wow... this thread sure has taken a bit of reading, and now is as good a time as any to enter the debate... starting with some of the key points as summarised below:
goangod said:
millersnose said:
islam is a dogma
homosexuality is a behaviour
So?
The outcome is still the same. An overrepresentation of Muslims in terrorism statistics prompts you to engage in a prolonged campaign to expose the flaw of Islam and educate people about its dangers
Ditto for me and homosexuality.
i disagree with both of you. enough said about this point.
Actually I have - what possible basis do you have for now denying polygamists or people engaged in incest the right to marry? Go on Millers -name one reason why these people shouldnt be entitled to full rights.
the law
You're going to have to do better than that my friend.
The 'law' also says that homosexual marriage is illegal- yet we are changing it because it 'discriminates' on the basis of sexual preference.
Th current law also discriminates on the same grounds against polgamy and incest - i ask again - give me one reason why we shouldnt change it?
yeah, millers, you should no better than using the law as reasoning in a debate about ethics and truth. after all, women and blacks had laws against them too. but i know that's not good enough for goangod.
so i ask you goangod, to consider this. my parents (who are possibly around your age) watched their Soviet classmates being forced to use their right hands because it was believed that being left handed was a choice and was evil. it is not so clear cut with homosexuality because apart from being born with a homosexual preference, heterosexuals, bisexuals and trisexuals (they'll "try" anything) choose to engage in homosexual acts as well.
but anyway, goangod, here is my explanation about polygamy and incest.
polygamy, in my view, can be ok (i might not engage in it myself, but who am i to stop others?). on the other hand, even though the adults in polygamy may appear to be consenting, they may be suffering from whatever it is that makes people join doomsday cults and I suggest this is why it is illegal. one difference between polygamy and homosexuality is that polygomy is always a choice whereas for homosexuals, they are homosexual even though they might prefer not to be.
incest between parents (grandparents) and children is wrong because the child relies on their parents to teach them what is right or wrong and can be influenced into consenting incest (even when they reach adulthood) even though they don't really want to. similar story for brothers/sisters, etc. another issue with incest is that it has medically been proven that inbreeding causes birth defects.
No, actually, its not.
How is it Millers, that nearly every religion and every culture have come up with prohibitions against muder? Against stealing? Against incest?
gut feeling. general consensus. they can often be right, but not under every circumstance. majority rule also has a large part to play.
just as a point of interest, there are very few values that are universal to all religions and cultures. the only one that does appear to be there across the board (satanism excepted) is the golden rule... treat others how you would like to be treated yourself. i think the rule needs a little modification, but it seems to work pretty well as a default.
in terms of the link between homosexuality and pedophilia, you have not proven any causal relationship. you have just provided circumstantial evidence (always wanted to say that). the only place you have tried to establish a causal link was when you said something about homosexuals having a preference for younger partners. if this is correct, does that mean that the younger partner in a homosexual relationship is generally a loser because they didn't get what they wanted?
in terms of the title of this thread, I think something along the lines of "the world's most tolerant nation" would be more appropriate.
the only debate that i think this thread has merited is the one about age of consent, which seems to have been glossed over in favour of "easier" topics to have an opinion on. [/rant]