-out. He was a clubman who held the pack together at times with his leadership and could have been co-captain at anytime. A dangerous gap runner and was Joey's go-to man for a long time. No club could ask for more.
 

Burwood

Bench
Messages
4,977
christopherjon said:
Jeez, what's with all the Newton-haters all of a sudden?

lol, I'm going to have a complete stab in the dark at the reason, and suggest it has something to do with him walking out on the club and re-signing with a rival in the space of 24 hours.

but he was there for us week-in, week-out.

And where is he for us this week?

No club could ask for more.

I hope the club could ask for a player who didn't walk out on them mid season.
 

voltron

Juniors
Messages
1,454
leadership?
ha!
no one really stands up and tries to lead for us.
except our rep players

i dont think they give their 100%
just do wateva
and watch now, he'll do well at the storm
why? cuz he isnt complacent anymore, he knows he has to work harder now because he is no sure thing.
i hope we can give it to him in round 18 when we vs the storm
 

macavity

Referee
Messages
20,638
Pika said:
That is harsh.

yes, perhaps too harsh.

but he has treated the club and its supporters like sh!t the past few days - this whole situation is because he had a massive sook - and the club were dumb enough to grant him an unconditional release.

he deserves no sympathy.
 

Innconu

Juniors
Messages
116
voltron said:
leadership?
ha!
no one really stands up and tries to lead for us.
except our rep players

i dont think they give their 100%
just do wateva
and watch now, he'll do well at the storm
why? cuz he isnt complacent anymore, he knows he has to work harder now because he is no sure thing.
i hope we can give it to him in round 18 when we vs the storm

Well said Voltron

The culture that everyone talks about in Newcastle has been for the past 5 years "I am a local product. I will work hard in juniors to get into FG then I can sit there for the next 10 years and get paid no matter how badly I play."

This is partly due to the reaction of the fans when the club made a hard decision in 2000 not to re-sign Matthew Johns due to cap and age. The backlash scared the club into retaining the locals at all costs. The personel problems were hidden by having the best player in the world running around until his form started to go down then we were exposed in 2004 and 2005.

Smith is going to make those hard decisions again for the good of the club and we as supporters need to give him a chance and see what the results are in the next few seasons. The players at other clubs play for thier spots, but Newcastle players seem to think they receive there spots through geographical birth.

Time for the Knights to become a professional outfit.

Time Clint Newton became a professional.

If you are working as a contractor somewhere you hate you work out your contracted period and then move on. This situation smells very fishy, how do Melbourne get a contract drawn up and presented in one day and so conveniently after they lose two top level forwards. Newcastle should not have given Clint a release from his contract, they should have withheld Clint's payments for not attending is required work and stopped him from playing anywhere else unless he was headed to England.
 

aqua_duck

Coach
Messages
18,629
Lets be honest here, I'm a huge fan of clint newton, but seriously he' done bugger all since 2005 nd hs never sown any leadership or taken any responsiblity when it cae down to the crunch
 

cram

Bench
Messages
3,396
Newton got a serve in the Newcastle Herald this morning from one of the reporters. There was comment about the fact that Wooly is sticking out the year but Newton jumped ship as soon as he could....

Matty Johns was cut from the club however, he still stayed till the final whistle....Shame Newton Shame
 

Gene Krupa

Referee
Messages
20,216
I was thinking of sending in something but when you censored all the swear words out, it was only 6 syllables long!
 

CJKnight

Juniors
Messages
1,339
wtf? Newton left because he couldn't get along with SMITH. Not because he wanted to abandon his team mates. Why should he tuff it out here with Smith and be held back from his future career? This is Smith's fault not Newton's.

This is what Smith does. He does crazy things to change cultures and futures of clubs that make fans pull their hair out. We were asking for this when we offered him the job. So if you don't like it, get used to it. And stop blaming Newton for being put in a position he didn't deserve from the club.
 

keeney

First Grade
Messages
6,640
Shut up CJ, Newton was told he wasn't wanted next year. He had a hissy fit. Plain and simple. If that's Smith's fault, I'll be damned.
 

macavity

Referee
Messages
20,638
christopherjon said:
wtf? Newton left because he couldn't get along with SMITH. Not because he wanted to abandon his team mates. Why should he tuff it out here with Smith and be held back from his future career? This is Smith's fault not Newton's.

This is what Smith does. He does crazy things to change cultures and futures of clubs that make fans pull their hair out. We were asking for this when we offered him the job. So if you don't like it, get used to it. And stop blaming Newton for being put in a position he didn't deserve from the club.

WTF are you on CJ

I have defended you, but seriously, lay off the smack, mkay?

Newton was under contract. Newton was starting for the team. Newton couldnt be guaranteed another contract. Newton spat the dummy and walked out. Stupid Knights management granted him an unconditional release.

It is 110% Newton's fault.
 

Jono078

Referee
Messages
21,201
Newton said Smith was the best tactical and technical coach he's been coached by.

I don't really know where he went wrong with him besides for the fact Smith didnt guarentee him a spot next year.

If that is the case, then it is Newton's fault.
 

Jobdog

Live Update Team
Messages
25,696
CJ, seriously what are you thinking? Or aren't you thinking at all?

As was reported in the Herald today, last week Newton sat alongside Smith at the press conference and they asked him about his future endeavours. He replied that he was fully committed to the cause and that he would like to finish his contract here and if it wasn't meant to be, he would go elsewhere next year. He then went on to say he would be 110% fully committed to the Knights up until the end of this season.

What happened over the next six days reeks of a 5-year-old not getting what they want from the lolly shop so they chuck a hissy fit
 

Latest posts

Top